Islamic protest march planned for Wootton Basset

I'm up for going to Basset on the day of their march with a few mates (and some who are in the army) and kicking the living **** out of them.

PMSL which keyboard you going to take?? Logitech or Microsoft??..i recommend M$ they tend to be more robust and last the distance:D.
 
Isn't the point that they find the exact reverse true, that our parading around and calling these guys heroes for participating in killing a lot of muslims in Afghanistan pretty appauling?

Who sent them there ?

I am teaching you how to such eggs here but British troops do not invade countries off their own backs.

They were sent by the elected government of this country and the decision to invade and use military assets to enforce UK foreign policy rests solely with the government.


Would you not be upset if you'd moved to a primarily muslim country, they were at war with England, killed hundreds of thousands of us then got all upset and had parades in their soldiers honour when they got back?

Quite possibly but then again would I engage in a protest deliberately designed to enflame the situation and would I do this in a particular area where dead troops pass through to be repartiated ? No.


I think both are in pretty poor taste, largely because we're in a pretty disgusting war against a country that has no ability to harm us in any way whatsoever and as for fighting terrorism, just by being there we are INCREASING the numbers of people who will join their cause.

While I disagree with you in poor taste, the foreign policy of the UK leaves a lot to be desired.

They have every right to protest, and while distasteful doing what they planned, so what, life is rather distasteful, as with most protests people couldn't give a flying **** if the protest doesn't irritate someone.

I don't disagree with their right to protest and indeed welcome anyon'e right to do it. I just feel that Wooton Basset is a very inappropriate place to do it.

THe BNP have their right to free speech and so do these guys, I don't like either groups. At least they are trying something, couldn't we force our government to agree to pull out of Afghanistan if the entire country simply protested by not going to work for a day. I don't know a single person aside from some moronic Labour people who are actively destroying this country, who think we should be there where we really are the invaders and frankly our army is murdering people over there.

Which is why I am at a loss as to why protest organisers think this demonstration will have any effect to getting British troops pulled out of Afghanistan ?

If anything, it may encourage support by sheer bloody minded people who will side with patriotism and respect for British dead ? Such a thing is not beyond the realms of possibility.

Why there isn't outrage that we are sending our people over their to murder people is pretty bad, that we seem to ignore everything that happens but mourn the loss of people as they come back, is strange, that we'd get outraged at a group of people fed up with their own people being murdered, is pretty awful.

Killing and murdering are two seperate entities.
 
Who sent them there ?
.....

I wouldn't waste your breath on him, he is a troll who like to stir up emotions with Daily Fail statements and clearly has an agenda against the military. See how he hasn't posted anything else in this thread? Its typical.

Anyway, back on topic, I can wholeheartedly agree with all of your points Von, but do you not wonder that extremists exist to voice the opinions of the moderates who are too afraid of voicing said opinions (and that goes for all groups)

Its a nightmare for the people in the middle (the police) because you will undoubtedly have trouble from the BNP or other groups and this Islam4UK group and have to sit between them while acting fairly and not being seen to be taking sides when you might be feeling bilious at the vile scum bags.

That website is worth reading because this is what people will use as their reason to incite violence against Muslims whether moderate or not.

Personally the protest is designed to cause tension and unrest, why not have it in Bradford or Nottingham?
 
I personally think its an extremely poor choice of setting and timing by the protesters. Wootton Basset is seen by most brits as the central mourning site for soldiers lost in battles in afganistan. To do a protest down the same streets as the funeral parades of our troops is disgustingly disrespectful to the familys of the fallen soldiers and a serious slap in the face to everyone else who actually give a toss about it.
 
I personally think its an extremely poor choice of setting and timing by the protesters. Wootton Basset is seen by most brits as the central mourning site for soldiers lost in battles in afganistan. To do a protest down the same streets as the funeral parades of our troops is disgustingly disrespectful to the familys of the fallen soldiers and a serious slap in the face to everyone else who actually give a toss about it.

Surely that is exactly why it would make it an excellent way to protest if your primary interest was publicity for your cause?
 
There interest should not happen this is the UK it's about time the Mr Brown had balls to to pull us out of the human rights act ect we were ok before that act. Mr Anjem Choudary should be told to shut the #### up or get the #### out.
 
This sounds like standard Islamophobic doctrine. Within Islam the standards they set themselves are for themselves the Quran plainly state the beliefs of Christianity and Judaism are to be protected. Modern Moderate belief doesn't advocate violence against women or anyone in any form. None of my friends who are muslims believe as your friend does. You are making a statement that All Muslims as a race are subject to their religion in a way that has its fallacious basis in extremist and medieval interpretation of the Quran. For the vast majority this is not the case.

You try to disguise an racist view of Islam with words like "unintentional", and portray yourself as a moderate, which I do not think you are.

You are entitled to your view, as is everyone, but at least be honest about it.

Now you're adding the claim that 'Muslim' is a race, on top of your baseless accusations in lieu of counter-argument. Unless you believe that Islam should be restricted to those of the "right" race, you're just talking rubbish. Do you add the idea of racial purity to your Islam? Or are you just pretending to do so in order to make another baseless accusation?

You're a fool as well as an unpleasant and dishonest person.

I very much doubt if your friends who are Muslims are prepared to openly state that the Quran is wrong. It's not a complicated section and doesn't have much scope for interpretation. You're also forgetting that I didn't ask one person only and you can't really be strange enough to believe that a person who would see me tortured to death is my friend. Although she believed that torturing people to death is good for them and there are (and have been in the past) other people with the same religious view. So maybe some people might see it as being friendly.
 
Please prove we're anywhere near becoming an Islamic theocracy in the UK?

Are we? I hadn't noticed. Personally, I'd be surprised if it went that far in my lifetime.

Your other arguments are all very well, but if they were wholly true then the number of Muslims in the world would have increased very little over time. Which is obviously not true. Conversion is allowed, in fact it's welcomed. Also, active support from the majority is not required to rule a country.
 
So why don't the normal everyday Muslims stand up to there own madmen? It never happens

It does, just not enough to make a difference. Which is to be expected - it's not like they have much contact. It also wouldn't have much effect - it's not like the aforementioned madmen are going to say "You're right, I've got it all completely wrong and I'll completely reverse my position" in response.
 
[..]
At no time have I invented anything, just told you what I understand to be your meaning, yet you will not defend those statements so my interpretation stands. You havent offered any real clarification beyond your explanation of your friends belief.

I continue to refuse to defend your statements. I will continue to do so in the future, so you are wasting your time. Your statements are not my statements. I am under no obligation to defend your statements.

For example, you believe that Muslims are all of the same race, whereas I reject the entire concept of race as applied to humanity - the superficial differences are too trivial to warrant seperate classifications. So why would I be obliged to defend your statements about race?
 
That website is just...... WOW.

I know people are saying this is just Islamic extremists, but what do people think will happen if these people acctually manage to get somewhere? Yes i know it will never happen but what if it did?

It could happen. A minority of very determined people have taken control of countries before. The most infamous example would be Germany in the 20s and 30s - most Germans were not Nazis at all, but that didn't stop the Nazis gaining absolute power.

Do you realy think non extremists would help us to stop it from happerning? Or do you think they would sit back and bask in the glory?

I think it would vary from person to person, most ending up in between the two extremes you refer to. As a general rule, most people tend to try to live quietly in whatever circumstances occur. Which is part of the reason why a determined minority can rule, especially if they use violence and fear to suppress opposition.

Seems to me like a lot of islam people just sit back and dont get involved so it all gets plamed on "extremists" dont mean they dont agree with them does it?

Doesn't mean they do, either. Again, I think it varies from person to person.
 
Now you're adding the claim that 'Muslim' is a race, on top of your baseless accusations in lieu of counter-argument. Unless you believe that Islam should be restricted to those of the "right" race, you're just talking rubbish. Do you add the idea of racial purity to your Islam? Or are you just pretending to do so in order to make another baseless accusation?

You're a fool as well as an unpleasant and dishonest person.

I very much doubt if your friends who are Muslims are prepared to openly state that the Quran is wrong. It's not a complicated section and doesn't have much scope for interpretation. You're also forgetting that I didn't ask one person only and you can't really be strange enough to believe that a person who would see me tortured to death is my friend. Although she believed that torturing people to death is good for them and there are (and have been in the past) other people with the same religious view. So maybe some people might see it as being friendly.



I am neither a fool, unpleasant or dishonest. I am not hiding my blatant hatred and bigotry behind semantics and ignorance. One of my friends (a devout muslim) who is sat here with me now, states that how you interpret the Quran is wrong in the first instance. You made statements which can be construed as being bigoted, that you do not see them as such is sad. I pity you I really do.There is no need to give a counter argument to what you are stating as I disagree with the view that Islam is violent and that the majority of Muslims believe that torturing people is good for them as you state again. That is a bigoted view. Other statements you have made since are not so islamophobic which leads me to believe you have absolutely no idea what your own mind is, or you are not educated enough to separate one from the other.

Because you deem it neccessary to insult rather than explain I cannot be bothered with you anymore.
 
I continue to refuse to defend your statements. I will continue to do so in the future, so you are wasting your time. Your statements are not my statements. I am under no obligation to defend your statements.

For example, you believe that Muslims are all of the same race, whereas I reject the entire concept of race as applied to humanity - the superficial differences are too trivial to warrant seperate classifications. So why would I be obliged to defend your statements about race?


All muslims as a group then, semantics.:rolleyes:

As a group you have stated that they all beleive as your friend does. That you rely on such things to defend yourself is truely sad.
 
Now you add hypocrisy to the list, because you've been insulting me since your first reply.

The statements that you made and claimed were mine were bigoted. But they are your statements, not mine.

You are dishonest because you are making statements and claiming I made them. Obviously dishonest. You've just done it again:

[..]the majority of Muslims believe that torturing people is good for them as you state again.

You are a liar.

Can I make it any clearer than that? You are a liar. You have, again and again, made up statement yourself and then claimed I had made those statements. I have not said that the majority of Muslims believe that torturing people is good for them once, let alone more than once ("again").

That is a bigoted view.

Yes, it is. And it's your statement, not mine.

'fool' and 'unpleasant' are more subjective judgements.

I think 'unpleasant' is easily supported - you've made things up in order to make serious baseless accusations against me. That's definitely unpleasant.

'Fool' is harder to support, although I think your assertion that all Muslims are the same race is very foolish.

So, in summary, you are making untrue statements in order to defame me and you're doing it in a forum where every word is recorded. I think that covers dishonesty (the lying), unpleasantness (the defamation) and foolishness (doing it where the truth is recorded, so it's much easier to show what you're doing).
 
Back
Top Bottom