• Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

AMD Fluid Motion "Enable 60fps Movies"

Because it looks like a home movie. Yes, it looks smoother and perhaps clearer, but that's not the be all and end all.
It takes away the atmosphere of the film.

maonayze said:
Putting a sentence in English so us Derps can understand it would help there bud. ;)
Click to expand...

U wot m8?
Is talking vague **** as well as not being able to read part of your 'special' skill set?
 
Apart from it looking smoother and less blur I fail to see home video? It looks like a movie to me..

It's like looking at 30fps game loads blur then look at a 60fps game less blur more smoother.

We don't go around saying console games eek look like home made video lol
 
Uncle Petey said:
Because it looks like a home movie. Yes, it looks smoother and perhaps clearer, but that's not the be all and end all.
It takes away the atmosphere of the film.



U wot m8?
Is talking vague **** as well as not being able to read part of your 'special' skill set?
Click to expand...

No need to be rude dude. I just read it wrong that's all. I got lots of 'special' skills dude, is one of yours abusing people from behind your computer screen? I guess so.
:rolleyes:
 
maonayze said:
I find it amazing how many industry experts we have in this section of the forum and everyone of them an absolute professor in their field ;)....Well done you educated chaps......LOL :D
Click to expand...

Some of us actually have a career in media creating/development...
 
Cyanide said:
Some of us actually have a career in media creating/development...
Click to expand...

Ah, now you said it....

Some of us.

Also depends on what you do in media creation and development.....I am sure it gives you a more knowledgeable insight into all this tech, but does it make you a graphics card engineer, a graphics card driver engineer or a flat panel/Graphics engineer/designer.

It's a shame that we dont have some bonafide engineers in those fields on here to be honest as at least then we could be confident that their opinions were at least based on fact rather than regurgitated speculation.

If YOU are a bonafide engineer in any of these fields please make yourself known......NOW! :p
 
At the end of the day..
Some will love it, others will hate it..
Display calibration some love over done colours, some love perfect colours.
Some like over the top sharpness..... Other hate it completely..
PC gaming motion blur people hate this so much on pc side but I feel most hate it without really understanding what it's really used for..

I never created this thread and wanted everyone to start jumping onto it like it's second coming no.
But it would least help if you tried it before slating it. And again no its not like what TVs have I should know I have tested it.
 
Shanks - I'm glad the thread was created as I did see you mention this Fluid Motion a few weeks ago and couldn't find the post. At least now I can give it a go and see for myself.

At least then I can comment on the actual topic in the OP. :p

cheers dude

:D
 
maonayze said:
Lets be honest here...If Nvidia had done Fluid Motion then they would all have been singing it's praises....good or not. LOL

I find it amazing how many industry experts we have in this section of the forum and everyone of them an absolute professor in their field ;)....Well done you educated chaps......LOL :D
Click to expand...

Nope. I dislike frame interpolation in all its forms, I also dislike any claim that frame interpolation is somehow making 24fps content in to 60fps content.

Some people don't like 60fps content at all, but personally I rely on the content creator to make that choice, what I don't like is trying to force 24fps content to not be, because the end result is rarely good. Trying to cover up the fact that you are trying to use the wrong type of media player for the content is an awkward cludge.
 
andybird123 said:
Nope. I dislike frame interpolation in all its forms, I also dislike any claim that frame interpolation is somehow making 24fps content in to 60fps content.

Some people don't like 60fps content at all, but personally I rely on the content creator to make that choice, what I don't like is trying to force 24fps content to not be, because the end result is rarely good. Trying to cover up the fact that you are trying to use the wrong type of media player for the content is an awkward cludge.
Click to expand...

You know that 24fps content is often not shown at 24fps due to 3:2 or 5:4 pulldown. since the content needs to be synchronised to the tv's refresh rate. But this depends on it your tv supports a refresh rate that is a multiple of 24 or 25, it will then just display each frame twice or three times. So more often than not you are not actually watching the content in 24fps.
 
Last edited:
shankly1985 said:
I never created this thread and wanted everyone to start jumping onto it like it's second coming no.
But it would least help if you tried it before slating it. And again no its not like what TVs have I should know I have tested it.
Click to expand...

I did test it, as I already stated, and it's identical to what modern tv's offer.

It's fine that you like it, but why are you so aggressive about making others like it too?
 
Mauller said:
You know that 24fps content is often not shown at 24fps due to 3:2 or 5:4 pulldown. since the content needs to be synchronised to the tv's refresh rate. But this depends on it your tv supports a refresh rate that is a multiple of 24 or 25, it will then just display each frame twice or three times. So more often than not you are not actually watching the content in 24fps.
Click to expand...

If the TV shows the same frame 2-3 times then it doesnt change the frame, so you only see it change 24 times in a second, so that's 24 different frames per second... What it is not doing is trying to generate additional inter-frames with artefeacts

Yes I understand that TVs don't have a native refresh rate of 24hz, but that doesn't stop them from displaying content at 24fps
 
Last edited:
Kreeeee said:
I did test it, as I already stated, and it's identical to what modern tv's offer.

It's fine that you like it, but why are you so aggressive about making others like it too?
Click to expand...

At what point have I been Aggressive to make other people like it? I been open mouth about it not beeing same has TVs version thats about it...
 
Last edited:
thebennyboy said:
Not sure why people are bickering over this... This is likely to be subjective.
Click to expand...
Agreed on this.

Tried it tonight and while it certainly helped in some cases i couldn't get on with the overall feel.

For example Ratatouille about 17mins in when the scene pans up on the roof then left to right across Paris natively in mpc-be you get 24p juddering (reclock / madvr disabled), with Bluesky @ 60p smooth as butter and in all fairness does look bloody good. The problem is more or less everywhere else not a 'look' i could get on with, the following scene in the chase around the kitchen for example. Tried various films but the Ratatouille scene is easiest to reference.

Not for me but each to their own :)
 
Are there any similar filters that works for nvidia users? Would like to see if this could solve the eye strain i usually gets in action movies.
 
Sh4rkie said:
Agreed on this.

Tried it tonight and while it certainly helped in some cases i couldn't get on with the overall feel.

For example Ratatouille about 17mins in when the scene pans up on the roof then left to right across Paris natively in mpc-be you get 24p juddering (reclock / madvr disabled), with Bluesky @ 60p smooth as butter and in all fairness does look bloody good. The problem is more or less everywhere else not a 'look' i could get on with, the following scene in the chase around the kitchen for example. Tried various films but the Ratatouille scene is easiest to reference.

Not for me but each to their own :)
Click to expand...
I can totally understand why some would can't get on with this for firms, but for me I use it for watching anime.

As anime is animation that are essentially going from one picture to the next for the movements, the frame interpolation works really well and the animations look much more fluid and smooth and pleasing to watch.

Using it for watching firm though it does feel "a bit weird", but that could well be down to being accustomed to watching firms at 24fps for decades.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom