Caicedo fee is a bit desperate which ever way you spin it. He has ended up being more expensive than Bellingham who was your number one target. You have essentially done a Man Utd desperation buy but with an actual good player.
Genuinely not sure I agree with this (and I've had issues with us paying big for players in the past).
If Brighton had said in June that we could have had Caicedo for £60-70m we'd have snapped their hand off. Instead, they asked for more, and we said no. We've now basically received the difference between £60m and what we've actually paid from the sales of Fabinho and Hendo. It's a pretty reasonable net spend for someone of his quality to replace two ageing players. It's even more reasonable when you consider that we got Macallister for £30m.
There's always a huge risk with spending big on a player and on and individual basis I agree that Caicedo is therefore "risky", but as part of this summer's business as a whole we've basically moved from having a pretty cheap summer (given the size of rebuild needed) to having an on expectation summer with some high quality recruitment.
As I said above, I never felt that Jude was what we needed (and I think if you search through my old comments you'll see that, even before we missed out on him). We have a lot of players who can play Jude's role (obviously not to the same quality, but well enough) and have added to that through Macallister for a third of the price. What we did not have was a good 6, and good 6s are incredibly scarce.
The player I do think we missed out on for that role was Tchouameni, and if we'd spent money last year we'd have had a chance. But live and learn. As things stood this summer, spending big on Caicedo was the right move. There's obviously always a risk that a transfer won't come off, but knowing what we know at present I'm happy with it.