The chap does live there, presumably you've been too (I know you've been to the ME)? So surely what he has experienced is a pretty fair account no?
The only real issues that do occur are people that break the laws there. If you're pregnant and not married, don't go to Dubai. Just follow their rules it's not hard. It may go against everything you believe in, but that's just the way it is. I accept their consequences are what we'd consider harsh however.
Unless you're talking about something else?
I don't think it is a fair account, yes I've been there no I haven't lived there. Regardless, objectively the following statement is false: "
be respectfull and youll have no problems."
That is what I'm taking issue with - the only real issues are not just confined to people who actively break the laws/are disrespectful and people can, despite trying to do things correctly, end up breaking laws through no fault of their own.
As I said I'm sure the vast majority of people don't have an issue - however there are very serious issues for a small minority of people that can turn out to be very serious and so it is certainly something to be aware of. I think that people actively denying that/brushing it under the carpet are being incredibly unhelpful as this isn't just a random GD discussion/thread but potentially serves as advice to real people who are planning to go there - that is why I'm taking particular issue with it - I appreciate that I can be pedantic at times but I've got quite strong views that with this sort of thing it is fundamentally wrong to be blasé about it and simply dismiss it as we're talking about something that could have real life consequences for people. I've posted examples/evidence of where things can go wrong so I'm not really seeing that there is much to dispute re: what I've posted - I've been quite clear that for the majority there won't be an issue.
I think I do need to clear up what I feel might be a misunderstanding re: your post above - you state
"If you're pregnant and not married, don't go to Dubai. Just follow their rules it's not hard."
Below is the story I linked to earlier -
key point here is that the woman in question didn't know she was pregnant and went to the Dr because she felt unwell while on holiday there - so in fact your reply for people who want to be super cautious perhaps could to be changed to don't go to Dubai if you're a single female and have had sex in the weeks/months prior to traveling there....
however we can throw some more stories into the mix, you can be arrested and sentenced for extra marital sex if you're raped:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle-east-23381448
A Norwegian woman has spoken out about the 16-month prison sentence she received in Dubai after reporting a rape incident to police.
so in fact perhaps we could just change it to don't go to Dubai if you're female.
I've already mentioned the supercars being abandoned but I'll reiterate - you can (could - law may have change relatively recently)go to prison for being in debt! Redundancy, medical issues etc.. suddenly the school fees, rental contract for your apartment, car etc.. can't be paid - this is more of an issue for ex-pats than holiday makers though and some of this might be insured against if you're employed rather than self employed.
Other laws you can break unintentionally - there was a US man arrested and charged for criticising his employer on Facebook, in post made when he was back on holiday on US soil, not even in the country. Then again you could say that he should have known better than to writing critical posts on social media - which is probably fair. This guy however, I don't think any reasonable person can criticise much, completely unintentionally broke the law by posting a charity appeal on Facebook, seriously!
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle-east-37114401
A 42-year-old man arrested in Dubai for sharing a charity post on his Facebook page has been charged.
Scott Richards, who holds both British and Australian citizenship, promoted a charity drive to buy blankets and tarpaulins for refugees in Afghanistan.
He was held for 22 days then charged with fundraising without permission.
[...]
"His wife is under extreme stress," Mrs Haberfield told the BBC.
"She can only take the clothes to him once a week. She takes him money so that he can buy water and extra food.
[...]
Police confirmed that Mr Richards had used social media to recommend a crowd-funding campaign run by a US charity which works in Afghanistan.
The
crowd-funding campaign seeks $35,000 for "new tarpaulins, blankets, warm clothes and socks, and sleeping bags" for children at the Chahari Qambar refugee camp on the outskirts of Kabul.
More than 100 children froze to death at the camp four years ago.
Mr Richards was arrested at his home on 28 July and has been held at Al Murraqabat Police Station.
Literally all he has done is post a link to a campaign for afghan refugees on Facebook and he got locked up for it! Sure he broke the law but unless you were aware of that law in the first place then you could quite easily break it without having any idea you were doing anything 'wrong'.