Help wanted

Man of Honour
Joined
14 Apr 2017
Posts
3,511
Location
London
Subsequent to the Gove admission of drug use, I’ve been following a discussion on another forum, and contemplating registering, just to chip in, but I’m unsure of some of my facts, and Google hasn’t helped.
Quite a few posters have made a great deal out of Gove possibly lying when applying for an ESTA, and wether or not he could now be denied further entry to the U.S.
I’ve had a multiple entry U.S. visa for ages now, certainly since prior to 9/11, so I’ve never had to complete an ESTA, surely one of the questions can’t be, “have you ever used drugs?” can it?
I can understand the question, “have you ever been convicted for drug use?”
I know that on my visa application, it asked, “have you ever been convicted of a crime of moral turpitude?”, but I don’t recall being asked if I’d ever smoked a doobie.
One poster insists that the U.K. authorities do NOT pass criminal convictions of our citizens to the U.S. authorities, so if you lie on your ESTA, you’ll get a green light to enter the U.S., and won’t be turned around on arrival, saying that he knows a guy who served a 2 years prison sentence in U.K., but goes to the U.S. frequently with no hassle.
This was countered by another poster, who said that a U.S. embassy official told him that if any arrests or convictions were concealed by a hopeful traveller, they would come to light when U.S. immigration typed their name into a computer.
Who’s right, and who’s being negligent with the verité, anyone know?
 
Soldato
Joined
26 Dec 2011
Posts
5,830
Location
City of London
I renewed my ESTA last week and it didn't ask me if I'd ever consumed any drugs. It asks lots of other questions like do you plan on terrorism or genocide or if you have a criminal record.
 
Soldato
Joined
8 Jun 2013
Posts
4,372
"It asks lots of other questions like do you plan on terrorism or genocide or if you have a criminal record."
tricky questions, I bet some people get caught out!
 
Associate
Joined
4 Dec 2009
Posts
518
ESTA Eligibility Question 3
“Have you ever violated any law related to possessing, using, or distributing illegal drugs?”

------
You can get a fine or prison sentence if you:




    • take drugs
    • carry drugs
    • make drugs
    • sell, deal or share drugs (also called ‘supplying’ them)
The penalties depend on the type of drug or substance, the amount you have, and whether you’re also dealing or producing it.

------
Class A- Crack cocaine, cocaine, ecstasy (MDMA), heroin, LSD, magic mushrooms, methadone, methamphetamine (crystal meth) Up to 7 years in prison, an unlimited fine or both Up to life in prison, an unlimited fine or both
-----
He is on film saying "yes i have used cocaine"
-----
As of 2:30pm hes not been arrested or convicted. yet.
 
Man of Honour
OP
Joined
14 Apr 2017
Posts
3,511
Location
London
I renewed my ESTA last week and it didn't ask me if I'd ever consumed any drugs. It asks lots of other questions like do you plan on terrorism or genocide or if you have a criminal record.

While I sincerely appreciate your reply, the thing that I was seeking to establish the truth of, is do the U.K. authorities supply the U.S. with details of convictions, or arrests, i.e. if a person has been convicted of say, punching someone on the nose, or forging cheques, and neglects to mention it on his ESTA application, will it come up on the immigration agent’s computer, when the visitor hands over his passport on arrival in the U.S.?
I reiterate, this isn’t for me, I’ve got nothing to hide, I have a multiple entry U.S. visa.
 
Soldato
Joined
17 Jan 2016
Posts
8,766
Location
Oldham
While I sincerely appreciate your reply, the thing that I was seeking to establish the truth of, is do the U.K. authorities supply the U.S. with details of convictions, or arrests, i.e. if a person has been convicted of say, punching someone on the nose, or forging cheques, and neglects to mention it on his ESTA application, will it come up on the immigration agent’s computer, when the visitor hands over his passport on arrival in the U.S.?
I reiterate, this isn’t for me, I’ve got nothing to hide, I have a multiple entry U.S. visa.

I don't think it does. But if your friend lied saying he hadnt been arrested, cautioned or convicted of a crime and then later on he tried to get a visa to move to the US then I think they ask for a full police record check, so it would come up there. I only know about visas for moving to the US. Not sure if a police record check is required for other visas though.

I'm not sure about the Gove issue. It might be by the letter of the law he didn't lie as if its never been brought to the polices attention then there is no record of it. But it's possible by his own admission recently that they might flag him up about it to ask him some questions.
 
Man of Honour
OP
Joined
14 Apr 2017
Posts
3,511
Location
London
I don't think it does. But if your friend lied saying he hadnt been arrested, cautioned or convicted of a crime and then later on he tried to get a visa to move to the US then I think they ask for a full police record check, so it would come up there. I only know about visas for moving to the US. Not sure if a police record check is required for other visas though.

I'm not sure about the Gove issue. It might be by the letter of the law he didn't lie as if its never been brought to the polices attention then there is no record of it. But it's possible by his own admission recently that they might flag him up about it to ask him some questions.

Thanks Bowdon, my hand to God, there is no “friend” trying to flannel U.S. immigration, nor am I.
The nub of all this is, when Joe Bloggs, U.K. citizen, arrives at U.S. immigration, can the agent type Mr. Bloggs name into his computer, and find Mr. Bloggs criminal record in the U.K.?
I think that he possibly can, others say that there is no such “sharing” between the two countries.
This is all IF Mr. Bloggs had purposely omitted any arrests or convictions on his application.
 
Soldato
Joined
29 Dec 2014
Posts
5,780
Location
Midlands
Thanks Bowdon, my hand to God, there is no “friend” trying to flannel U.S. immigration, nor am I.
The nub of all this is, when Joe Bloggs, U.K. citizen, arrives at U.S. immigration, can the agent type Mr. Bloggs name into his computer, and find Mr. Bloggs criminal record in the U.K.?
I think that he possibly can, others say that there is no such “sharing” between the two countries.
This is all IF Mr. Bloggs had purposely omitted any arrests or convictions on his application.

US immigration don't have routine access to the UK criminal record databases, or the PNC - so no, when you turn up at US passport control they have no information at all on the criminal past of any individual, unless it's really serious and shows up on any of the shared databases (people trafficking, terrorism, etc) which if it did would probably mean you wouldn't have gotten on the plane in the first place.
The only law enforcement database CBP have access too is their own US one (and the Canadian one)

If they suspect something, they can eventually get your PNC record through 'back door channels' but there are hardly any cases of this ever happening, and they'd have to be really suspicious.

The only way US immigration would ever see criminal record information, is if you actually request it from the police via an ACRO certificate and take it to the embassy when you apply for a visa. (which you need to do for immigrant visas)

I know this from speaking to the police, an immigration lawyer, and also reading various freedom of information requests that have been made, as the good old 'crime involving mortal turpitude' question used to cause a lot of problems for people applying for ESTAs (they've changed the question now to something more sensible)
 
Man of Honour
OP
Joined
14 Apr 2017
Posts
3,511
Location
London
US immigration don't have routine access to the UK criminal record databases, or the PNC - so no, when you turn up at US passport control they have no information at all on the criminal past of any individual, unless it's really serious and shows up on any of the shared databases (people trafficking, terrorism, etc) which if it did would probably mean you wouldn't have gotten on the plane in the first place.
The only law enforcement database CBP have access too is their own US one (and the Canadian one)

If they suspect something, they can eventually get your PNC record through 'back door channels' but there are hardly any cases of this ever happening, and they'd have to be really suspicious.

The only way US immigration would ever see criminal record information, is if you actually request it from the police via an ACRO certificate and take it to the embassy when you apply for a visa. (which you need to do for immigrant visas)

I know this from speaking to the police, an immigration lawyer, and also reading various freedom of information requests that have been made, as the good old 'crime involving mortal turpitude' question used to cause a lot of problems for people applying for ESTAs (they've changed the question now to something more sensible)

Thanks for that, very concise and informative, it’s appreciated.
 

mjt

mjt

Soldato
Joined
31 Aug 2007
Posts
20,015
"It asks lots of other questions like do you plan on terrorism or genocide or if you have a criminal record."
tricky questions, I bet some people get caught out!
Before ESTA you had these landing cards which contained similar questions. One that stood out for me was, "Are you, or have you ever, been part of the Nazi German regime", or words to that effect. Surely being a Nazi is a requirement for settling in the USA now, what with good people on both sides..?
 
Associate
Joined
2 Aug 2013
Posts
124
Location
Oxfordshire
I guess travelling to/through the US, the border staff can pull whoever they want to one side to question them further which would no doubt involve electronic background checks especially through ESTA etc. The programmes on the sky channels show what happens. Always makes me laugh when I see those US citizens crossing into Canada assuming Canadian laws are the same as in the US (particularly re drugs and guns).
 
Soldato
Joined
1 Mar 2010
Posts
21,891
One poster insists that the U.K. authorities do NOT pass criminal convictions of our citizens to the U.S. authorities,
even though they don't pass information , information is freely available on court proceeding, so if the USA were just logging that, couldn't they easily make the conenction.
(eg. record - Mr so and so of X town Y street Age Z was convicted of ABC with penalty XYZ)

Boris has admitted possession too, so he would be as culpable as Gove ?
 
Caporegime
Joined
29 Aug 2007
Posts
28,597
Location
Auckland
Subsequent to the Gove admission of drug use, I’ve been following a discussion on another forum, and contemplating registering, just to chip in, but I’m unsure of some of my facts, and Google hasn’t helped.

Just LOL if you think that being right or having a cohesive argument or even informing yourself enough to carry a convincing line of thought bears any weight on the likelihood of literally anyone on the internet paying attention to your opinion in any meaningful way.
 
Soldato
Joined
12 Dec 2003
Posts
10,996
Location
Wiltshire
"It asks lots of other questions like do you plan on terrorism or genocide or if you have a criminal record."
tricky questions, I bet some people get caught out!

They do

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-45678517

Cancer patient Mandie Stevenson had to postpone a bucket list trip to New York after she accidentally labelled herself a terrorist on her visa waiver form.

The online application asked if she was seeking to or had ever engaged in terrorist activities or genocide.

Mandie, from Falkirk, mistakenly answered "yes".
 
Soldato
Joined
8 Jun 2013
Posts
4,372
if the previous thread's idiocy of claiming an unborn child is "life", I guess everyone who's jerked off is guilty of genocide. every sperm is sacred, I think the song said.
 
Soldato
Joined
26 Sep 2007
Posts
4,137
Location
Newcastle
https://www.gov.uk/penalties-drug-possession-dealing

Taking drugs is a criminal offence in the UK.
You cannot take cocaine without being in possesion of it and possesion of cocaine has a maximum 7 year sentence.


That's not the law though, the offences are "possession" and "possession with intent to supply" alongside the obvious production offences.
https://www.cps.gov.uk/legal-guidance/drug-offences#a08

You can't be arrested and charged for having consumed cocaine otherwise you'd find half of your local city could be locked up on an average weekend night out. Of course you can consume drugs without being in possession of it, there's a table in the middle of the room with a line of coke on it, you consume the drug. At which point was it in your possession?
 
Back
Top Bottom