Thread bump because I was waaay behind on watching TGT and only caught up last night
I think its pretty harsh the slating some have given to Clarkson. You may think he was over the top but I don't think you could really call his emotion fake. Also takes some balls to leave that in the show as they could have decided to snip that out in the edit.
Several episodes in this series I've felt that the producers have made some bold moves leaving stuff it that takes the shine off the production but allows you to see their character a bit more and the show is massively better for it.
I think it quite clearly showed that either A) He loves the audience interaction and feels it a huge loss. B) TGT is literally just a few specials from being canned for good. Is it possible that these have already been shot so as far as the trio are concerned it is actually all over?
Anyway, I hope that last episode is a taster of how things are continuing as it was awesome. The specials are always good because they focus on one thing for the whole episode whether it be a country, a particular type of car, a challenge. The 15 minute sectioned magazine feature style doesn't really cut it now nobody cares about current cars beyond "how much per month and how big is the infotainment screen?"