Indestructible brake pads/disk

Caporegime
Joined
20 May 2007
Posts
39,700
Location
Surrey
Coasting in neutral isn't specifically illegal. However, if you had an accident while you were coasting in neutral, then you could be prosecuted for not being in full control of the vehicle.

I wonder how anyone could ever prove you were doing that though (aside from anyone actually in the car testifying against you).
 
Soldato
Joined
14 Sep 2007
Posts
15,660
Location
Limbo
As a mechanic it's scary how quick some people go through brakes. In 12 years I have never worn a set of pads out on a car, it's amazing what a bit of engine braking and reading the road ahead can do :D

My driving instructor advised against engine breaking citing that the stress put on the engine/gears/components and possible subsequent failures is more expensive than simply replacing disks and pads.

In reality, I do one or the other dependent on the circumstances.
 
Soldato
Joined
2 Aug 2012
Posts
7,809
Coasting in neutral isn't specifically illegal. However, if you had an accident while you were coasting in neutral, then you could be prosecuted for not being in full control of the vehicle.

I am sure I recall cars from my younger days that had free wheel gearboxes, IE they effectively disengaged on overrun. Bet they must have been heavy on the brakes mind...
 
Soldato
Joined
18 Aug 2007
Posts
9,710
Location
Liverpool
My driving instructor advised against engine breaking citing that the stress put on the engine/gears/components and possible subsequent failures is more expensive than simply replacing disks and pads.

In reality, I do one or the other dependent on the circumstances.

I'd challenge anyone who says that to show one single solitary car built in the last 50 years that failed, or developed a problem with its engine, from running with the throttle closed for brief periods rather than relying solely on brakes. Unless he drives clog and anchor style (very wearing on components in itself!) then he's also driving off-throttle tens of thousands of times per day, just not for as long as someone who reads the road ahead and uses acceleration sense to vary the vehicle's speed. In fact any modern car's handbook I've read has recommended this over relying solely on brakes.

TL,DR: Nonsense.
 
Soldato
Joined
14 Sep 2007
Posts
15,660
Location
Limbo
I'd challenge anyone who says that to show one single solitary car built in the last 50 years that failed, or developed a problem with its engine, from running with the throttle closed for brief periods rather than relying solely on brakes. Unless he drives clog and anchor style (very wearing on components in itself!) then he's also driving off-throttle tens of thousands of times per day, just not for as long as someone who reads the road ahead and uses acceleration sense to vary the vehicle's speed. In fact any modern car's handbook I've read has recommended this over relying solely on brakes.

TL,DR: Nonsense.

This was 11 years ago and he was in his late fifties, once I started actually driving it became apparent that engine braking is quite handy and it's now a habit I generally can't undo.
 
Soldato
Joined
9 Dec 2009
Posts
5,178
Location
Bristol
I think driving instructors advise their students to do what they think will prolong the life of the car, such as mine telling me to hold in the button when engaging the handbrake to avoid wearing out the ratchet. Who's ever worn out a handbrake ratchet?
 
Caporegime
Joined
23 Dec 2011
Posts
32,918
Location
Northern England
I think driving instructors advise their students to do what they think will prolong the life of the car, such as mine telling me to hold in the button when engaging the handbrake to avoid wearing out the ratchet. Who's ever worn out a handbrake ratchet?


Just had one replaced on one of our trucks today!
 
Soldato
Joined
22 Nov 2006
Posts
23,371
I think driving instructors advise their students to do what they think will prolong the life of the car, such as mine telling me to hold in the button when engaging the handbrake to avoid wearing out the ratchet. Who's ever worn out a handbrake ratchet?

You aren't supposed to press the button when applying the handbrake. If you slip it won't always catch it, I've tried :p
 
Back
Top Bottom