Greta Thunberg

Soldato
Joined
2 Aug 2012
Posts
7,809
You're spouting that Facebook myth again.
So much C02 is good, way too much C02 is bad.


Fred Hoyle made an interesting comment regarding the heat trapping effects of CO2 back in the 1970's

The frequencies of IR that are trapped are trapped almost completely by only very small amounts of CO2.

More CO2 =/= More trapping. (Well, not until we are talking many orders of magnitude# more like back in the Archean where the Atmosphere was very different to what it is today and the seas were at around 70C)

By analogy, a thin layer of cling film can make a very effective polytunnel. Using a sheet of polythene that is twice as thick will not make the polytunnel twice as hot...

# Much more than orders of magnitude really, The Archean atmosphere was rather more like Venuses. Known carbonate rocks contain several "Atmosphers" worth of trapped CO2. The Oxygen locked up in Iron oxide deposits represent several "Atmospheres" more. As Hoyle pointed out. Somewhere in the earths crust there must be very large amounts of fossilised carbon of which Coal/Oil and Gas can only represent an almost microscopic proportion...
 
Caporegime
Joined
22 Oct 2002
Posts
26,906
Location
Boston, Lincolnshire
I like the fact everyone is arguing over something no one really has a clue about. Climate change in hundreds of years time will just end up being the new version of religion. Overpopulation will kill this planet long before climate change has anything to do with it.
 
Associate
Joined
5 Mar 2017
Posts
2,248
Location
Cambridge
I like the fact everyone is arguing over something no one really has a clue about. Climate change in hundreds of years time will just end up being the new version of religion. Overpopulation will kill this planet long before climate change has anything to do with it.
True.
People, regardless how frugal they may try to live, will always cause harm to the planet.
 
Man of Honour
Joined
13 Oct 2006
Posts
91,052
I like the fact everyone is arguing over something no one really has a clue about. Climate change in hundreds of years time will just end up being the new version of religion. Overpopulation will kill this planet long before climate change has anything to do with it.

Doesn't mean we shouldn't try to do better. Also I hate the way certain things have become the be all and end all over things like innovative solutions for instance all the focus is now on electric cars because that is what the activists have decided is best and far too little time is spent on things like revolutionary changes to increase fuel efficiency and new ways to reduce pollutants in ICEs, etc. trying to go all out in banning certain types of packaging when the replacements have environmental concerns of their own versus clever ways to being able to recycle or reuse packaging, etc. for instance some companies have started making jiffy bags where once opened and/or once beyond a state of re-using as a jiffy bag you can quickly disassemble them for easy recycling of parts you'd normally not be able to due to the construction and other parts can be repurposed once disassembled for other uses such as part of one layer can be removed, refolded, stuck and used as a normal envelope rather than disposed of as normally would have been the case.
 
Associate
Joined
14 Jan 2020
Posts
50
True.
People, regardless how frugal they may try to live, will always cause harm to the plane
And that is the most sound-minded comment I have read so far. But the reality is we are told to buy more, spend more, waste more. It is not a financially viable option to promote frugalness for the multinational corporations that provide us with energy or consumables.
 
Don
Joined
7 Aug 2003
Posts
44,302
Location
Aberdeenshire
And that is the most sound-minded comment I have read so far. But the reality is we are told to buy more, spend more, waste more. It is not a financially viable option to promote frugalness for the multinational corporations that provide us with energy or consumables.
Every bodies jobs for a start rely on everyone buying stuff.
 
Soldato
Joined
22 Nov 2006
Posts
23,362
I like the fact everyone is arguing over something no one really has a clue about. Climate change in hundreds of years time will just end up being the new version of religion. Overpopulation will kill this planet long before climate change has anything to do with it.

Overpopulation is the problem. If you have to much of anything it causes problems, in this case it's people.

Its like how we give aid to poor parts of Africa because they cant support themselves. But then they all have 10 kids, so the problem never goes away.
 
Caporegime
Joined
22 Oct 2002
Posts
26,906
Location
Boston, Lincolnshire
Overpopulation is the problem. If you have to much of anything it causes problems, in this case it's people.

Its like how we give aid to poor parts of Africa because they cant support themselves. But then they all have 10 kids, so the problem never goes away.

One of my biggest bugbears is those help Africa adverts. I am all for helping the poor and needy but having several kids without thinking of the complications and being unable to support yourself is where natural selection should just take its course.
 
Associate
Joined
14 Jan 2020
Posts
50
It is a debt-based system if people stop buying crap they don't need with cash they don't have the system literally will crumble. Buy buy buy!

A small example is supermarkets; if you only bought what you needed and carried it home in your own bag the supermarket makes less money. If they provide you with unlimited bags that cost them 0.01p each (which you really pay for via increased food prices) but you fill your trolley with crap you don't need knowing the bags are unlimited. For decades they have known the plastic bag along with all the packaging the food you purchased comes in isn't recyclable and will either be burned at the tip or put into landfill and can take between 10-1000yrs to decompose depending.

Are they the bad guys or are you?

You didn't make them, you didn't offer them limitless for free, you didn't provide them to the world knowing they were nonrecyclable and will inevitably cause severe harm to the environment. You did not benefit financially from them you simply gained convenience at the expense of your bank account by spending more knowing the bags were free and it would not be a struggle to get your crap home. But you get the blame for destroying the environment with plastic pollution. Now you must pay 10p per bag. What happens to the bag when it rips?

You can apply that formula to almost every industry.
 
Back
Top Bottom