Rugby union?

Soldato
Joined
20 Dec 2004
Posts
15,766
Sadly, this was the game for Youngs, the conditions were right for being slow, and box kicking well.

We looked much better going forwards with Heinz' snappy delivery, it just wasn't the right game for it. Can't be too hard on his kicking with the mad wind.

Ford and Farrell both showed their experience today, and Eddie his selection.

Curry carried pretty well actually, although I'd still rather see Underhill, Dombrandt, Curry as the backrow.
 
Soldato
Joined
13 May 2003
Posts
8,833
England took their chance and were rock solid in the set piece given the conditions. But England's open play was poor. Kicking was bad in second half, refused to go through any phases most of the game. If Scotland's line out had worked at all England would have been in a really tough place. It was basically a get out of jail card for really dumb play. England looked good physically and the back row looked better, Curry looked a bit more like a No8.
 
Soldato
Joined
13 May 2003
Posts
8,833
Scotland managed several decent bits of phase play I don't remember it being a major problem for them. And whilst I agree it wasn't the weather for it to win you have to take risks. If Scotland hadn't gifted us the game we never looked like actively winning it. You can at least try and build some pressure in the final third. We looked clueless most of the second half.
 
Soldato
OP
Joined
18 Jun 2018
Posts
4,607
Location
Isle of Wight
When they did string phases we turned them over. We smashed their lineout, so why wouldn't you kick, even with so many going out on the full. We left i think 12 points in missed kicks on the pitch. They knocked around 9 times, maybe more, in total conceding 20 turnovers to our 7. At no point were we behind and we led for most the match.

Yes it was close due to conditions, but if England looked unlikely to score, Scotland struggled to achieve even that.
 

Stu

Stu

Soldato
Joined
19 Oct 2002
Posts
2,737
Location
Wirral
Yep, that baffled me. But they scraped the win in what we're clearly horrific conditions. The team doesn't seem to have the awareness to realise something isn't working and switch it up at the moment.

Kicking for goal was arguably 50/50 success rate given the conditions, but 50% chance of points is probably better odds than going to the corner. It is also important to send the message to the opposition that giving away a penalty might result in 3 points... I think the defending team win a psychological battle when the opposition give up kicking for posts when awarded a penalty.

I agree that we should have played a bit more ball in hand in Scotland's half, even with limited creativity, but they got the job done. However, the kicking early in the second half was terrible... any kick was hard to catch, there was no need to attempt to send a kick down the 5 meter channel.
 
Soldato
Joined
21 Sep 2005
Posts
14,837
Location
Bradley Stoke, Bristol
Kicking for goal was arguably 50/50 success rate given the conditions, but 50% chance of points is probably better odds than going to the corner. It is also important to send the message to the opposition that giving away a penalty might result in 3 points... I think the defending team win a psychological battle when the opposition give up kicking for posts when awarded a penalty.
My previous comment was more aimed at the box kicking rather than necessarily kicking for goal. As you said, kicking down the channel was risky, the few times they kicked down the middle to get territory seemed quite effective versus risking not actually gaining any ground due to kicking straight out.
As for kicking for goal, I'd have liked to see England try going for the lineout in Scotland's 22 a few times - just for the extra pressure. Can't recall what the final conversion percentage was for Farrell, don't think it was as high as 50% was it?

In other news. France vs Italy was a fun match to watch. Some well taken tries, great offloads and clever direction changes. A stark contrast to the England game!
 
Soldato
Joined
13 May 2003
Posts
8,833
Referee has got a total hard on for France now. I’m not convinced by all the penalties.

You weren’t wrong about the kick though. He got his yellow for a less blatant penalty later.
 
Soldato
Joined
20 Dec 2004
Posts
15,766
Best performance since against NZ...shame we dropped the ball in the France game and threw away the slam as I can't see Wales beating us at home.
 
Back
Top Bottom