Poll: *** The official 2020 MacBook Air/13" MacBook Pro thread (it has the M1 chip and everything!) ***

What 2020 Apple Silicon notebook have you ordered?

  • MacBook Air

    Votes: 71 71.0%
  • 13" MacBook Pro

    Votes: 29 29.0%

  • Total voters
    100

TS7

TS7

Soldato
Joined
16 Feb 2010
Posts
2,556
Location
East Mids
I was massively conflicted given just how good the MBA seems to be but... after much (an hour) of deliberation I've just placed an order for the Pro - with student discount.

This is probably not going to be a popular opinion but the main reason for going Pro over Air is the Touchbar. I had the 16" (which I returned because 1) it was too big and too overkill spec wise for my needs 2) there was a lot of talk about ARM) and I found the Touchbar really useful. In addition, better speakers, mic and fan will probably just make it that bit more futureproof for me (I replace every 5/6 years).

If I already had a functioning laptop I would have held out for this 14" redesign coming at some point next year. Unfortunately, my laptop has completely given up so only have the work Dell tiding me over at the minute.
 

LiE

LiE

Caporegime
Joined
2 Aug 2005
Posts
25,599
Location
Milton Keynes
Gone for the higher spec Air, 512 SSD 16 RAM. The fanless design sealed it for me. I’ll probably grab an LG ultra fine 5K at some point if it drives it smoothly (I suspect it will given the improved GPU).
 
Soldato
Joined
1 Jan 2008
Posts
11,023
Is no one worried the fanless air might overheat? I’m genuinely surprised by the uptake for the Air over the Pro so far.

You mean thermal throttle, right? I would say it’s certainly possible with extended high workloads, but I suspect if that’s your usage profile you’re probably not going for the Air over the MBP 13 (or waiting for a more powerful Apple chip in a iMac/Mac Pro or Mini).
 
Associate
Joined
4 Aug 2014
Posts
1,111
Is no one worried the fanless air might overheat? I’m genuinely surprised by the uptake for the Air over the Pro so far.

I know it’s not competent comparable but the iPads don’t have fans and I do believe that for the vast majority of day to day workloads the M1 is going to do just fine without a fan.
 
Soldato
Joined
9 Mar 2003
Posts
14,055
Temped by an Air, I need to replace a Surface Pro 3 and this would fit the bill. Bit unsure on the memory only being 8GB, I'll certainly be waiting for reviews and looking to buy early next year, my 5900X and a 3080 FE were just delivered :D.

I wonder how the 8gb holds up with it being an SOC with a fast SSD, could be interesting.

On the face of it though, looking very nice. That battery life and fanless design... nom. I wonder what they'll do int he iPad pro as it can obviously take a M1 chip based on this.

EDIT: Super torn actually as a next gen iPad Pro would also do the job. If only the iPad pro has MacOS, it would be an instant buy (with a magic keyboard of course...).
 
Commissario
OP
Joined
16 Oct 2002
Posts
2,646
Location
In the radio shack
I cancelled the order I made a couple of minutes after the presentation and re-ordered using my wife's discount link which took nearly £90 off. It's not quite educational discount but it's better than nothing and the delivery date is unchanged from the 25th November.

a816Ps9.png
 
Associate
Joined
29 Jul 2011
Posts
1,425
Tempted to get this as been wanting to downsize for a while. I don't use my PC for much anymore other than browsing, streaming and Tableau.

Will wait for reviews.
 

fez

fez

Caporegime
Joined
22 Aug 2008
Posts
25,023
Location
Tunbridge Wells
Not sure if they covered this but what is the difference between all the different models with regards to the M1 chip. Are they clocked differently?

I assume not as the a series are all identical and the only differentiator is the X version in the iPad pros as far as I know.

Edit: Just found out.

Basically, the low end air has only 7 cores instead of 8 (binning the lower quality processors) and will likely suffer a bit from thermal throttling. The next model up air doesn't have this however. The air has a smaller battery, less bright screen, no cooling fan and no touchbar. Beyond that, they are all identical.
 
Last edited:
Associate
Joined
23 Sep 2008
Posts
2,294
Location
London
You mean thermal throttle, right? I would say it’s certainly possible with extended high workloads, but I suspect if that’s your usage profile you’re probably not going for the Air over the MBP 13 (or waiting for a more powerful Apple chip in a iMac/Mac Pro or Mini).

I know it’s not competent comparable but the iPads don’t have fans and I do believe that for the vast majority of day to day workloads the M1 is going to do just fine without a fan.

Agreed, if you’re doing long compiles, exports, renders, then the air isn’t the one for you.

Hmm I guess I'm really out of touch with the tech (currently on a 2013 MBP). Got me thinking maybe the new MBA would cut it for me since I'm coping with the MBP and the only thing extra I'm likely to mess around with going forward is Lightroom which I don't think I'll be a heavy user.
 
Soldato
Joined
18 Feb 2006
Posts
10,637
I've got the 2019 13" 2.4 i5 MBP and the MBA's are quite tempting, may wait and see how people find them initially. Fanless definitely an interest..
 
Soldato
Joined
15 Sep 2009
Posts
2,876
Location
Manchester
Hmm I guess I'm really out of touch with the tech (currently on a 2013 MBP). Got me thinking maybe the new MBA would cut it for me since I'm coping with the MBP and the only thing extra I'm likely to mess around with going forward is Lightroom which I don't think I'll be a heavy user.

Let's be honest most people aren't heavy users - they may think they are and always want to overspec but a good majority of people aren't going to tax their systems on a regular basis except for certain workloads. Large 4-8k Video Editing/Large VM Usage and massive CAD work isn't the norm I would say.
 
Soldato
Joined
6 Oct 2009
Posts
3,991
Location
London
Would be interesting to see if the SSD is PCIe 4.0 (they said controller is 2x performance, and previous controllers were close to PCIe ceiling). Unified memory means the SSD likely doesn't have its own DRAM cache, and uses system memory.

I didn't order one, but I'm excited for the teardown and benchmarks :D
 
Back
Top Bottom