Now where did I say that? I never once said he was or wasn't successful. I made no claim about that.
I actually said he should stop putting other people down based on his own views of what people should do with their lives.
He was the one saying that if you live at home you are a failure (etc).
How you managed to turn that around and claim I was the one judging him, is anyone's guess. Maybe read the thread again?
e: I did say that reading him list his successes (by his own criteria) was a bit cringe, in the same way it's a bit cringe when anyone starts claiming success or greatness. "Multiple premium cars" etc
And then you and others started chiming in to say that's how people generally define success, with wealth and cars and jobs ranking highly on the list. And that he was for sure a successful guy.
So the judgement is all from you guys, really. I'm quite happy to say I don't like him, but I don't pretend he doesn't meet your (and others) definition of success.