When are you going fully electric?

Soldato
Joined
16 Jun 2005
Posts
24,023
Location
In the middle
Sorry I don't know what you can and can't afford. You simply stated what you wanted to do, and if it was achievable.
Not really no, I said what I did. If you can do a list of BEV's under 30k that will do a 400 mile trip with one 15 minute stop I'm all ears. I'm not an evangelist to either form of transportation.
 
Soldato
Joined
24 Oct 2002
Posts
14,177
Location
Bucks and Edinburgh
There will always be some people that will "never buy cheap Chinese rubbish.

Thats because we have been conditioned to buy cheap Chinese rubbish due to Western companies profiteering. You can buy any product you want in China to whatever budget you choose, so you can buy cheap rubbish or decent quality but more expensive and everything in between, most companies that import from China go for the cheaper end because of the bottom line and thats mainly what we have been conditioned with
 
Soldato
Joined
14 Mar 2011
Posts
5,421
Been chatting to a few places about the id3, but it's crazy that leasing one from VW themselves is so much more expensive than leasing one through one of the bigger lease companies...

I can get the Family Pro 58kWh model with a handful of extras (colour change, alloys, 3pin charging cable which for some reason isn't included as standard), 8000 annual miles and 4 year term from selectcarleasing for about £330 pcm (with only a single month initial/deposit), but for the exact same loadout the VW garage near me want £460?! The VW "lease + care" includes basic servicing as well but that in no way justifies the difference in price... madness... I could lease a Model 3 instead for that kind of money

The lead time on the id3 is also pretty long (next April/May at the earliest) and part of me wonders about waiting for the supposed cheaper Tesla models that could be coming out next year (though who's to say if that will happen)
 
Soldato
Joined
18 Oct 2002
Posts
21,056
The lead time on the id3 is also pretty long (next April/May at the earliest) and part of me wonders about waiting for the supposed cheaper Tesla models that could be coming out next year (though who's to say if that will happen)
There isn't going to be cheap Tesla in the UK for a while yet.
The Model S, 3 and Y have all taken 2+ years since the US launch to become available in the UK.
 

mjt

mjt

Soldato
Joined
31 Aug 2007
Posts
20,015
Random question: What is the going rate for the average kWh you guys charge at? Both at home and at charging stations.
 
Soldato
Joined
18 Oct 2002
Posts
21,056
Random question: What is the going rate for the average kWh you guys charge at? Both at home and at charging stations.
My home rate is 16p kWh
Some overnight home tariffs have 5p kWh between 00:30 and 04:30

Public charging rate varies from free at some 7kW chargers, e.g. Tesco, or 23p to 69p per kWh. depending on the charging company and the speed of the charger.
 
Soldato
Joined
14 Mar 2011
Posts
5,421
There isn't going to be cheap Tesla in the UK for a while yet.
The Model S, 3 and Y have all taken 2+ years since the US launch to become available in the UK.

Makes sense, in which case going for the id3 for ~4 years and then see what the state of things are at that point I guess

Edit: But not from VW themselves, as they appear to be a total ripoff
 
Soldato
Joined
18 Oct 2002
Posts
21,056
Makes sense, in which case going for the id3 for ~4 years and then see what the state of things are at that point I guess

Edit: But not from VW themselves, as they appear to be a total ripoff
4 years is a long time to lease a car, especially an EV, where the landscape is changing significantly every year. I would personally go for 2 or 3 years.
 

mjt

mjt

Soldato
Joined
31 Aug 2007
Posts
20,015
My home rate is 16p kWh
Some overnight home tariffs have 5p kWh between 00:30 and 04:30

Public charging rate varies from free at some 7kW chargers, e.g. Tesco, or 23p to 69p per kWh. depending on the charging company and the speed of the charger.
Thanks. I'm fortunate in that my night tariff is roughly 6p/kWh and it's 22:00-07:00!

Looking at some of those prices, I can't see how a BEV is really worth it over a hybrid or ICE. At 70p/kWh, you might as well just drive a normal car...
 
Soldato
Joined
14 Mar 2011
Posts
5,421
4 years is a long time to lease a car, especially an EV, where the landscape is changing significantly every year. I would personally go for 2 or 3 years.

Agree although you should see how much that jacks the price up :D I'm happy to stick with a car for 4 years even if I could technically upgrade to a better one...
 
Soldato
Joined
18 Oct 2002
Posts
21,056
Thanks. I'm fortunate in that my night tariff is roughly 6p/kWh and it's 22:00-07:00!

Looking at some of those prices, I can't see how a BEV is really worth it over a hybrid or ICE. At 70p/kWh, you might as well just drive a normal car...
The 70p chargers are Ionity. At that price it would be one off use for longer trips.
Also, some car companies are Ionity partners (Porsche, Audi, Mercedes, Polestar and others) so the rate drops to 30p.
 
Soldato
Joined
9 Mar 2003
Posts
14,214
Not really no, I said what I did. If you can do a list of BEV's under 30k that will do a 400 mile trip with one 15 minute stop I'm all ears. I'm not an evangelist to either form of transportation.

The Kona is about as close as you are going to get but it’s above your budget and will require more time stopped.

Is £30k your normal ‘ICE’ budget or does it already factor in the considerably cheaper running costs of an EV? The total cost of ownership equations is greatly slated towards purchase cost, where as ICE is much higher running costs. The residuals on BEVs are also very good at the moment.
 
Soldato
Joined
16 Jun 2005
Posts
24,023
Location
In the middle
The Kona is about as close as you are going to get but it’s above your budget and will require more time stopped.

Is £30k your normal ‘ICE’ budget or does it already factor in the considerably cheaper running costs of an EV? The total cost of ownership equations is greatly slated towards purchase cost, where as ICE is much higher running costs. The residuals on BEVs are also very good at the moment.
I could be wrong, and hope I am, but sort of think running costs will increase massively once a majority of people are in BEV's. Gov will want that lost tax money back somehow.
 
Soldato
Joined
9 Mar 2003
Posts
14,214
I could be wrong, and hope I am, but sort of think running costs will increase massively once a majority of people are in BEV's. Gov will want that lost tax money back somehow.

The government generally doesn’t pass retrospective tax legislation. They can’t realistically tax the fuel so I can’t see any EV being bought now being in scope of what new taxes they bring in on new vehicles to replace VED/fuel duty.

For example, my euro 5 diesel still has £30 VED despite it being pretty bad on nox emissions and my wife’s euro 5 petrol is £200 and increasing while its ULEZ compliant.
 
Soldato
Joined
18 Oct 2002
Posts
7,020
Location
Melksham
The government generally doesn’t pass retrospective tax legislation. They can’t realistically tax the fuel so I can’t see any EV being bought now being in scope of what new taxes they bring in on new vehicles to replace VED/fuel duty.

For example, my euro 5 diesel still has £30 VED despite it being pretty bad on nox emissions and my wife’s euro 5 petrol is £200 and increasing while its ULEZ compliant.

They could easily add a tax to any public chargers, but the more likely scenario is per-mile road pricing.

I agree they're not likely to alted the VED rates retrospectively, but there's other options which will almost certainly happen. Probably not for a fair while yet though.
 
Soldato
Joined
18 Oct 2002
Posts
14,114
Location
West Midlands
October car registration data is out now.

BEV's up 73.1% YoY, to 16,155 from 9,335, the total registrations for the month were 106.2k down from 140k last year, putting the BEV market share for October at 15.2%, and PHEV's at 5.5%. BEV's for the year to date are now at 9.93% of total registrations, PHEV's at 6.71%. Looks like it could hit 10.5% in total for BEV's be the year end, possibly 11% if there are big numbers being delivered from all manufacturers in a push to get their CO2 target fines lowered.
 
Soldato
Joined
13 Jan 2004
Posts
20,946
The government generally doesn’t pass retrospective tax legislation. They can’t realistically tax the fuel so I can’t see any EV being bought now being in scope of what new taxes they bring in on new vehicles to replace VED/fuel duty.

For example, my euro 5 diesel still has £30 VED despite it being pretty bad on nox emissions and my wife’s euro 5 petrol is £200 and increasing while its ULEZ compliant.

Our local Government is going to reintroduce user pays road tax because they are losing fuel duty income as BEV adoption increases.

All the while they are scratching their heads as to how to encourage greener transport and living.

Bunch of muppets.
 
Soldato
Joined
1 Mar 2010
Posts
21,892
October car registration data is out now.
they need to be upfront on the % of total that are company bev purchases , if it's still 2/3 of total then government needs to adjust incentives - levelling up;
for example they are starting advertising for care-workers, but like other professions, if they cannot afford London congestion charge say, you create unecessary economic problems.
 
Soldato
Joined
19 Jan 2006
Posts
15,975
Random question: What is the going rate for the average kWh you guys charge at? Both at home and at charging stations.

16p or so at home, free at any public chargers in my local authority area. So generally I pay nothing as I charge once a week at the golf course (public 22kw chargers x 2) or jump on the rapid charger once a week whilst my daughter is at one of her swimming training sessions. (6 x 7kw chargers, 2 x 22kw chargers and a 50kw CCS/DC/AC rapid all in the same car park at the pool - all still free)
 
Back
Top Bottom