Cue the debate about PVA
PVA is for cowboys there is no debate.
Cue the debate about PVA
PVA is for cowboys there is no debate.
Cue the debate about PVA
I'm only being led by other people's advice, having now spoken to a mate who is a plumber and looking at some more information online I have a much better idea of what needs to be done to tackle the issue.You're really over complicating things here.
It's worked on odd bits of board for years so there's no reason you can't patch it up for another few years. Sure cement board is better but if you're redoing the bathroom in future then it's not really needed.
Don't worry too much about tiles that move a little, as long as the grout isn't cracked they'll be fine.
PVA the block work and edges on the plasterboard and fill the deep bits with bonding coat so it's flat with the plasterboard, let it dry then PVA or Primer G everything you need to tile.
Stick the tiles back on, any tiles you want, if the tile is cracked then make sure you leave a space big enough to grout in, or silicone/sticks like the cracks as you put the tile on so it glues the tile together. Doesn't matter if the tiles sit a little proud.
Then grout in the tiles, leave to dry and re silicone around the tray.
There's no reason your repair can't last as long or longer than the the current tiling.