Apple servicing - are they lying to me?

Associate
Joined
3 Jan 2006
Posts
171
Location
Tonbridge, Kent
Hi all,

I haven't been on the forums for a while, but thought I'd drop in to tell you about my i-pod touch.

I hooked it up to my computer the other day, when it had synced and charged, I took it off and the touch screen was completely fronzen. No way could I get in to the user interface.

Being a normal person, I looked up the possible causes online and took the wise and useful steps that Apple gives for such a problem:

1. Hold the only two buttons (not including the vol controls) down until the device resets. I did this several times with no joy.
2. Backed up the i-pod (as the computer interface to i-tunes was unaffected)
3. Restored the i-pod using the back-up, no joy with the touch screen
4. Restored the i-pod to factory settings, no joy with the touch screen

So I thought, this i-pod is knackered, I'll send it back to them. After all, it is under warranty. I went through the online service request on the Apple website, received the packing return service with UPS and duly packed it up and waved it off. Beforehand, I checked it was still knackered by trying to use the touch screen (no joy).

Their service is very good, I received an e-mail the next day, the i-pod has arrived at the service centre in Harborough (not sure where that is but, hey, I could look it up on google maps if I was that interested).

The following day (today) I received the following e-mail:

QUOTE
Dear Anthony,

Thank you for choosing AppleCare Service.

Our technicians have performed full diagnostic checks on your IPOD TOUCH (2ND GENERATION) and have been unable to reproduce the symptom(s) you reported when you requested the repair. As a result of our tests, we can confirm that your product meets Apple specifications for performance, usability, and functionality.

As a part of our assessment and test procedures, your product has had the latest software and firmware updates installed. It is now being returned to you, and you should expect to receive it within two business days along with a letter that provides details about our assessment as well as useful troubleshooting tips.
UNQUOTE

Now, I hear you say, that's good news. Well, it is good in the respect that I should have my fully functioning i-pod touch back within the next week. My worry is that I know for certain the i-pod was defective and the touch screen was basically inert.

I therefore think there are two options for what has happened (and I assume that the i-pod will work once it is returned)

1. The i-pod miraculously recovered during the transit to the service centre.
2. The technicians at the service centre didn't bother to check whether there was a problem and hooked it up to their machine, reinstalled the software and firmware and found it worked OK when they had finished wiping and resintalling.

So if you managed to read this far and, yes, I know it's a bit boring, I do have a point to all this;

I think that Apple do not wish to admit to anyone that their products may fail inexplicably. They do the right thing by having a great service in place to ensure the product is looked at and then returned, but they do not appreciate that their e-mail is suspect and patronising. I could be wrong and have fingers that are not the "correct type of fingers to use a touch screen", but I don't think so.

Should I get me i-pod back and just shut up?....Yes, probably, but sometimes I just feel that companies like this don't respect your judgement and views. They try to cover up the products failings with good service but poor excuses.

Any road up....I would be interested to have your comments and know whether this has happened to anyone else (I didn't check the posts as I needed this /rant).

Cheers Folks.
Disgusted of Tunbridge Wells.
 
Not convinced it's a particularly patronising email. They haven't said that you are an idiot and were wrong - just that they couldn't reproduce the issue you reported and that during their tests it was fine. What did you want them to say?

As mentioned, you may find that discharging the battery managed to magically reset the device, rendering it okay again.
 
2. The technicians at the service centre didn't bother to check whether there was a problem and hooked it up to their machine, reinstalled the software and firmware and found it worked OK when they had finished wiping and resintalling.
I do not see anything patronising whatsoever with their email. Also, I think it's perfectly acceptable that the first thing they would do is reinstall the software, which I personally would have tried myself before requesting repair. Quite why you're disgusted I don't know. What poor excuses have they offered? What's wrong with their email?
 
I don't really see what your beef is. You sent it off, they say it's fixed. If it comes back fixed, which it seems it will, then what you wanted has happened.

If it doesn't come back fixed, then moan... But I can't see it happening because if it did you'd just send it back again, why would they want that?
 
I don't really see what your beef is. You sent it off, they say it's fixed. If it comes back fixed, which it seems it will, then what you wanted has happened.

If it doesn't come back fixed, then moan... But I can't see it happening because if it did you'd just send it back again, why would they want that?
what if it gets messed up again and he send it in. they think he's messing them around?
 
The best thing to do is take it to an apple store and show the problem directly with the genius. They won't be able to argue with you once they see it for themselves.
 
I just had a similar problem with my touch 3G 32GB

After a week safari packed up it tried to load a java page and got "stuck".

When I opened safari app I couldn't do anything except close the app again the screen was frozen.

I had to do a full software install since you can't remove (well I don't know if you can but I couldn't ) Safari and reinstall it separately (which you should be able to do IMHO :o ) given the number of sites these days which surrupticiously redirect you to full flash sites :(

I don't know how to reinstall from back up the only option Itunes seems to give is RESTORE which when clicked reinstalls the software. Of course when I tried this from my desktop running WIN 7 64 bit I got an error 13 code :(

After a sweaty 40 minutes during which I had thought I'd just bricked a 270€ ipod I tried to restore on my netbook (running Win 7 32 bit) and it restored the machine.

Still a bit quirky as I reinstalled all music and apps yesterday afternoon and when I tried to sync last night it asked me if I wanted change my synced computer again and afterwards proceeded to "update" all my music and vids which took some time.

Thing is working fine I just think the software is a bit buggy. Of course with all the 3rd Party apps going around you never know which one could potentially screw up your touch/phone.
 
Back
Top Bottom