BenQ xl2410t VS Asus VK246H

I'll back up the 3D on Flatout 2. For a game that isn't rated by nVidia at all, it really is superb. Mr Trofeo and I have been playing it, according to Steam, for 8 hours so far, and it's brilliant fun.

I haven't tried the Benq; I went for the Asus as the glossy screen wasn't an issue for me. I'm very happy with it in terms of picture quality. It's great for watching films and TV series, and games look really nice on it. It's the closest I've seen in terms of colours to my friend's Dell 2407WFP S-PVA panel. In fact, in programs that don't use the full Adobe RGB spectrum it looks too saturated, being a wide gamut monitor. After using a 120Hz screen for a couple of months, 60Hz seems very juddery though. I couldn't go back to using a 60Hz screen now. I'd miss the 3D as well.

The Asus does have a little backlight bleed, but it's only noticeable on a completely black screen. Even dark scenes in films and games aren't a problem though.

However, I'm less than impressed with Asus' returns policy. I got a stuck blue pixel, and then a whole line, top to bottom, of stuck blue pixels, and upon contacting Asus was told they would only replace it for a new monitor within 7 days. I've had it about 10 weeks. I contacted the retailer explaining the situation and haven't had a reply yet, however when I tried to submit an RMA they said it had to go directly to Asus. I'm pretty sure a 12 month replacement with a new product warranty applies regardless, but they don't seem to think so. I can get rid of the line when it rears its head now and again, but I don't see why I should seeing as it cost me nearly £400 for the bundle.

Just be warned. It's looking like I'm going to have to jump through a few hoops to get a replacement. Check the warranty terms before parting with any money.
 
The Asus does have a little backlight bleed, but it's only noticeable on a completely black screen. Even dark scenes in films and games aren't a problem though.

However, I'm less than impressed with Asus' returns policy. I got a stuck blue pixel, and then a whole line, top to bottom, of stuck blue pixels, and upon contacting Asus was told they would only replace it for a new monitor within 7 days. I've had it about 10 weeks. I contacted the retailer explaining the situation and haven't had a reply yet, however when I tried to submit an RMA they said it had to go directly to Asus. I'm pretty sure a 12 month replacement with a new product warranty applies regardless, but they don't seem to think so. I can get rid of the line when it rears its head now and again, but I don't see why I should seeing as it cost me nearly £400 for the bundle.

Just be warned. It's looking like I'm going to have to jump through a few hoops to get a replacement. Check the warranty terms before parting with any money.

I got a brand new replacement for 1 dead pixel within a week. I contracted the retrailer about it to ask if i could replace it for the benq but they said it had been over 7days so couldnt return under DSR but they would be happy to liaise with Asus on your behalf to see if we can have a on-site swap out carried out under their DOA policy

Also the monitor frame had a small dint that wasnt to noticable unless looking for it but but they rang me up and said they will make it sound worst then it is so i get a replacement. Got a brand new one with in 7days shiped with the asus warehouse.
Your best hope is to contact the retrailer again and ask them to ring up asus.

Only downside on my new monitor is that it has very small backlight bleed at the top that i can notice on dark scenes in films while my last asus didnt have any. But its not that bad
 
I'll back up the 3D on Flatout 2. For a game that isn't rated by nVidia at all, it really is superb. Mr Trofeo and I have been playing it, according to Steam, for 8 hours so far, and it's brilliant fun.

I haven't tried the Benq; I went for the Asus as the glossy screen wasn't an issue for me. I'm very happy with it in terms of picture quality. It's great for watching films and TV series, and games look really nice on it. It's the closest I've seen in terms of colours to my friend's Dell 2407WFP S-PVA panel. In fact, in programs that don't use the full Adobe RGB spectrum it looks too saturated, being a wide gamut monitor. After using a 120Hz screen for a couple of months, 60Hz seems very juddery though. I couldn't go back to using a 60Hz screen now. I'd miss the 3D as well.

The Asus does have a little backlight bleed, but it's only noticeable on a completely black screen. Even dark scenes in films and games aren't a problem though.

However, I'm less than impressed with Asus' returns policy. I got a stuck blue pixel, and then a whole line, top to bottom, of stuck blue pixels, and upon contacting Asus was told they would only replace it for a new monitor within 7 days. I've had it about 10 weeks. I contacted the retailer explaining the situation and haven't had a reply yet, however when I tried to submit an RMA they said it had to go directly to Asus. I'm pretty sure a 12 month replacement with a new product warranty applies regardless, but they don't seem to think so. I can get rid of the line when it rears its head now and again, but I don't see why I should seeing as it cost me nearly £400 for the bundle.

Just be warned. It's looking like I'm going to have to jump through a few hoops to get a replacement. Check the warranty terms before parting with any money.

Its not just ASUS that pulls stuff off like this. NEC who are a high end brand also do not replace units with new ones after 14 days.

I went through about 4 LCD2080UXi's because of the shocking white uniformity until I pestered them so much they sent me a brand new 2090UXi. :cool:
 
Back
Top Bottom