Since when were graphics a good judge of the quality of a game anyway? Heavenly Sword sucked, it was beautiful, but it sucked.
Agreed. Look at the original Goldeneye. The graphics for that are now bad but the game itself is great!
To me a good game is something which has good gameplay and a decent story backing it.

i'd take HS beautiful graceful combat over God of War 3 any day of the week!
but yes, maybe I'm being rash to dismiss it so soon, but it just strikes me that it's going to be like that all the way through, the mindless platforming bits where you just press a button to jump to the next designated handhold, mindless button mashing combat, that horrible camera switching positions when you least expect it.