1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

His Dark Materials - New BBC/HBO/New Line Cinema TV Series

Discussion in 'Music, Box Office, TV & Books' started by Maccy, May 22, 2019.

  1. Maccy


    Joined: Nov 23, 2004

    Posts: 34,871

    Location: Back in Blighty

    New tv series starting this year, there was an old thread about this back in 2015 but thought it best to start a new one.

    Hopefully it's better than the film which was dreadful!
  2. checjb

    Wise Guy

    Joined: Oct 18, 2002

    Posts: 2,188

    Location: Royston, Herts

    That looks promising.
  3. HeX


    Joined: Jun 20, 2004

    Posts: 11,628

    Location: Huddersfield, UK

    Looking faithful to the books, hope they do a better job than the movie.
  4. Rroff

    Man of Honour

    Joined: Oct 13, 2006

    Posts: 61,481

    I thought the movie captured some elements of the books but ultimately didn't really understand the material it was working with.

    I'm not sure from the trailer - some bits feel a bit wrong i.e. too modern compared to the aesthetic in the book, etc. but without seeing more I can't be sure.
  5. Shamikebab


    Joined: Mar 9, 2006

    Posts: 48,958

    Location: Surrey

    please, please get this right.
  6. ricid


    Joined: Sep 26, 2018

    Posts: 268

    Just started rereading the original books so should be fully prepped to annoy everyone by pointing out any differences.
  7. Minusorange


    Joined: Nov 25, 2005

    Posts: 3,593

    Didn't read the books, thought the film was alright, disappointed they didn't do the sequels though, so looking forward to this
  8. Marsman


    Joined: Oct 18, 2009

    Posts: 10,623

    Was just about to update the old thread and noticed this thread.

    To say I am looking forward to this is an understatement. I loved the books, but for me, the film was let down. As Rroff said; they got the look of the world right, but they didn't understand the material.

    I have seen some comments from people who read the books and also liked the film though, so not all readers of the books found the film to be below par.

    The Golden Compass reminds of the Ghost in the Shell film somewhat; that also got the look right and captured elements from the 1995 anime, but didn't understand what made the source so material so good. Both were fancy looking but pretty hollow. I suppose it wouldn't be Hollywood though, if they didn't take a source material, make something visually fantastic from it, but miss the point of the story.
  9. Shamikebab


    Joined: Mar 9, 2006

    Posts: 48,958

    Location: Surrey

    I don't think it was them not understanding the material at all, it's a difficult story to make into a big movie with the external pressures based on it's content. Hopefully a TV series might fly under the radar a little more and have less pressure to appeal to certain groups.
  10. ttaskmaster


    Joined: Sep 11, 2013

    Posts: 8,017

    Location: Reading, UK

    Oh yeah, I remember that.
    Having not read the books, I thought the film wasn't bad.... just a while ago, with only rumours of more films. I remember wanting to see/know more, so hopefully this will be good enough.
  11. FTM


    Joined: Dec 10, 2003

    Posts: 5,879

    Location: South Shields

    the thing about the film is many people say it was cut to ribbons and re-arranged to suit american the american market...so its wast a fair reflection of the the way its was shot and cut by the original director
  12. Marsman


    Joined: Oct 18, 2009

    Posts: 10,623

    That is a fair point FTM. I've been too critical of The Golden Compass without realising and taking into account that what was released was not what the director has intended. That happens far too often and the director gets the blame.

    David Fincher on Alien 3 is another example of a director's work being butchered by the studio. While Terminator is in my mind (from another thread); I read that Emilia Clarke was relieved that there wouldn't be a sequel to Genisys. She worked with Genisys' director, Alan Taylor on Game of Thrones. She said he was not the director she knew from GoT and that he was eaten and chewed up while directing Genisys.

    I've a couple of friends who haven't read the books and they quite liked the film. They were surprised that I was quite scathing about it. I've only seen it the once though (when it came out) and long before knowing anything about what FTM mentioned above. Knowing it was another film to suffer at the hands of studio meddling, maybe my view on it would be softer and less critical if I watched it again. I'd probably should do really..

    It's a real shame we can't see these films as the director had envisaged. Some might still have been poor, but some might have been much better without studio meddling.