Human Recycling: Corpses are the Prize in Global Drive for Profits

[Bear]

Care to explain the rational behind purposefully not saving a life then?

That's what I want to hear. What is the REASON for denying organs to someone in need, where is the logic behind that concious decision.

My reasons are pretty clear, I won't need my organs after I die therefore the most reasonable and logical option is for them to be used to help others.

How about over population which is one of the reasons we choose for instance not to have children. There are over 6 billion people and growing on this planet which is a major concern with many agencies about how many more can be supported.

One way to control the population is for people to choose not to have children as it is not right to put in rules like China have and force it on people. The other way is people dying. As you can't kill people and it is illegal to not to treat people then not passing on organs is one method that doesn't suffer the above problem. It is no different to not giving money (disposable income) to charities that use that money to feed starving people and plenty of people don't give money.

 

[Fenris]

So your reason is because you want people to die?

Ok I'm done here, I think my position has been justified well enough.

As you can't kill people and it is illegal to not to treat people then not passing on organs is one method that doesn't suffer the above problem.

Just thought I would quote that because it amused me more than the rest of your post, I quite like how you make it sound like killing people should be legal.

 

[Bear]

So your reason is because you want people to die?

Ok I'm done here, I think my position has been justified well enough.

I havent challenged your position your position is perfectly fair, you have challenged other peoples. Just because you can't accept other peoples reasons doesnt mean their reasons are irrational

Unless you don't think there is a world population problem and happy to see the huge disparity in world inequality in terms of energy, food and wealth keep on growing then something has got to give.

 

[Bear]

Just thought I would quote that because it amused me more than the rest of your post, I quite like how you make it sound like killing people should be legal.

Not at all, I was just explaining a point, obviously I didn't make it clear enough

 

[Fenris]

Not at all, I was just explaining a point, obviously I didn't make it clear enough

Oh no you made it perfectly clear, you think a valid reason to deny organ donation is a concious decision to want other people to die.

 

[Bear]

Oh no you made it perfectly clear, you think a valid reason to deny organ donation is a concious decision to want other people to die.

Sorry I misunderstood what you originally meant, yes you are right in part what you have written above although I don't want people to die. Just like many peoples conscious decision to choose not to give money to charities which feed starving people, I'm sure they don't want people to die but they don't care enough to give any money. Do you give all your disposable income away? How do you feel about those people that may have died because you didn't part with that money, do you care? Was that conscious decision not to give that money away mean you wanted those starving people to die?

I don't think killing people should be legal as I thought you implied.