If you're focusing purely on the spec sheet then you'll never justify the extra $40k for the Gallardo and go straight out and buy the R8. Then again though, who buys cars based only on specs and performance figures, especially at this kind of money?
Having never driven either I can't give an informed opinion or official verdict, but I believe that the 40 grand premium would be more than justified by the event surrounding each and every drive, and the overall ownership experience. Imagine the thrill you'd get waking up on a morning knowing your very own Lamborghini is there in the garage, waiting to be driven, hard. Imagine the grin on your face every time you open the garage door to see it sat there, decked out in it's completely outrageous hue of paint. Imagine the tingle down your spine you'd get each time you fired up engine, ready to head out into driving nirvana.
The R8, whilst being a fabulous looking machine, and by all accounts just as capable as it's Italian contemporary, just wouldn't stir the above in me, at least nowhere near to the same degree, I believe. Ultimately it would come down to old cliche head versus heart decision, the logical choice being very obviously the R8. In the end though, sometimes, you just have to throw logic and reason to the wind and go with what your heart is screaming at you to do. For me, it would be Gallardo all the way.
I can't help but think Lamborghini went soft
Only on OcUK can a company that makes such cars as the Gallardo LP550-2 Balboni, the Murcielago LP670-4 SV and the Reventon be accused of 'going soft'.