My Audi RS4 / S5 experience.......

OcUK Staff
Joined
17 Oct 2002
Posts
38,635
Location
OcUK HQ
Hi there

Got to the Audi dealer, was short on time however they quickly through me into an RS4 Avant. Was not too happy about this because its the saloon I am interested in. Upon throwing many questions at the sale guy who tells me the Avant and Saloon both drive the same etc. etc. due to having the same wheelbase etc. etc. First of all is this true?

The car had the lighter RS4 seats, damn comfy and nice plus he mentioned something about uprated suspension, Audi option.

Anyway started the car up, radio off and set off in the car amongst rush hour traffic. Like the EVO the car was so easy to drive, as in clutch control, gears etc.

Don't shoot me now, but I forgot to press the sport button which makes the seats hug you and makes the throttle response crisper, suspension and power remain unchanged so not a big boo. Anyway upon leaving the Audi car park I noticed the steering, it was so light, once out onto the main road with some speed it got gradually heavier, kinda annoying really but at least it had some weight to it now.

Driving the car in traffic was a breeze and I soon found some open stretches and country roads. The engine sounds nice inside, lovely V8 burble but just a little on the quiet side. Power delivery well the car does not feel particular quick at all, but my god the speedo goes round pretty quick. Its certainly a car that when you think your travelling at 30 your actually doing 50 and 100 leptons feels more like 60-70. Like I say the speedo goes round in a rather quick fashion and shows no signs of slowing not even when entering 3 digit area.

I drove the car on my route home and back so roads I know, same roads as I took the EVO etc.

There is a long sweeping bend which gets sharper and sharper which in the dry the Mustang can do 55-60 with ease, though I do slide across the seat and you can push to around 70mph but that promotes some tyre squeal. So in the Audi I entered the corner doing 50ish, did not go any faster because I simply had no communication from the car but as I went into the corner it felt like the rear-end went to step out, then for a millisecond the car felt a little unstable under me but then it just planted itself, maybe it was some kind of traction or 4WD system doing some trickery but it did not feel natural.

Anyway took some more corners and even though the car grips the steering feels completely disconnected from the car and its also pretty slow, as in the steering is sluggish in comparison to the Mustang and some of the other cars I've driven. I could also certainly feel the cars weight in the corners as well, basically even though it corners quickly it makes you feel very disconnected from the road and in some ways just feels plain strange.

Now what I did like was the interior it really did just oooze pure quality, certainly the best yet. The seats were superb they held you perfectly in place, so no sliding about like in the Mustang but they are very comfy too. The suspension was a little harsh but perfectly fine.

The good points are its certainly quick, it feels slow due to the disconnected feeling and it don't really push you back in the seat but the speedo goes round in no time. Standing start acceleration is fantastic, I had no issues with traffic light grand prix the car just took off and flew. The car also picks up very well in higher gears from low RPM too, so the torque is available from down low and the cars gearing is relatively short too which no doubt gives it the impression of having more torque.

The bad points is it very muched reminded me of my 3000GT driving experience. Completely disconnected and slow steering which I found rather off putting, its certainly not a focused drivers car at all. The handling, well it grips well and no doubt the onboard computers keep it on the black stuff but I could certainly feel the cars weight in the corners, it did not feel chuckable at all, but it did grip well.

I can see why some like it so much due to the fact the car shields you from road feel and noise, plus makes driving fast incredibly easy, not to sure on how the chassis handles when you go past its limits though.

Anyway the sales guy could see I was not too impressed and obviously my drive was a bit short. So he invited me to the S5 launch and took me over to an Audi I'd not seen before. He said what do you think of this and I said it looks damn fine and am guessing its got a V8 in it, he said yep.

So on Sunday I am back for an hours drive in the RS4 (Saloon hopefully this time) and then an hour in a Sprint Blue S5. This will give me more time to properly put the cars through their paces and see if I change my mind.

So favourable points of the RS4 are its truly amazing build quality and its straight line performance. Also the prices seem reasonable at 42k-46k for a 12month old example.

Will report back at the weekend on how the S5 drives which by the way I love the look off and if I think any better of the RS4.

Would still like to find out if the Avant is an equal to the Saloon like Audi say, they guy knows I don't want an Avant and as such is not trying the hard sale on me, but he was adament they both drive and handle identical apart from the fact the Avant is 50kg heavier which I suppose is not gonna transform the car anyway.
 
panthro said:
Your post about the driving feel seems to contradict most good car reviews of the RS4. By not pressing the sport button it seems a bit of a waste, because the transformation between sport and non sport is a very big difference.
Also, if you are so concerned about speed, why waste your time driving the S5?

Hi there

According to the Audi manual the Sport button changes the engine map, so more quicker reving and makes it sound slightly different, it does not mention that it changes anything else. I am sure its not all of a sudden going to give the steering communication it previously did not have. Though I do take it the sport button defaults to off, if so then it was off, unless it defaults to on.

So if Audi offered you a drive in their latest newest S5 would you say no. ;)

On sunday I shall make sure to press the sport button and if it does transform the car I will duly report back. I like the look of them, especially in sprint blue but unless the sport buttom does some kind of amazing transformation of how the car drives I doubt its the car for me.

I am not interested in car reviews, I don't buy cars based soley on car reviews but more how they feel to drive. Plus as I am comparing it to cars such as a highly modified Mustang, EVO 9's, Z06 and BMW M Coupe might just be a tad different to what the car reviews were comparing against. :)
 
MrSix said:
Have you looked at an Audi R8 Gibbo?

Hi there

Oh I only wish I could afford one. If I had the money thats the car I'd buy as long as it drives as well as it looks and my experience agrees with the press. From reading reviews they all comment on how it has great steering feel and is very focused sports car so I reckon I'd definetely have one. Its just 20-30k out of reach for me. :(
 
[TW]Fox said:
If you are looking at the S5 please try the 335i - in a recent twintest Evo reckoned despite being marginally down on power it was the better car, and they even said the 3.0 TDI was the best engine in the A5 becuase it suits the car better than the S5.

Hi there

Also seen similar on the 335i, many many reviews saying its one of the best BMW's ever, its supposedly perfect in every way.

Daft question but as its a turbo, can it be tuned relatively easily and safely without costing a fortune?

Any comments on the steering, feel, quickness as is it an improvement over the outgoing M3, maybe as good as the Z4MC or CSL?

Don't think the dealer has an A5 TDi, just the S5 and if they do trying to test drive 3 cars in one day might be a bit too much, plus I am also got a test drive on a 911 Turbo Sunday too. :)
 
Tomsk said:
Mechanically all the RS4s are the same.
It the chassis, especially the stiffness that differentiates them - RS4 Saloon > RS4 Avant > RS4 Convertible

The S5 only has ~340BHP, whereas the RS4 has ~415BHP.

If you fancy a bargain 'supercar' with a difference, try a Jeep Grand Cherokee SRT8 - 420BHP, 0-60 <5.0sec, 1/4 mile 13.5sec. I've seen a six month old example going for £32K, new they're £41K. Tuning to 600BHP in the USA. They are a bit rare though.

Hi there

I am sorry but a Jeep is not going to handle at all and 13.5s is not really that quick. Not a car for me but certainly something different. :)
 
panthro said:
Oh well, at least next time you'll be able to compare the sport to non sport. I found it does make a pretty big difference. Im not sure I would take the test drive if I was looking at and driving a car superior to the S5.

Hi there

Yep, will make sure to press the button. Though from double checking it really ONLY does change the engine map to give more finer throttle response and makes the seats hug you more. Power and suspension settings along with steering remained unchanged.

The S5 may have less power but I preferre the looks and as it is the latest model Audi may have improved aspects such as the steering feel and handling. Plus it no doubt weighs a little less too so where it may lack the power it might do other things better. Only way to find out is to drive it. :)
 
Dolph said:
Don't hold your breath, most reviews have said the S5 isn't the car it should be because of it's fairly nose heavy attitude encouraged by the marketing department :(

Hi there

Well at least I can give it a try. :)
 
Simon said:
Will there ever be a car you don't tune ? :p


Nope. :D

Cars from the factory are trying to meet strict CO2 emmissions, hit MPG targets and not be too loud all of which I don't care about. I like my cars to breathe and sound as they should. I just went a tad crazy with the Mustang. :D
 
MrLOL said:
id ask for a test drive

and this time use the sport button. Most of the reviews ive read have had nothing but praise for the RS4.

have a read of the evo review

http://www.evo.co.uk/carreviews/evocarreviews/60571/audi_rs4.html



maybe thats they are describing the sensation you felt when it seemed to just plant itself. But nowhere have i read that the steering feels disconnected though ...

Hi there

From reading the EVO review, am definetely in agreement to regards build quality, performance from the engine and yes the brakes were very good indeed.

Still the steering did not seem great to me, yes it added weight but artificial weight and as such road feel just seemed minimal. Plus one thing that was for sure is the steering was not particular fast or hugely precise. Anyone who has been in the Mustang will know what I mean by quick and precise steering, its basic but works damn well, think it rather impressed Elliot. :)

Again my drive was short and at the weekend I will test it more and see how it performs. :)
 
Hi there

OK I re-visited the RS4 again today and had a much better test drive even though it was pooring with rain.

I took out a sprint blue RS4 saloon, so on the looks side of things this is a car I would buy because it looks good and again the interior was just sheer quality.

Upon starting the car, I made sure to hit the S button straight away. Anyway lets get straight to the driving experience. I put more focus into the steering this time to see if I was maybe been a tad harsh in my previous judgement and I would say I was maybe a little harsh. The steering does have some feel and it is reasonably precise and kinda quick. Its still lacking in feel and precision of the Mustang but its not quite as bad as I originally thought.

So this time I had a good 45 minutes in the car driving the routes I wanted to drive and goto. It was pooring it down but the car never had a single issue putting any of the power down right upto the 8000rpm redline.

2nd gear in this car is just amazing, floor it from 3000rpm and 8000rpm comes up in a matter of seconds, up into third and a second or two later your at warp speed. The speedo gives me the impression the car is quicker than it is, which I am a little confused about because on a rolling start the old M5 is just as quick but the RS4 to drive seems quicker, anyway guess that leaves the question is the RS4 tunable to get a little bit more without having to spend thousands?

This time handling wise this car behaved much better it felt sure footed all the time on the road and it was great to be able to corner at pretty high speeds in the what were very wet conditions. Also the V8 did sound fantastic.

So now I do think better of the RS4, its a real pleasure to drive because on one hand its a very capable road warrior and on the other hand it can commute you too and from work in great comfort, but just at warp speed.

I would like more steering feel and slightly quicker steering along with a bit more communication from the car as to when your about to run out of grip and get slingshot off the road.

Then it was my go in the S5, another sprint blue. Now this car I love the looks and the interior, well its the sexiest interior yet, even more so over the BMW Z4M Coupe so already I was liking it more than the RS4 based on its looks and interior.

To drive the car has really light steering at low speeds, far too light in fact but it does weighten up with speed and its about the same speed as the RS4's along with similar level of feel, maybe a tad less. However this car did feel more nimble, a little more chuckable which is odd because I don't think it weighs much less than the RS4 but it certainly did feel a little lighter on its feet.

Now unlike the RS4 2nd gear in the S5 is not shall we say as fun, however it would appear 3rd gear is the S5 trumps card because it pulls just as hard as 2nd more or less but you get a much wider range. The car is also no slouch, its certainly has less grunt low down but past 4000rpm it pulls well and does not seem hugely slower than the RS4 at speeds sub 100mph. Inside the car the V8 engine does not sound that great, not very V8 at all, infact more V6. However from the outside the sound that comes from the four rear tailpipes is rather amazing and does indeed sound very V8 and muscular.

So to sum this up I basically want an RS5. If Audi in 12-18months do release an RS5 with circa 450 horses with slightly better suspension and improved steering I think I shall definetely consider buying one.

Now would I buy an RS4, well after todays drive not 100% sure because the Audi is none stop screaming quality from every crevice. I would like a little more grunt and some extra steering feel but apart from that its a damn good car. I do preferre Coupe style cars and where possible something more rarer but I think its fair to say the RS4 does stand out from your traditional A4 especially in RS only colours. :) The RS4 is extremely good of the mark, no need for any revs just floor it from idle in 1st and it just goes, real quick and very smooth. In comparison the EVO is very slow if you try similar because instead you obviously need to drop the clutch at high revs which is something I don't like doing.

Now as I was rather impressed with my Audi test drives I went straight to the Mitsubishi dealer and got a test drive in the older EVO 8 GSR, this one however had an ecutek in place and was running at 358BHP and had 20,000 on the clock so I could basically thrash it.

Now we know the EVO is no match for the Audi when it comes to build quality and interior etc. etc. so lets not go there. The ride quality is firm and not as good as the Audi's.

When it comes to power this car did have some lag below 3000rpm, in fact it was quite annoying because the Audi's been V8's don't have this. Obviously the EVO 9 I drove was much better below 3000rpm which is no doubt due to the introduction of Mivec on the EVO 9 range, so if I did buy an EVO it would have to be a 9 because to be frank the lag on the others is a pain in the ass.

Now the steering on the EVO is fantastic, its as quick as the Mustang and gives just as much feedback. Performance wise, off the mark this car seemed a little slow, again due to lag but when boost came online it was a case of hold on very tight, crazy damn car. On a roll from say 60mph-110mph I'd say this was just as quick as the RS4 which I was quite surprised by because it was indeed rather quick. So the EVO is certainly more of a drivers car and fun to drive quick in all weather.

Then I set off in the Mustang, many big tail slides and lots of sideway roundabout stuff, thats the beuty of RWD it can be fun at all speeds.

Still I am left pining for an RS5, considering the quality of the RS4 and the fact if the dealer does me a good price I should not loose anything on depreciation due to RS4 production has now stopped so in theory a safe car to buy. Then I think that if I enjoyed an EVO 8 and a EVO 9 which I drove gently does that mean I'd find an EVO 9 GT with 400 horses an absolute hoot to drive.

I never thought that buying another car would be so damn difficult. Because then there is the other contenders such as the Z06, Porsches and even the M3 CSL. Its a hard life trying all this different machinery out:D but definetely confusing as which one to buy.
 
Back
Top Bottom