New car for other half help us decide

What do you think of people who have horribly judgemental views on why people like you drive a Boxster?

How is it not basically the same thing as you are doing here? I don't understand why you seem utterly unable to comprehend that others have different tastes and sometimes those tastes are neither logical not rational.

Some people prefer the way an SUV looks and drives. It's really that simple. Personally I hate the way they drive but that's the glory of taste isn't it?
 
What do you think of people who have horribly judgemental views on why people like you drive a Boxster?

How is it not basically the same thing as you are doing here? I don't understand why you seem utterly unable to comprehend that others have different tastes and sometimes those tastes are neither logical not rational.

Some people prefer the way an SUV looks and drives. It's really that simple. Personally I hate the way they drive but that's the glory of taste isn't it?

I think they're perfectly entitled to their view and that if they tried driving one or reading the extensive reviews available from those who do would understand why. It's widely accepted as being a fantastic car with exceptional handling, performance and quality.

It's worth noting for example that I find the f-type to be a better looking car but the boxster was just better.
 
Last edited:
And some SUVs are widely accepted as being good cars too. Just not ones which are to your personal preference.

Yes, but crossovers and compact SUVs are considered inferior to the hatchback from which they tend to be derived or rough equivalents available in terms of size/cost. This is simply down to physics.

Prime example being fiesta vs ecosport.
 
Yes, but crossovers and compact SUVs are considered inferior to the hatchback from which they tend to be derived or rough equivalents available in terms of size/cost. This is simply down to physics.

Inferior in some respects, sure. I found the handling on the X5 frustrating for example, but not in others - it rode well and was refined on the motorway.

Prime example being fiesta vs ecosport.

The EcoSport is just crap full stop.
 
I'm yet to hear one of those people that like it logically explain it.

That's not true. The potential advantages of a higher driving position have been explained to you several times...but you've dismissed them all as "excuses" because of your own opinions on the psychology of SUV buyers, and therefore you won't accept those reasons, and instead, berate the people who give them. As Fox has demonstrated, this is pretty ironic considering you have had to come up with a rather tenuous excuse to justify why your own car choice is based on "need" rather than desire. None of us can understand that excuse, yet you seem insistent that we accept it's validity - so why can't you accept the reasons people give for SUV ownership? You might not think they hold any weight, but don't pretend for a second that you "haven't heard anyone explain it"...you have, you just refuse to accept the explanations as valid, when they no less valid than your "I needed a 6 cylinder for overtaking commuters" explanation.
 
That's not true. The potential advantages of a higher driving position have been explained to you several times...but you've dismissed them all as excuses because of your own opinions on the psychology of SUV buyers, and therefore you won't accept those reasons and berate them instead. As Fox has demonstrated, this is pretty ironic considering you have had to come up with a rather tenuous excuse to justify why your own car choice is based on "need" rather than desire. None of us can understand that excuse, yet you seem insistent that we accept it's validity - so why can't you accept the reasons people give for SUV ownership? You might not think they hold any weight, but don't pretend for a second that you "haven't heard anyone explain it"...you have, you just refuse to accept the explanations as valid, when they no less valid than your "I needed a 6 cylinder for overtaking commuters" explanation.

Please highlight these advantages.
 
Back
Top Bottom