Poll: OCUK Book Club - Poll for book #2

OCUK Book Club - Poll for book #2

  • David Mitchell - Ghostwritten

    Votes: 4 15.4%
  • Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn - August 1914

    Votes: 7 26.9%
  • Orson Scott Card - Speaker for the Dead

    Votes: 6 23.1%
  • Clive Barker - Weaveworld

    Votes: 4 15.4%
  • Jeffery Archer - Kane & Abel

    Votes: 5 19.2%

  • Total voters
    26
  • Poll closed .
Soldato
Joined
10 Feb 2004
Posts
5,116
Location
Crewe, UK
Hey,

Now the lottery is complete, I will add the five books that have been randomly chosen for next month, along with a short blurb about the book. If a passing mod can add a poll that would be great.

David Mitchell - Ghostwritten

Ghostwritten is the first novel published by the author David Mitchell. Published in 1999, it won the John Llewellyn Rhys Prize and was widely acclaimed. The story takes place mainly around East Asia, but also moves through Russia, Britain and the USA. It is written episodically; each chapter details a different story and central character, although they are all interlinked through seemingly coincidental events. Many of the themes from Ghostwritten continue in Mitchell's subsequent novels, number9dream and Cloud Atlas.

Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn - August 1914

August 1914 is a novel by Russian novelist Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn about Imperial Russia's defeat at the Battle of Tannenberg in East Prussia, known in Russian history as the Battle of the Masurian Lakes. The novel was completed in 1970, during Solzhenitsyn's period of exile while residing in the United States[1]. The novel is an unusual blend of fiction narrative and historiography, and has given rise to extensive and often bitter controversy, both from the literary as well as from the historical point of view.

Orson Scott Card - Speaker for the Dead

Speaker for the Dead (1986) is a science fiction novel by Orson Scott Card and a sequel to the novel Ender's Game. This book takes place around the year 5135, some 3,000 years after the events in Ender's Game. However, due to relativistic space travel Ender himself (who now goes by his real name Andrew Wiggin or by his title "Speaker for the Dead") is only about 35 years old.
Like Ender's Game, the book won the Hugo Award (1987) and Nebula Award (1986) for outstanding science fiction novel, making Card the first author in history to win both these awards in two consecutive years. Speaker for the Dead was published in a slightly revised edition in 1991. It was followed by Xenocide and Children of the Mind.

Clive Barker - Weaveworld

Weaveworld is a novel by Clive Barker. It was published in 1987 and could be categorized as dark fantasy. It deals with a parallel world, like many of Barker's novels, and contains many horror elements.
It was nominated in 1988 for the World Fantasy Award for Best Novel.

Jeffery Archer - Kane & Abel

Kane and Abel is a 1979 novel by British author Jeffrey Archer. The title and story is a play on the Biblical brothers, Cain and Abel. Released in the United Kingdom in 1979 and in the United States in February of 1980, the book was an international success. It reached No. 1 on the New York Times bestseller list and in 1985 was made into a CBS television miniseries titled Kane & Abel starring Peter Strauss as Rosnovski and Sam Neill as Kane.

Please vote for your choice of book, the poll ends this friday at midnight and the second book club begins on the 28th of April.

Rich
 
Just a quick question but would it not be better to have Ender's Game in there instead of Speaker for the Dead? I realise these books were picked by lottery (Which I was quick to support in the other thread and completely agree with) but it just seems silly to jump into the middle of a series instead of starting at the beginning.
 
No, because Speaker for the Dead is a much better book. Ender's Game made a good novella (for those who have read the original version) but an over-rated novel. If anything, the retelling in "Shadow of the Giant" is better. You don't need to have read it to understand Speaker. I have given Speaker to non-SF readers to try and they've got along with it quite happily. It's a much more "mainstream" book than Game.


M
 
I'd have to go with Speaker For The Dead of those options as I've already enjoyed reading Ender's Game and Xenocide so it gives me an excuse to buy that one.

However I think I've already got Weaveworld, I'll have to check later on tonight back at my folk's place.
 
No, because Speaker for the Dead is a much better book. Ender's Game made a good novella (for those who have read the original version) but an over-rated novel. If anything, the retelling in "Shadow of the Giant" is better. You don't need to have read it to understand Speaker. I have given Speaker to non-SF readers to try and they've got along with it quite happily. It's a much more "mainstream" book than Game.


M

Oh, okay. I haven't read any of them so just assumed jumping in in the middle would leave the reader lost.
 
August 1914 sounds like my kind of book. This might not be quite proper but that gets my vote.
May I be so impertinent as to ask how you conducted said lottery please? Just wondering really because I think tichard has done a fantastic job with what he's doing (Underboss votes anyone? ;)) and would like to know how he came up with this final list. Whatever happens I shall be reading this one as it strikes me as very interesting. All 20th century again though! (Moby Dick and the Dickens werent last time ok ok!) Hopefully number three will have no 20th century!!11
 
Ghostwritten from that list - I really enjoyed Cloud Atlas and have heard good things abour Ghostwritten. For a Solzhenitsyn book one of his others would be a better choice I think, the sci-fi one doesn't sound great, and I refuse to read a Jeffrey Archer book out of principle (and because I've heard they're tripe).

Where's the poll...?
 
I refuse to read a Jeffrey Archer book out of principle (and because I've heard they're tripe).

You're cutting your nose off to spite your face.

I picked that particular book up from a car boot sale about ten tears ago, having seen the miniseries when I was little. Since then I have read that book three times. It really does justify its bestseller status. I've tried a couple of his other books and didn't rate them but Kane & Abel is a classic.
 
Well, I just finished Catch 22 - so hopefully a mod will weave there magic and make the poll appear, I did email earlier today but no joy.

Personally this month not too fussed but then again they seem novels I would not usually choice and maybe that is a good thing, new literary styles and broadening the horizon.

Rich
 
Well, I just finished Catch 22 - so hopefully a mod will weave there magic and make the poll appear, I did email earlier today but no joy.

Personally this month not too fussed but then again they seem novels I would not usually choice and maybe that is a good thing, new literary styles and broadening the horizon.

Rich

That's why I thought it would be a bad idea to have any one person choose the books because no matter how they tried they'd probably end up picking the same/similar genres.

Same here though, they don't look like books I'd ordinarily pick up and read though that was the case with Catch-22 and I am enjoying that.
 
I've read Kane & Abel many times - it's one of my favourite books (big Jeffrey Archer fan) - and would vote for this to encourage more people to read it as it's a truely fantastically written book.
 
i've added the poll for you and set it to expire in 3 days (ie 2.18pm on saturday) since there was no option to expire at midnight on fri night. give any mod a shout when you want it closing though (note: ill prob not be around at that time)
 
Hmmm now, we seem to have a tie, we can go down two routes.

A)Read both (as you can read one or the other) and cover all ground.
B)Vote again.

Personally option B is silly - and think that we should choose which we want to read and discuss it from there.

Rich
 
Back
Top Bottom