So, Ferrari were 'not exactly following the spirit of the rules' then?

Soldato
Joined
1 Jun 2013
Posts
9,315
So it's looking to me that the Ferrari engine had all the systems in place to enable some sort of fuel-flow related cheat, but Ferrari said "yeah, but we never used it, and you can't prove that we did".
 
Soldato
Joined
15 Feb 2003
Posts
10,052
Location
Europe
Very likely. This is a huge bargaining chip for them.

Good for them. I don't really believe in governing bodies. After-all it's just a bunch of people who got together and decided we are the governing body for such and such. In the modern world they've become too large and too corrupt.

And to think less than a decade ago I used to do research for some of the UKs largest sporting governing bodies. ha.
 
Caporegime
Joined
28 Feb 2004
Posts
74,822
It wouldn't because the FIA don't use official public courts or anything has anything to do with actual laws of the land. Instead they make up their own like the International Court of Appeal and International Tribunal. these are private FIA 'courts; with little to do with real laws.

It's a bit like when the FIA's kangaroo court or in this case the so called 'World Council' issued a lifetime ban to Flavio Briatorie, who then took the FIA to an actual real court


If the other teams take the legal action they mention, it will be in full public courts, NOT any of the "FIA courts"
 
Caporegime
Joined
28 Feb 2004
Posts
74,822
The FIA have not declared the car legal? This is the whole point of the argument.
They wouldn't have to make the actual technology used public so there would be no copying of anything, all they needed to say was 'the car was found to be legal/illegal' which they haven't, they have instead dodged around it with cryptic and suspicious statements.

This is the whole point of all the backlash.


I never said the FIA declared the car legal.
 
Caporegime
Joined
28 Feb 2004
Posts
74,822
No one needs the fia.

Wonder if the teams will now hold off signing the 2021 contacts?


As others said before, without the FIA there is no Formula One.

Obviously the teams could all get together with liberty media and create a brand new series, with brand new rules and regulations, (another try at A1 series anyone?) but it could never be called Formula One.
 
Soldato
Joined
17 Jul 2007
Posts
24,529
Location
Solihull-Florida
As others said before, without the FIA there is no Formula One.

Obviously the teams could all get together with liberty media and create a brand new series, with brand new rules and regulations, (another try at A1 series anyone?) but it could never be called Formula One.


The F1 name is owned by Liberty Media\Formula One Group. http://www.libertymedia.com/companies/formula-one-group.html

The fis sets some of the rules and what tracks they can race on.
F1 does not need the fia. With all the money the fia charge the drivers and teams each year.
The Formula One Group could have the money instead and do there own rules.

The fia has been corrupt for at least 40 years.
 
Soldato
Joined
18 Oct 2002
Posts
4,267
Location
Lunatic asylum
Nice easy-to-read and understand aticle here.

https://f1-insider.com/en/formula1/fia-and-ferrari-drag-f1-in-its-deepest-crisis/

I think what were dodgy moments last year are now very much more relevant such as Leclerc was found to have almost 5kg too much fuel in his car for the Abu Dhabi GP, which Ferrari blamed on a 'measuring' mistake, suspiciously Leclerc was allowed to keep his starting position, but worse still (for us conspiracy theorists), the FIA 'didn't think' to check Vettels car for the same 'oversight'.

The whole thing just stinks of corruption.
 
Soldato
Joined
6 Aug 2010
Posts
5,631
Location
Birmingham
I doubt it too, the FIA aren't going to want to pee Ferrari off by giving more information. Entirely of their own making but the FIA are in a bad position - Do they want to face legal action from Ferrari for breaching the confidentiality agreement? Or face legal action from all the non-Ferrari teams over the failure to deal with the Ferrari PU issue.
 
Man of Honour
Joined
9 Jan 2010
Posts
13,722
I don't really believe in governing bodies. After-all it's just a bunch of people who got together and decided we are the governing body for such and such. In the modern world they've become too large and too corrupt.

Can we keep this thread for F1 chat please, there are other threads on this forum if you want to talk about the European Union

:p
 
Caporegime
Joined
26 Dec 2003
Posts
25,666
It'll probably die down now, the teams will use it as leverage over the FIA and get some kind of deal they're happy with themselves and that will be the end of it I expect. F1 operates more like the corporate world than a sport. The public only gets to see a fraction of what goes on.
 
Caporegime
Joined
17 Jul 2010
Posts
25,735
"Mercedes is no longer part of the ‘gang of seven’ teams which was pressing the FIA over its settlement with Ferrari over last year’s investigation into the legality of its power unit."

https://www.racefans.net/2020/03/17...ontinue-fia-fight-over-power-unit-settlement/

IF it's true.
Then Merc has thrown Wolf to the dogs(sorry about the pun)
Or Mercedes have been told/have found out and realised they're doing what Ferrari were and have decided they don't want investigated themselves.
 
Soldato
Joined
18 Oct 2002
Posts
15,203
Location
The land of milk & beans
An Italian source says that agreement was then struck between Kallenius (chairman of Daimler) and Ferrari CEO Louis Camilleri due to the “bigger picture”. Daimler, BMW and Fiat are believed to be cooperating on autonomous car technologies, while Elkann was concerned that the mud-flinging was damaging Formula 1’s image.
I want to know what dirt Ferrari have on everyone so that every time they have a quiet word in someone's ear, be it an FIA rep or a Merc exec, they get what they want. Every god damn time.
 
Soldato
Joined
22 Nov 2002
Posts
2,738
Location
South UK
Or Mercedes have been told/have found out and realised they're doing what Ferrari were and have decided they don't want investigated themselves.
Rubbish!

Wolff has long been rumoured to be leaving Mercedes for RP/Aston Martin. Wolff was very angry about it(Ferrari), Mercedes as a manufacturer weren't that interested as they had won the championship and therefor wouldn't gain much, if anything, anyway - all the other teams would gain millions *if* Ferrari were booted from the championship.
 
Soldato
Joined
15 Feb 2003
Posts
10,052
Location
Europe
Rubbish!

Wolff has long been rumoured to be leaving Mercedes for RP/Aston Martin. Wolff was very angry about it(Ferrari), Mercedes as a manufacturer weren't that interested as they had won the championship and therefor wouldn't gain much, if anything, anyway - all the other teams would gain millions *if* Ferrari were booted from the championship.

How can you say MissChief's post is rubbish unless you privvy to some information that hasn't been released to the public?
 
Soldato
Joined
1 Jun 2013
Posts
9,315
How can you say MissChief's post is rubbish unless you privvy to some information that hasn't been released to the public?

There's nothing in the article that even hints at that. If we're all going to start making **** up, might as well say that Mercedes pulled out because Ferrari have got pictures of Ola Kallenius taking part in a Tijuana donkey show. Makes just as much sense, and there's just as much evidence of it.

If Mercedes were doing the same cheat (and I don't believe for a second they were), then how come they were obviously slower than the Ferrari, until Ferrari were called on their cheating, and then the Mercedes didn't get faster, the Ferrari got slower.

What happened was Ferrari threw their toys out of the pram behind the scenes, and Mercedes decided to let it go because of the money involved in their joint business projects outside of F1. Mercedes F1 still beat Ferrari and won't be getting any more prize money regardless of Ferrari getting booted from the 2019 results.
 
Back
Top Bottom