• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

Solar panels and battery - any real world recommendations?

Whatever you decide to install, you'd want the ROI to be under 10 years. The lower the better (obvs :cry: )
The best ROI setup was 9 years 3 months, that was for 12 panels (6 front, 6 back).

I'm glad for your advice.

Given I'm planning on staying here for 10-15 years maybe, it makes a lot of sense.
 
Last edited:
The best ROI setup was 9 years 3 months, that was for 12 panels (6 front, 6 back).
The reason why most of us say 10 years for ROI is because the inverter and battery warranty runs out at 10 years. So if it dies at 10 years +1 day, there will be an additional cost incurred for replacement of these parts.
Basically, you'd want the system to pay back itself before there is potential to incur additional costs. If you'd never get back the initial cost over the lifetime of the system then it's a bad monetary investment...you could choose to install it for other reasons if you wish though (ya tree-huggin' sheep-shaggin vegan :P )
 
Last edited:
Parents Solaredge inverter became unresposive on Thursday morning. I had a play with it Friday and it seemed like no power at all. Checked all the breakers etc. Feared worst case, that the inverter had died. Installer has been out this morning, turns out the inverter is ok, but the export meter may have seen better days :eek:

WhatsApp Image 2026-10-29 at 12.28.21.webp
 
You need to create an account on Solis Cloud and pair the dongle on the inverter with that account. You can do both of these things in the app, you pair the dongle by scanning the QR code on the dongle (or box) and job jobbed. It takes 5 mins.

Hopefully they installed it in a way which means it blinded to your EV charger so that is not possible (assuming you asked for this).
This is what I did in the end up.
I had a scheduled follow up phone call with the office staff yesterday and they gave me the info for the app and said I could work away.

It was a good job too because the EV charger wasn’t blinded from the inverter.
I was able to set up a charging window from 1-8am when I get my cheap overnight rate. I set the charging amps to 0 though because I didn’t want the battery charging from the grid (even at the lower rate) as there is more than enough daytime solar generation to take care of said charging.
 
You're lucky the damage was contained to the CU!

At least it's a relatively easy thing to fix, wonder what caused it though, might have been a faulty meter, or the cables weren't installed into it correctly.
 
This is what I did in the end up.
I had a scheduled follow up phone call with the office staff yesterday and they gave me the info for the app and said I could work away.

It was a good job too because the EV charger wasn’t blinded from the inverter.
I was able to set up a charging window from 1-8am when I get my cheap overnight rate. I set the charging amps to 0 though because I didn’t want the battery charging from the grid (even at the lower rate) as there is more than enough daytime solar generation to take care of said charging.
Is your EV in your normal CU, or does it have it's own? If it has it's own, it's likely to be fairly easy to move the CT so the inverter is blinded from it. If you can post a picture of your CU & surrounding bits, we'll be able to tell you where to move the CT to, if it's possible.
 
Is your EV in your normal CU, or does it have it's own? If it has it's own, it's likely to be fairly easy to move the CT so the inverter is blinded from it. If you can post a picture of your CU & surrounding bits, we'll be able to tell you where to move the CT to, if it's possible.
The issue I suspect I may encounter with that approach is that I have two consumer boards (one for upstairs and one for downstairs) plus an extra dedicated unit for the charger.
I may be wrong, but my limited circuitry knowledge leads me to believe that there’s nowhere to place the CT clamp (other than at the main tails) which would ensure the inverter sees the load from both upstairs and downstairs in the house?

*Edit* Although I’m guessing this could all be resolved by just adding an additional clamp..?
 
Last edited:
Almost all solar inverters only allow one clamp to measure import/export.

It depends on how the upstairs and downstairs board are connected. If upstairs comes off downstairs and downstairs goes to the meter it can be done.

If all 3 boards all connect in the same place, probably not with out adding in a second junction box just after the meter for the EV charger only.
 
Last edited:
As @b0rn2sk8 has said, it'll depend how your junction boxes are configured.

I have 2 junction boxes for mine so my connections go:
Code:
                                   - EV Charger CU
Incoming supply - Connection block - Link cable with CT - Connection block - Main CU
                                                                           - Solar CU

Means the CT only sees the current to the main CU & Solar CU, and doesn't see the EV charger. You'd need similar. Could you request your installer modifies things similar to this? If not, it's not a lot of work for another electrician to do, but because of the small amount, it'll be disproportionately expensive, as most won't think it's worth their time.
 
You're lucky the damage was contained to the CU!

At least it's a relatively easy thing to fix, wonder what caused it though, might have been a faulty meter, or the cables weren't installed into it correctly.
Indeed, easier than it being the inverter! The system is just over 2 years old, so not sure. I would have thought a loose connection would have shown before now. Who knows.
 
Indeed, easier than it being the inverter! The system is just over 2 years old, so not sure. I would have thought a loose connection would have shown before now. Who knows.
It’s 99% a loose connection.


The heat cycles can gradually loosen the termination which wasn’t fully torqued up and eventually it will get hotter and hotter then eventually you get melting and in rare cases, fire.

I had an issue with a loose connection on my install which didn’t present itself for well over a year.

Fortunately no damage and a quick snip and re-terminate fixed it because I caught it early. The installer was all over it and quite rightly made it right with absolutely zero fuss and plenty of apologies.
 
Which company did you go with for fitting? as i know you are local.
Hi Johnny, we live in midwales now and we're more local to Telford so we used Craig Michael Renewables.
Some issues with the order to start as the panels we'd ordered became unavailable so we went for 490w Aiko's.
The fitting team were really good and communication was good, and we'll be going back for a gateway and another battery at some point.
Had some teething troubles to do with setup but that was me playing with the app. They could see what I had done and advised.
Overall a good experience.
 
Last edited:
But do think it I need to delve deeper into this, using real numbers

I'd previously dismissed Agile export for exactly the reasons that b0rn2sk8 mentions, I export a huge amount over the summer months, I think the most I generated in one day was 85 kWh, but can export more due to dumping batteries in the evening

I've looked at this a few times, but cant beat the flat 12p export. The problem as you mention, is that you tend to export most when the price is low on Agile. This can be avoided a bit by either not filling the battery overnight and letting it charge in the day when the export rate is low, or force exporting early on and doing the same. The issue is that with "only" 27kWh, you can have days in summer where you're sending out 50kWh for next to nothing before the evening 4-7pm window. The flat rate wins out then

I finally ran the numbers, downloaded my data for the last 12 months, and also the outgoing Agile rates. Bit of a faff doing it in a spreadsheet, but got there in the end. With my current export pattern Agile export was slightly better than the flat rate, about 1% better over the last 12 months.

To double check I used Octopus Compare, once I'd persuaded it redownload my data, as the first time half my export was missing it came to the same conclusion, in fact both times it was the same conclusion, about 1% better, but for year to date it's almost 3% better, likely due to reduced export in November and December, which will pull it back down.

I'm sure if the system was optimised for Agile it woukd be substantially better.

The big question is, is worth it? I have a system that works very well, and is pretty simple. I'd either have roll my own system or use Predbat or,Victron DESS.

I think even a basic system where I export more in the peak 16:00 to 19:00 hours would payoff, that would be very easy to setup, just involves adding another schedule and target SOC to my current schedules.
 
You also have to remember that Ron’s system is also more suited to this than typical.

He has an huge amount of potential storage capacity and panels which face all orientations which spread out the generation over a longer part of the day.

For a more typical system with less raw storage, you’ll struggle to store enough energy to make up for the loss during peak generation.

There are potentially ways you can increase it though as the typical EV tariff approach is to time shift what you can to overnight. If the export rate of below 7p/kwh you can shift that back into the middle of the day.
 
Last edited:
I think it ultimately comes down to your solar to battery ratio and how flexible you can be with time shifting.
The more battery you have compared to solar and the more you can time shifts to when agile rates are low (e.g. car charging during the day) the more likely it is agile will be better.

But as Ron set out, there isn’t actually that much in it and you have to be ‘on it’ constantly.
 
Back
Top Bottom