Sony PRS-500 eBook Reader Review - many images

Soldato
Joined
31 Mar 2006
Posts
6,606
Location
Sydney Australia
Part 1

The Sony PRS-500 is an e-ink reader designed with the intention of eliminating the good old paper based book. I love reading books and since moving to this country I have more than filled a tall book case with books that I have purchased. The approximate value per book is £7 - £15 so I have over the last 3 years spent around £500 - £600.

Much like back in the day when I built my CD collection up to around 2000 CDs I reached a critical mass with both storage and portability. The answer to my CD situation was simple, buy an MP3 player. Problem solved.

Now Sony has presented us with a solution to the book/library issue, the answer not being that dissimilar to the MP3 payer, the ebook reader.

prsmobilecomparison.jpg


The PRS-500 uses a relatively new technology called e-ink. The 6inch diagonal screen is actually filled with small capsules containing charged pigment. When the charge applied to each capsule is adjusted, they will appear as black, white, or multiple shades of grey. Though the screen is designed primarily for text, it can also display drawings and photographs. The resolution is 800-by-600 and about 170 pixels per inch, which is more than sufficient for nice smooth letters. The display as no preferable reading angle and does not suffer from being in either dim light or bright sunshine any more than would a page in a book

technology_inkballs3.jpg


As yet this technology is in the beginning stages of development so its response time leaves something to be desired taking just under a second to turn a page but in terms of reading it is more than enough. The other down side is of course that it will not do colour however this is currently in development. The upside of eInk technology is that it does not require any power to retain the information on the display. The only time it uses any power is when it is actually changing something or flipping a page. Sony states that one charge will last a whopping estimated 7500 page turns. Since purchasing the reader around 3 weeks ago, I have only charged it once.

So on to the unit itself. Weighing in at 9 ounces or around 255 grams and measuring 175mm x 125mm x 10mm it is small enough and light enough to slip into a bag and not really notice the difference. Design wise it is not the most attractive of things, the main eyesore being the 5 way control on the bottom right of the face. Whilst being very usable it is far from aesthetically pleasing. The rest of the control layout in my opinion was not particularly well thought out although I will expand on this a little later.

The unit has 64MB on board storage which can be expanded via a memory slot on the side and accepts either the Sony Memory Stick, Memory Stick Pro or standard SD cards to a 2GB capacity. Top marks to Sony for using non proprietary storage media, a trend that we have started to see in most of their new devices such as their new DSLR and their MP3 players.

memoryslot.jpg


The Bottom of the unit contains the input connectors and the headphone jack socket. As you can see it accepts the standard mini USB jack as well as a Sony proprietary connector for the optional docking cradle. The cradle is personally an option I can do without as it really just adds another piece of plastic to my computer desk surface. The other input is for the charger which is just a standard transformer that will switch between 110V and 220/250V without issues. The transformer itself has a standard 2 pronged connector so you can swap it with the appropriate lead thus eliminating the need to buy a new power supply for every country you visit.

bottom.jpg


There are two controls on the side of the Reader, one being the rocker volume buttons and the other being the power switch.

side.jpg


The other controls are on the front of the Reader, two buttons on the left side to turn pages and a size button to change the size and rotate the displayed text and images. Along the bottom there is another larger button for turning pages, a mark button for marking the page where you left off in a book and also the 5 way controller for navigating through the menu system. Running along the bottom of the screen are 10 buttons which have various functions which I will go into in Part 2.

The PRS-500 will accept a decent range of text formats. Sony Style lists the compatible formats as follows: BBeB Book, Adobe® PDF, TXT, RTF, Microsoft® Word (Conversion to the Reader-requires Word installed on your PC). It will also handle MP3s however this greatly shortens its impressive battery life. Whilst not doing an impressive job at it the Reader will also display JPEGs but it does reduce them to a 4 Grey Scale image at a 170pixel resolution. This for me is not really an issue as I didn’t buy it as a photo storage device especially since I can quite happily fill my Nikon D80s 4GB in one shooting session.

Each eBook weighs in at around about 300-500KB so I can roughly fit 4000-7000 books (here’s hoping that my math stands up!) which far exceeds any real desired capacity. Of course once you start putting the larger PDFs and MP3s onto this the space does diminish at a significantly higher rate.
 
Part 2

Using the Sony Reader

Once you turn the Reader on you are presented with a menu screen with 10 options each of which can be either accessed by navigating with the 5 way controller or with a 10 buttons running along the bottom edge of the display. Personally I find the numbered buttons on the bottom to be the faster method of navigating through the menu as the 5 way controller is limited by the update rate of the display, so navigating to option 5 might take close on 4-5 seconds. This is just one of the restrictions caused by the technology. Perhaps in the future we will see the eInk in a touch screen format with hand writing recognition but at that stage it stops being a reader and starts drifting into the PDA convergence.

sony-reader-12.jpg

Taken from: http://the-gadgeteer.com/

As you can see you are presented with 10 options which allow you to selectively view the different aspects of your library; Books, By Author, By Date, Collections and All Bookmarks. I can see this as being useful as attempting to scroll through 7000 odd books could become quite tedious. By either moving the pointer down or selecting one of the associated numbers you are able to move on to the next level of options.

books.jpg


Again selecting the associated number or using the 5 way controller you move into the next menu option – in this case the book itself.

waroftheworldsmenu.jpg


The menu is pretty self explanatory and the learning curve for the device is very low. Much like a normal book you can bookmark where you are by pressing the Mark button which will then ‘fold’ the corner of the page for future reference, a very simple and effective setup. Ultimately having the option to actually highlight and note on the pages would make this a brilliant study tool but the reality of the technology is that it’s just not ready yet.

The major question with this device is, what is it like to read? There is a simple answer and a much more involved answer. The simple answer is that it is brilliant, the high contrast eInk has no optimum viewing angle, does not strain the eyes and is as easily visible in dim light as it is in bright. The lack of a backlight does make it a little more complex to use at night but this I have simply remedied by purchasing a book light. The more involved answer is related to the nature of the reading material itself.

The Reader has several viewing ‘modes’ and for the majority of the eBooks you load into it provides you with a Size option.

sony-reader-15.jpg
sony-reader-16.jpg
sony-reader-17.jpg


Depending on your eyesight and the quality of the light this is a very useful option. The reader also allows you to rotate the display for even larger text and splits a page vertically into 2. As an experiment I copied across a PDF copy of Tintin Destination Moon to have a look at how it dealt with both PDF images and colour conversion. Whilst not perfect it was quite readable and exhibits why the rotate option can be useful. Being a colour comic it does wash out a little in the grey scale and a comic that was black and white to start with would make for better reading.

destinationmoon.jpg
destinationmoonside.jpg


Where the Reader falls down is in its PDF capabilities. Due to the nature of PDF and Sony’s setup of the device, the Reader is unable reflow PDF documents. The unfortunate side effect of this is that the majority of reference documents are pretty much unreadable. When a PDF has been set up specifically for the device it is just brilliant. All page links work within the document and a PDF menu can be navigated using the 5 way controller.

So if using the Reader for reference is your intention then unfortunately this is a miss however I do not believe that this was ever Sony’s intention and as a replacement of the good old paperback it excels.

In conclusion the PRS-500 does what it says on the box – it lets you read eBooks and it does it extremely well. I am very impressed with it as a complete package especially when keeping in mind how young the technology is.

A personal mark of 8.5-9 out of 10
Awesome technology but still lacking in some areas – this is still early adopting stuff.
Pricing is around £250 on the bay but I found a second hand one for £130 from the States. Definitely cheaper to get one from the States rather than trying to find one over here.

Pros:
Massive book storage
Portability
Battery life
Rekindles the joy of reading again
Money saved in the long run

Cons:
No colour
No PDF reflow
No touch screen and annotating capability
Slow (ish) refresh time
Odd placement of buttons

The future

Sony have stopped manufacturing the PRS-500 in favour of the next iteration the PRS-505 which comes in silver or blue as opposed to the rather odd dark purple of the 500. In the 505 they have addressed many of the layout issues in the 500. They have moved the 10 menu buttons to correspond directly with the menu options and shifted the side page buttons to the right hand side which makes somewhat more sense to me. It also comes with twice the internal memory which is a nice add. The eInk display has also moved on a little and is supposedly somewhat whiter than the 500s with a much higher contrast. Will I be getting this one? Nope. Whilst being a bit prettier than the 500 it is still essentially the same device, no colour, no touch screen and no PDF reflow (until I find out otherwise) so I’ll be happily sticking with my PRS-500.

sony-prs-505-ebook-lg1.jpg


Colour?

Fujitsu have just recently showed a colour eInk prototype that pending decent reviews I’d drop the 500 in a heartbeat for. 4069 colours and weighing in a 6.2 ounces it trumps the Sony Reader in more ways than one.

fujitsu-ryu.jpg

Taken from: http://www.engadget.com/2006/10/05/fujitsu-shows-off-color-e-ink-tablet-concept/
 
Last edited:
nice one,

very interested in this, the better half keeps moaning about the amount of books i have,

One question, what formats does it support?

As in i see Mobipocket, Adobe eBook Reader and Microsoft Reader as the main formats on most of the ebook stores i have looked at.

Would it fully support any of the above? very tempted lol

Cheers
 
As described in part 1:

The PRS-500 will accept a decent range of text formats. Sony Style lists the compatible formats as follows: BBeB Book, Adobe® PDF, TXT, RTF, Microsoft® Word (Conversion to the Reader-requires Word installed on your PC). It will also handle MP3s however this greatly shortens its impressive battery life. Whilst not doing an impressive job at it the Reader will also display JPEGs but it does reduce them to a 4 Grey Scale image at a 170pixel resolution.

It is very easy to find converters to change the format of the .lit format (Microsoft ebook format). I use ABC Amber for converting http://www.processtext.com/abclit.html
The same company 'ABC' also make a converter for the Mobipocket format. Unfortunately I don't know about the Adobe format - I will have to do some research on that one.
 
I have just checked - the 505 is available for $299 USD so at current exchange rates is £147 + VAT and shipping. If you know someone over there I'd get them to buy it, unpack it and either bring it over or note it down on customs as being a gift.

They are on the Bay in the States for £137 plus shipping.
 
Last edited:
cheers,

noticed the one on auction, the 505, looks like a nice bit of kit.

Will have to run it past the missus first, spent quite a bit this month :(
 
cheers,

noticed the one on auction, the 505, looks like a nice bit of kit.

Will have to run it past the missus first, spent quite a bit this month :(

I think the general consensus is that if you already own a PRS there isn't really any point in upgrading to the new one as the changes are really not that significant however if you don't have one totally go for it. You will not be unhappy with it.
 
Not yet matey, gotta wait till beginning of next month, nice bonus coming in.

Also need to check that the books i want are available for it lol
 
Gonna bump this a little rather than start a new thread.

I was thinking of order one of the new Sony PRS-505, at £200 they seem a reasonable price. Just wondered if any one had any experience of the lastest batch of ebook readers and if there are many ebook available?

Cheers :)
 
Amazon in YankLand have had something like this for ages!

Amazon's one was called Kindle.

its weird how these things are only popular in America...
 
Last edited:
Amazon in YankLand have had something like this for ages!

Amazon's one was called Kindle.

its weird how these things are only popular in America...

Nah this was out at least a year before the Kindle.

Waterstone's in the UK are due to be selling the PR-505 at some point in September. I'm seriously tempted.

Great review BTW.

Thank you - it was written quite a while ago.

very true, a good read! no puns or anything like that...

Thank you also. Since this review I have not needed to 'upgrade' to the newer PRS-505 nor have I felt any pressure to shift to another piece of hardware. I have around 300 books on it and still entirely enjoy reading with it. I've taken it all over Europe and it will be coming to Egypt with me next week - it's so much more convenient than a book.

Cheers for all the kind comments guys.
 
Back
Top Bottom