To me it's a classic for the type of game it is, regardless of what anyone else tells me. People bang on about how Bioshock Infinite is a rare classic etc. well not for me it wasn't.
Same with movies, or any art form.
Actually this is a common logical fallacy. Just because you think something is a classic does not make it a classic, or vice versa. There are commonly accepted definitions, standards and measurements used to define this so it is not, as people like to try and argue, completely subjective.