Same here. I was looking forward to playing it but after getting killed umpteen times by the boss in the tutorial I gave up. I didn't like the control system but mostly, where was the incentive for me to try and beat the guy? No story yet, no intro, no nothing. Switched to Darksiders 3 and loving it.
I had this with Dark Souls 1. Tried to play it twice, each time got sick.
Third time I played it and wow. I got totally engrossed in the atmosphere of the game, the challenge, the moveset.. you appreciate all the little things. Even when I completed the game, I got googling about the lore. Its a really delicate game. Unlike other games, it really does reward skill and keeps things relatively simple. You can pretty much complete the game with most of the starter weapons aslong as you upgrade them. The lore and constant challenge and mystery was addictive.
Its definitely a proper hard core game tho.
I'm playing Witcher 3. Just heading to Skiellege now. Its pretty good. I've done most of Velen and Novigrad and its been good. The story is great, the side quests are the best I've seen in a video game. The actual world seems a bit too big and densely populated though. Its almost as if too much is going on.
After playing BOTW, Trails in the Sky and even Skyrim, Witcher 3 has a few flaws. Namely world building of NPCs other than the main cast. They just lack a lot of proper characterisation and for me this stems from the inability to talk to them outside of a specific quest line. Its sad because they tackle some awesome themes but walking down a street and having 10 people talk at the same time is just annoying. Also not being able to interact with the woman crying about her dead child or husband is just a bit annoying.
The towns are also just too big to the extent they're not memorable. Every street looks the same in Novigrad and I'm basically just using my mini-map all the time which is never a good sign of a game IMO. I hope after BOTW, more open world developers will now try to ditch the absolute reliance on mini maps to navigate.
Don't get me wrong, its shaping up to probably be one of my favourite games played because I'm invested in the Witcher universe and the world they've created is awesome. I think If I'd played this before BOTW, I'd be very very impressed. It destroys BOTW in regards to story + lore + characters but as a game, BOTW has a few really vital advantages over it.