When are you going fully electric?

lancia delta retro look.
not sure if you meant it in this way but i would say that is high praise indeed. The lancia delta is an absolute classic imo (that could be why i like the ionic 5 so much actually as i agree now you point it out, there is a bit of that in there)
 
Last edited:
I have had my 2021 Nissan Leaf Tekna for a couple of months now and it was completely the right move for me. I am getting a economy of £1.73 per 100 miles compared to around £13.50 per 100 miles in my old Ford B-Max 1.0 125hp (averaged 48mpg) and I still can't believe how little it's costing me to run it. Like far too many people I used to be against EV's for mainly bs reasons and I couldn't have been more wrong about them if I tried. It's so smooth and quiet, has more grunt than any car I have ever owned, is more comfortable than any car I have ever owned and is super economical to run. The Leaf doesn't exactly have a great range but it's more than enough for our use and will get us to and from Aberdeen and Inverness on a full charge (around 62 miles each way to both) which is the furthest I drive these days. I doubt if I could drive home to Cornwall from here (720 miles each way) in any car right now with the problems I have so that's a train journey anyway. Mostly it's just local trips between here and Elgin (35 mile round trip) and the odd trip to Huntly (around 44 miles round trip) so I don't need a EV with massive range. It was absoluetely the right move at the right time for me.
 
Anybody see the TV show last night called Petrol V Electric - Which Is Better?

Even me being an ICE owner thought 3 of the tests were stupid.

1) Father (ICE) v daughter (EV) have got to drive 100 miles to Colwyn bay but both cars filled to 25% so both needed to stop to fill up and of course the Father won by about 30 minutes.
This was totally unfair because both would 100% fill and drive there and back but with the ICE being way cheaper per mile.

2) A petrolhead trying ICE V EV on a track doing different things but the ICE won because of the noise :)
He admitted that both handled exceptionally, the EV could be marginally better but he preferred noise, that's not a way to win a point.

3) Second hand market.
Similar ICE was £2,500 cheaper than the EV so that was the winner.
Surely if you've got a brain in your head you would also work out the major advantages of the EV eg fuel cost, driving in the City, noise etc.

So basically the score was 3 V 3 but in my petrolhead opinion it was 6 v 0 to the EV.
 
imo the bias in the media is obvious.
There are some glaring reasons why EVs are just not ready for some people.... we all know this. Affordable destination charging simply has to get (a lot) better for those without the ability to charge at home
And brand new EVs are still too expensive for those who cant get the sweet company car/lease deals....

and whilst its possible with the right car, people who tow a lot, EVs are still a bigger headache than an ICE car

These things need to be talked about and improved on.

but so many of the other issues with EVs are either just pure BS or are people desperately scrabbling round for edge case, people using the wrong car for the job or starting from a position that no sensible EV driver ever would.

the complaint about EVs weigh too much...... cars have been putting on weight for donkeys years, when it is a range rover no one bats an eyelid, but when its an EV suddenly heavy EVs are to blame for our crap roads and car parks are gonna collapse.

ICE car makers have been trying to make cars quiet for ever (outside of the obvious types where loud is part of the goal) but now EVs are dangerous because too quiet.

ICE cars have been improving 0-60 times since for ever, but now EVs are so fast they are dangerous, and damage the roads.
Also now, 0-60 time is no longer important... it is about the "soul" of the car, which apparently can only be gotten from internal combustion.

and then that is ignoring the flat out lies such as EVs having more brake dust pollution and EVs being more likely to set on fire.

I do like the smell of petrol tho, so i guess i miss that ;) (not sure many would say the same for diesel however)
 
Last edited:
Anybody see the TV show last night called Petrol V Electric - Which Is Better?

Even me being an ICE owner thought 3 of the tests were stupid.

1) Father (ICE) v daughter (EV) have got to drive 100 miles to Colwyn bay but both cars filled to 25% so both needed to stop to fill up and of course the Father won by about 30 minutes.
This was totally unfair because both would 100% fill and drive there and back but with the ICE being way cheaper per mile.

2) A petrolhead trying ICE V EV on a track doing different things but the ICE won because of the noise :)
He admitted that both handled exceptionally, the EV could be marginally better but he preferred noise, that's not a way to win a point.

3) Second hand market.
Similar ICE was £2,500 cheaper than the EV so that was the winner.
Surely if you've got a brain in your head you would also work out the major advantages of the EV eg fuel cost, driving in the City, noise etc.

So basically the score was 3 V 3 but in my petrolhead opinion it was 6 v 0 to the EV.

Have to consider target audience.

The 3rd one. Its a really really silly test, not just for the reasons you put.
The initial cost difference is for most somewhat irrelevant. Its the lifetime cost which includes depreciation you need to consider.
ICE basically go to zero, EV arent going to. Quite what the minimum will be we will see, but there is a lot of value in even fairly heavily degraded EV batteries.

I suppose the first one you can argue is an unexpected trip after work type scenario.
I mean we all know that an Ev takes longer to charge (very model dependent) but its a real world scenario that you may get home and then suddenly need to do a decent journey. Eg parents need help, son/daughter, you know that sort of thing.

Noise. Its a funny thing (like smell also). I always think that its because people are already pre conditioned to accept and hence the sound of a nicer engine, or oddly the smell of petrol trigger good feelings.
I cannot imagine how hard a sell it would be for the majority used to EV motoring were we ditching EV to move to fossil. The vast vast majority aren't going to consider the sound a positive in an ICE.
 
(I'd rather be in Elgin, it's a better class of cold and wet - listen to that in car regularly)

not sure if you meant it in this way but i would say that is high praise indeed
yes as a compliment, but I thought opel ev front better captured that design on a normal sized saloon .. and Renault 5 is doing even better.
 
Channel 5 programme was a farce. Unplugging your car at 25% from your home charger? Give me a break.

Thought ioniq 6 looks like a poor mans rip of of the mercedes cls shape, and it's an impractical saloon, not a hatch (we don't have everything delivered by amazon in the UK, yet)
Ioniq 5 up close is massive/chunky, opel ev stole the lancia delta retro look.

Nio ET5 touring I'd pick as standout Chinese/Korean design.

isnt it a cheaper car, of a different brand with a different engine type. Nothing poor mans about that.

Rest is just inside mind ramblings that frankly dont need to see a keyboard. You are picking car that dont exist. like what?
 
Last edited:
imo the bias in the media is obvious.
There are some glaring reasons why EVs are just not ready for some people.... we all know this. Affordable destination charging simply has to get (a lot) better for those without the ability to charge at home
And brand new EVs are still too expensive for those who cant get the sweet company car/lease deals....

and whilst its possible with the right car, people who tow a lot, EVs are still a bigger headache than an ICE car

These things need to be talked about and improved on.

but so many of the other issues with EVs are either just pure BS or are people desperately scrabbling round for edge case, people using the wrong car for the job or starting from a position that no sensible EV driver ever would.

the complaint about EVs weigh too much...... cars have been putting on weight for donkeys years, when it is a range rover no one bats an eyelid, but when its an EV suddenly heavy EVs are to blame for our crap roads and car parks are gonna collapse.

ICE car makers have been trying to make cars quiet for ever (outside of the obvious types where loud is part of the goal) but now EVs are dangerous because too quiet.

ICE cars have been improving 0-60 times since for ever, but now EVs are so fast they are dangerous, and damage the roads.
Also now, 0-60 time is no longer important... it is about the "soul" of the car, which apparently can only be gotten from internal combustion.

and then that is ignoring the flat out lies such as EVs having more brake dust pollution and EVs being more likely to set on fire.

I do like the smell of petrol tho, so i guess i miss that ;) (not sure many would say the same for diesel however)
The heavy EVs damaging roads is just a big load of BS. Cars have been heavy for years, not to mention the trucks and lorries using the roads every day that are so so much heavier, but apparently they don't matter.

It's just silly the reasons people try to invent for EVs being bad.
 
I called the Ionic 5 back when people were drooling over it when it was released, ugly thing.

It’s not quite Fiat Multipla or what ever that was called but it was never going to age well.

It’s bit like those houses people have retrofitted grey UPVC double glazing (and new builds!), in 20 years we’re going to look back and use the phrase ‘what were they thinking’.

It's definitely a marmite car. I actually love the looks of the ionic 5! The wife on the other hand.... will see who wins the battle when it comes to picking up a 2nd hand car in a couple of years ha
 
Anybody see the TV show last night called Petrol V Electric - Which Is Better?

Even me being an ICE owner thought 3 of the tests were stupid.

1) Father (ICE) v daughter (EV) have got to drive 100 miles to Colwyn bay but both cars filled to 25% so both needed to stop to fill up and of course the Father won by about 30 minutes.
This was totally unfair because both would 100% fill and drive there and back but with the ICE being way cheaper per mile.

2) A petrolhead trying ICE V EV on a track doing different things but the ICE won because of the noise :)
He admitted that both handled exceptionally, the EV could be marginally better but he preferred noise, that's not a way to win a point.

3) Second hand market.
Similar ICE was £2,500 cheaper than the EV so that was the winner.
Surely if you've got a brain in your head you would also work out the major advantages of the EV eg fuel cost, driving in the City, noise etc.

So basically the score was 3 V 3 but in my petrolhead opinion it was 6 v 0 to the EV.
Did you spot the acceleration test faux pas?
They put the cars on a track with 1 side wet and the other side bone dry.
The outcome would have been the same but not an apple for apples situation.
 
I have had my 2021 Nissan Leaf Tekna for a couple of months now and it was completely the right move for me. I am getting a economy of £1.73 per 100 miles compared to around £13.50 per 100 miles in my old Ford B-Max 1.0 125hp (averaged 48mpg) and I still can't believe how little it's costing me to run it. Like far too many people I used to be against EV's for mainly bs reasons and I couldn't have been more wrong about them if I tried. It's so smooth and quiet, has more grunt than any car I have ever owned, is more comfortable than any car I have ever owned and is super economical to run. The Leaf doesn't exactly have a great range but it's more than enough for our use and will get us to and from Aberdeen and Inverness on a full charge (around 62 miles each way to both) which is the furthest I drive these days. I doubt if I could drive home to Cornwall from here (720 miles each way) in any car right now with the problems I have so that's a train journey anyway. Mostly it's just local trips between here and Elgin (35 mile round trip) and the odd trip to Huntly (around 44 miles round trip) so I don't need a EV with massive range. It was absoluetely the right move at the right time for me.
You should see the replies to my 2016 thread about trading in an Audi TT for a Nissan Leaf. :p

It belongs in the far reaches of the 'Seriously Un Cool' section of the cool wall. But as a purely functional piece of machinery, it's very hard to beat. The amount I've saved over the past 8 years compared to what I was spending on cars previously has made a huge difference to my quality of life.
 
i just hope the production N vision 74 is close to the concept version (though with proper electric propulsion)

Lets hope so because the main negative to the Ioniq 5 N for me was that it has zero desirability in the looks department, no wow factor, and of course at £65k, its a strong ask to sit in something that is not great looking and has a budget interior despite a software defined driving experience that blows every other EV I have driven away. You can let one thing slide sometime for a generally good thing but not too many things.

2) A petrolhead trying ICE V EV on a track doing different things but the ICE won because of the noise :)
He admitted that both handled exceptionally, the EV could be marginally better but he preferred noise, that's not a way to win a point.

Feedback is a big part of the driving experience.
 
Last edited:
To be fair any TV show comparing ICE to EV is always going to swing one way and if we're being honest it gives greater viewing figures on both sides for different reasons.

As a tribal species we love to clan up wherever possible. City vs United, Left vs Right, Petrol vs Electric... pathetic really but we are what we are I guess.
 
Anybody see the TV show last night called Petrol V Electric - Which Is Better?

Even me being an ICE owner thought 3 of the tests were stupid.

1) Father (ICE) v daughter (EV) have got to drive 100 miles to Colwyn bay but both cars filled to 25% so both needed to stop to fill up and of course the Father won by about 30 minutes.
This was totally unfair because both would 100% fill and drive there and back but with the ICE being way cheaper per mile.

2) A petrolhead trying ICE V EV on a track doing different things but the ICE won because of the noise :)
He admitted that both handled exceptionally, the EV could be marginally better but he preferred noise, that's not a way to win a point.

3) Second hand market.
Similar ICE was £2,500 cheaper than the EV so that was the winner.
Surely if you've got a brain in your head you would also work out the major advantages of the EV eg fuel cost, driving in the City, noise etc.

So basically the score was 3 V 3 but in my petrolhead opinion it was 6 v 0 to the EV.
I saw it mentioned but knew it would be trash so skipped it.
 
Back
Top Bottom