Golf is overpriced, and the older style Civic diesel isn't that nice.
Newer Civic diesel is a nice car (I've got one, and a Fabia vRS). Engine is much more progressive than the Fabia vRS's - wider spread of power, slightly better mpg, less tractorish. Service intervals are further apart (12.5k vs 10k), but servicing seems to be expensive so far.
Spec is generally not too bad on these. I've got a Type S and it'a got alcantara seats, 6 speed gearbox, ESP, mp3 cd player, climate control, air con, CAT 1 alarm, 17" alloys, fairly simple computer for mpg etc. Not amazing, and all fairly standard these days, but the MP3 CD player and Climate control is a nice touch as standard. Doesn't have fog lights as standard which is strange.
Compared to the Fabia it's a bigger car inside, bigger boot, more comfortable and feels much more modern. Ride is quite bumpy. Inside/dash is very different - I like it, a lot don't and it'll probably age badly. Plastics quality could be better, but it appears well screwed together so far.
I like it - but I wish I'd bought an Octavia vRS TDi instead.
