Xbox One X - Loud varying fan, overheating even after paste replacement

Associate
Joined
3 Jul 2020
Posts
2
Hi all,

I bought an early Xbox One X secondhand. It works mostly fine, but playing any sort of graphically demanding game turns it into a hairdryer. I've replaced the paste 3 times with varying amounts and different thermal pads. No matter what I do, I can't get the thing to shut up. The console itself doesn't feel hot or even warm, it has great ventilation and tons of air coming out the back, but no matter what the fan is varying it's speed constantly between 70-100% if I had to guess a level. It's like it can't decide between 90-95% so it keeps cycling between the two every second or half second. Sitting on the home screen or watching 4k content it is silent, but demanding games make it crank.

I'd been living with it like this since I bought it back in the winter, but recently with the warmer weather it started to shut down with the overheating/poor ventilation message. I thought maybe the thermal pads I used were too thick and the heatsink wasn't making good contact so I went with thinner pads and that doesn't seem to have helped. I also tried doing a clean install of the OS thinking maybe it was a software bug.

Does anybody have any ideas? Could the fan be faulty? It seems like odd behavior for a bad fan since its definitely moving a good amount of air and is spinning freely. It's almost like the console thinks it's overheating, but it doesn't feel or seem like it actually would be.

I consider myself pretty technically inclined when it comes to electronics like this, but I'm stumped. I don't want to keep sinking money and time into this console, but I also want to play it.

Thank you in advance!
 
Associate
Joined
3 Jul 2020
Posts
2
It's starting to look that way. I just tried to play on a cooling pad with the case off and couldn't make it through one game of PUBG. I stripped it down real quick and the heatsink is almost burning hot. So I guess it's making good contact, but for some reason the APU is toasting itself. The fan is definitely working with a ton of airflow.
 
Soldato
Joined
16 Jul 2009
Posts
5,121
My Xbox One X has sounded like a plane taking off for a long time depending on what game I'm playing; some stuff just doesn't trigger it (Snooker '19) but COD: Warzone and F1 make a helicopter sound quiet.
Never thought about re-pasting or anything though; its never died on me or cut of so I assume its not over-heating.
 
Caporegime
Joined
17 Oct 2002
Posts
25,506
Location
Lancs/London
Mine does this as far as the fan sounding like a jet (never shut off however), I sent it to MS for a 'fix' and it still does it.
 
Soldato
Joined
14 Sep 2009
Posts
8,976
Location
Northumberland
There must be a bigger issue than simply paste for that console, unfortunately. Mine is very quiet and runs reasonably hot. For comparison, it is much quieter than a PS4 Pro and runs cooler too.
 
Soldato
Joined
24 Dec 2004
Posts
18,390
Location
Telford
Tbh it sounds knackered. I have 3 one x’s and all are silent or no more than a feint whoosh. Even my launch day model is silent. My Pro sounds like it’s about to jump into a new dimension though....
 
Associate
Joined
10 Jul 2020
Posts
42
Location
Edinburgh
Tbh it sounds knackered. I have 3 one x’s and all are silent or no more than a feint whoosh. Even my launch day model is silent. My Pro sounds like it’s about to jump into a new dimension though....

This. I have seen very few X one X’s that aren’t near silent.
My PS4 pro on the other hand is so noisy that it makes me play it less than I would normally.
 
Soldato
Joined
12 Jun 2005
Posts
2,812
Location
A lake!
I did mine recently and didn’t put enough paste on, I went in PC-style with a very thin layer but that caused the fan to go mental. I re-applied a slightly thicker layer and all is well again.
 
Soldato
Joined
18 Oct 2002
Posts
4,090
Location
Nottingham
Mines a launch day project Scorpio and the fans are fairly loud. No where silent as others suggest.

I did send it away couple of years ago for repair under warranty but it came back the same.
 
Soldato
Joined
16 Nov 2003
Posts
5,026
So mine never crashes or anything but in certain places in certain games the fan will go to max. (Already taken it apart and re-thermal pasted it.) The times i've noticed it go to the max are when i talk to the Drifter in Destiny 2 and at the menu screen in COD Warzone when the characters are walking forward towards you. The funny thing is, the fan doesn't get anywhere near close to these moments when playing the actual games themselves. I hear it get louder just nowhere near the max. Its odd...
 
Soldato
Joined
14 Sep 2009
Posts
8,976
Location
Northumberland
This. I have seen very few X one X’s that aren’t near silent.
My PS4 pro on the other hand is so noisy that it makes me play it less than I would normally.

I only play the Pro with my GSP 600's on and they have incredible noise isolation. However, it's still really audible unless the sound starts to ramp up...

I'd say the Xbox seems to be a little bit of a lottery, where you're unlucky if you get a loud one.
 
Associate
Joined
15 Sep 2021
Posts
1
Location
Uk
I know this is an old thread, but I had same prob as OP. Done pads and paste but still overheating. Noticed a little moisture on the cpu, turns out the vapour chamber had a pin hole in it. Got 2nd hand one off ebay and now it works
 
Associate
Joined
18 Jul 2009
Posts
1,094
Location
Tividale, West Midlands
I know this is an old thread, but I had same prob as OP. Done pads and paste but still overheating. Noticed a little moisture on the cpu, turns out the vapour chamber had a pin hole in it. Got 2nd hand one off ebay and now it works

I was about to suggest to the OP that the vapour chamber had sprung a leak...Paste would not fix that issue.
 
Top Bottom