Poll: BOTW Weekly Results Round H - Human

Is Ahleckz beer entry valid?


  • Total voters
    29
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
Caporegime
Joined
17 Oct 2006
Posts
25,703
34hc5e0.jpg




Round H - Human



The Results:

Ahleckz - Bute Brew Co. **** Up Your Beaver
Ahleckz.jpg


Anchundan - Atlanta Laughing Skull Amber Ale
Anchundan.jpg


bam0 - Yellow Belly Sundae
bam0.jpg


Bickaxe - Badger Tangle Foot
Bickaxe.jpg


Bobmunkhouse - Badger Tangle Foot
Bobmunkhouse.jpg


deej - The Orkney Brewery Skull Splitter
deej_BOTW_H.jpg


DirtyJester - Beavertown Neck Oil Session IPA
Dirty_Jester.jpg


Executive_Beef - Beavertown Neck Oil Session IPA
Executive_Beef.jpg


Feek - ****faced
Feek.jpg


Gilly - Daleside Old Leg Over
Gilly.jpg


Janesy_B - Wild Card Brewery King of Hearts
Janesy_B.jpg


Jokester - Woodforde's Norfolk Ales Head Cracker
Jokester.jpg


Kaptainmarc - Beavertown Neck Oil Session IPA
Kaptainmarc.jpg


Kennysevenfold - Beavertown Neck Oil Session IPA
Kennysevenfold.jpg


Kuros - K*ntish Town Beard Weird Beard
Kuros.jpg


lego - Pistonhead Kustom Lager
lego.jpg


Maccy - Hogs Back Brewery co. T-E-A
Maccy.jpg


Mrs_Seabiscuit - Wild Card Brewery King Of Hearts
Mrs_Sea.jpg


Nyvo - Shepherd Neame Bishops Finger
nyvo.jpg


Pingwing - Vocation Brewery Heart & Soul
Pingwing.jpg


R-evans - Block 15 Sticky Hands Hop Experience Ale
R_evans.jpg


Raptor - Theakston Lightfoot
Raptor.jpg


rubberduck - Badger Tangle Foot
Rubberduck.jpg


Russinating - Odell Brewing Cutthroat Porter
Russinating.jpg


Seabiscuit - Beavertown Neck Oil Session IPA
Seabiscuit_H_Human.jpg


Sonea_Fifer - Inveralmond Brewery Thrappledouser
Sonea_Fifer.jpg


Street - Mad Hatter Breweries Sorachi Face Hugger
Street.jpg


The_Abyss - The Orkney Brewery Skull Splitter
The_Abyss.jpg


the_r_sole - Horns Brewing Co. Stiff Upper Lip
the_r_sole.jpg


timmeh - Bells Two Hearted Ale
timmeh.jpg


Touch - Stewart Brewing - Skeleton Blues
touch.jpg



Points Awarded:

Street - 10pts (Jester played.)

Anchundan - 5pts
bam0 - 5pts
Gilly - 5pts
Jokester - 5pts
lego - 5pts
Nyvo - 5pts
pingwing - 5pts
R-evans - 5pts
Raptor - 5pts
Russinating - 5pts
Sonea_Fifer - 5pts
the_r_sole - 5pts
timmeh - 5pts
Touch - 5pts

deej - 4pts
The_Abyss - 4pts

Janesy_B - 4pts
Mrs_Seabiscuit - 4pts

Bickaxe - 3pts
Bobmunkhouse - 3pts
rubberduck - 3pts

DirtyJester - 2pts
Executive_Beef - 2pts
Kaptainmarc - 2pts
Kennysevenfold - 2pts
Seabiscuit - 2pts


Ahleckz - 0pts Bute Brew Co. **** Up Your Beaver (This would be fine for Round X)
Feek - 0pts ****faced (This would be fine for Round X)
Kuros - 0pts K*ntish Town Beard Weird Beard (Beard is a feature, not a part)
Maccy - 0pts Hogs Back Brewery co. T-E-A (Not beer name)




Barstool Fallers:
Cat_J
Dante6491
DrunkRufie
Gambisk
hilly
inogen
Kanifee
Keyboards'Fear
One_More_Solo
oulton
Papalazaru
rexehuk
Sagalout
Silent
taB
tomoW1
TwsT
Wez130




Next Week - I.P.A
 
Commissario
Joined
16 Oct 2002
Posts
2,829
Location
In the radio shack
Thanks again for the quick results DJ, especially as it was a late evening for you.
I think that's a bit harsh though. I suspected it was risky when I was deciding what to enter but based on this question and answer I was confident.
Quick question about H. Does the body part have to stand alone or can it be part of a word? For example if the beer was called "coldfeet" would it count? I'm aware that's not a real word but couldn't think of a real example and I've got one that's like that :p.
Yes, that will be acceptable.
 
Caporegime
OP
Joined
17 Oct 2006
Posts
25,703
Thanks again for the quick results DJ, especially as it was a late evening for you.
I think that's a bit harsh though. I suspected it was risky when I was deciding what to enter but based on this question and answer I was confident.

As with all 0 point entries it is up for debate.

The quote above doesn't relate to the swearing issue for which it has been deemed invalid.

Furthermore to the point you are making. Have a read HERE.
 
Commissario
Joined
16 Oct 2002
Posts
2,829
Location
In the radio shack
As with all 0 point entries it is up for debate.

The quote above doesn't relate to the swearing issue for which it has been deemed invalid.
Oh right, so was it invalid because it has a sweary in the name? I don't remember seeing anything in the rules saying that sweary beers are only allowed in round X :confused:

/edit - Be interested to see what everyone else thinks.
 
Caporegime
OP
Joined
17 Oct 2006
Posts
25,703
Oh right, so was it invalid because it has a sweary in the name? I don't remember seeing anything in the rules saying that sweary beers are only allowed in round X :confused:

Correct.

Forgive me for not including what really should be a given. That all entries during the competition should fall within the rules of the forum (Round X being the exception where I shall edit pictures and names).
 
Soldato
Joined
28 Oct 2002
Posts
5,014
Correct.

Forgive me for not including what really should be a given. That all entries during the competition should fall within the rules of the forum (Round X being the exception where I shall edit pictures and names).

Honestly, that this was a rule hadn't occurred to me either. I did wonder why Feek got 0.
 
Associate
Joined
12 Jan 2009
Posts
2,321
Location
OcUK HQ
I've got to disagree withyour decision for Feek, face is clearly part of the name. If Tanglefoot is valid as foot is part of the phrase, then I can't see it not being valid. And on that basis Ahleckz's too, albeit "slang"?
Sorry DJ. This honestly is not because you have the same one as me. :p
 
Associate
Joined
3 Jul 2004
Posts
1,261
I found a couple of great beers to enter for this round last week in Bath, but a niggle in my head told me sweary edits were x round only, but as always, I'll go with the majority.

I'm becoming known as the weirdo who orders pints and likes to take pictures :)
 
Caporegime
OP
Joined
17 Oct 2006
Posts
25,703
I've got to disagree withyour decision for Feek, face is clearly part of the name. If Tanglefoot is valid as foot is part of the phrase, then I can't see it not being valid. And on that basis Ahleckz's too, albeit "slang"?
Sorry DJ. This honestly is not because you have the same one as me. :p

No need for sorry, it's an open debate :)

To be clear, I've deemed both Feek and Ahleckz invalid due to swearing. We have a separate round solely for this purpose (Round X). Slang was never covered if acceptable or not.

Forgetting the swearing aspect, Feek's entry ****faced is not the same as the acceptable quote below:

Quick question about H. Does the body part have to stand alone or can it be part of a word? For example if the beer was called "coldfeet" would it count? I'm aware that's not a real word but couldn't think of a real example and I've got one that's like that :p.
 
Soldato
Joined
13 Dec 2006
Posts
6,882
Location
On the forest moon Endor
Appreciate the update after a busy shift DJ - though I was somewhat surprised to finish my shift and find I've no points . . . . . .

Sonea_Fifer - 0pts Inveralmond Brewery Thrappledouser I don't even...

  • Thrapple - Definitions
  • noun: the throat or windpipe

Collins English Dictionaries Link

It's also the same beer I used for the same round in BOTWMK3 and I got points for that . . . . . . :confused:
 
Commissario
Joined
16 Oct 2002
Posts
2,829
Location
In the radio shack
OK, my feedback on all the zero pointers.

I think that Ahleckz shouldn't be penalised for the swearing either, his should be a valid entry. Personally I think mine is covered by Russinating's question which is why I submitted it.

I do agree with your 'beard' decision, Maccy had a body part in the brewery name so that's a correct decision and I'd love to know the reason Sonea_Fifer submitted Thrappledouser!

/edit - I've seen the explanation for Thrappledouser above and after that explanation, I think it should be valid along with Ahleckz and me (it also strengthens mine as it's been accepted before for the same round in a previous competition).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom