Soldato
- Joined
- 29 Aug 2006
- Posts
- 3,779
- Location
- Wales
I blame those pot noodle adverts.
What sort of mental state do you think someone must be in to commit suicide?sorry to be mean, but if a 17 year old cant survive without her ass bouncing off the wall, whats she going to be like when she gets real responsibility or hell, even a kid? the poor little tyke would have the worst start ever. Depression as a teenager is attention seeking, you have an entire life to live, and you wanna end it so early? good riddence, you dont deserve the gift youve been given.
You really, really need to grow up. Seriously, you obviously have no idea why people become depressed. A lot of the time it's not their choice, they're not doing it to 'seek attention', it's a very serious problem. For you to say that people who commit suicide due to depression don't deserve to live, is quite frankly, frightening.
Sorry ? You've had experience in commiting suicide ? Congratulations on writing from beyond the grave :s Id agree its not nessesarily the easy way out though, often it is easier the facing the problems in life, but not always.but I've enough experience to say that it is not an easy route, an easy choice, the cowards way out
There are some very narrow minded views in this thread!
Emo culture is nothing more than an image, a style that teenagers congregate under, much like grungers, goths, chavs ad infinitum.
People who commit suicide are at best unpredictable, and often in a dark place, but I've enough experience to say that it is not an easy route, an easy choice, the cowards way out. Those that think that, well, you are the ones that need to get a bit more clued up, mental health is not as black and white as that.
Purely because the press reports a 17 year old girl as having a supposedly good life etc does not mean that she doesn't have the right to end her life. Granted it's tragic and horrifying, particularly for those close to her, but who the hell are some of you guys to be basically saying how dare she take her own life.
It's not as if she's living in a warzone? So what? Does that make her emotions, thoughts and feelings any less worthy. It's all relative.
I agree with the bulk of that, e.g. 'emo' although can be associated with depression and suicide isn't exclusive by any streach of the imagination.
What I don't agree with is this whole 'right to commit suicide thing'. IMO, there should never be a reason to commit suicide for emotional reasons, there is always another way, you just need the foresight to see that.
This thread reminded me of emo-corner and there are some very disturbed young individuals there who really highlight this issue.
Burnsy
Indeed, I think I maybe phrased that poorly. Rather than saying it is her right, I mean to say that who here has the right to say whether it was just or not. Granted, it is a tragic waste of a life, but some of the people here saying 'good riddance' for example are, imo, more tragic.
DavidB said:Stateing that somebodys views are "narrow minded" without actually looking at both sides of the discussion, is in my eyes thats narrowminded too.
Sorry ? You've had experience in commiting suicide ? Congratulations on writing from beyond the grave :s Id agree its not nessesarily the easy way out though, often it is easier the facing the problems in life, but not always.
The only cure for depression is time and being around loved ones in my opinion.