I've played every big MMO under the sun, and EQ2 does what it set out to do flawlessly. I'm just burnt out on them. I also have a char on Runnyeye, played form beta. I just don't connect to it in any way. Star wars Galaxies to date is the only one that made me feel i was in a world.
I subscribed to Pirates of the Burning sea last month and cancelled after a week. I demand a social, grouping living game. Until then, FPS's offer a more involving polished online experience than any MMO out at the moment.