Poll: Fat or thin?

What do you prefer?

  • Slightly overweight.

    Votes: 535 63.9%

  • Slightly underweight.

    Votes: 256 30.6%

  • I'm gay.

    Votes: 46 5.5%
  • Total voters
    837
  • Poll closed .
They are slim and not underweight, but they are not what this thread is about. Obviously those 2 are very much what most men like on average... however we're talking about skinnier than those 2 or slightly curvier than those 2. Using clear cut "as good as you can get" specimens doesn't really belong to this thread, though eye candy is always nice! :D
 
Raikiri said:
Neither of whom are underweight, medically speaking they have a low BF% and probably a fairly normal BMI (just checking based on their weight in recent films - 19.7 for Alba and 18.6 for Megan Fox).
Click to expand...

Both those BMIs are considered underweight actually :p

Alba has the PERFECT body :D
 
Neither, without comparison it's hard to say.
Slightly skinny = no shape, curves, has showing rib cages?? etc according to this forum.

Dare to think what they think skinny is, then anorexic!
 
Burnsy2023 said:
Ok, if you had the choice between a girl (or guy) who was slightly over weight - you know a bit of extra luggage or someone who was a bit underweight, you can see her ribs a bit and generally looks a bit boney, what would you choose?

For me I can't stand underweight girls, it makes me feel a bit sick. Likewise I don't like huge girls and the baggage needs to be in the right places, but I much prefer a girl with love handles than a girl I'm worried about holding her kidneys rather than her sides.

Thoughts?
Click to expand...

It really depends really how fat or how thin they are.

If I had to choose between the extremes it'd probably be skinny
 
The comparison of Jessica and Megan is a little unfair considering they are both stunning and would look hot "slightly over" or "slightly under". Their faces are really pretty and they have amazing bodies where everything is in the right place and of ample proportion.
 
Craig321 said:
Definitely.

What you do is you get a hot skinny girl and feed her until she looks better :p

Now if you get a fat girl first off it's harder to get her to lose weight and you can't really tell if she'll be hot if you ever do get her slim.

:p
Click to expand...

Plus it means I don't have to adjust my meals to allow the fatty to lose weight :p
 
krooton said:
Plus it means I don't have to adjust my meals to allow the fatty to lose weight :p
Click to expand...

Well if you want to go for the fatty and make her lose weight then we she eats just slap her and say "No, bad fatty". :p

But I still stick with getting a skinny girl and making her eat. That way you get to eat what you want :D
 
Raikiri said:
Er no, they aren't. 18-25 is considered a healthy BMI.
Click to expand...

Right you are, that'll learn me to go by the first google hit I get, hehe.

Weirdly, my BMI is 23, which is only 2 off being 'overweight', and I am physically MILES away from being overweight, pretty damn slim actually.

Muscle mass and dense bones don't factor in to BMI, which is why it's a bit crap.

In fact, the slimmest girl I've dated was a size 8, 5'7", and had a BMI of 19.
 
Slightly under weight for me, but not overly so. Idealy a well toned girl. Can't stand fatties any more. First girl friend was over weight, and I was fine with it at the time. But when I got with my next girl who was a skinny goth girl, I knew then what I liked. Was just gutted when she started piling on the pounds lol.

I'm really skinny too, just well toned, so just need someone who's similar.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom