So animals using rocks to crack open nuts etc. are acting unnaturally?
No, that's perfectly natural.
What I mean is that the fish are being caught and killed in a way that does not occur in nature. Now, personally I don't have a problem with that.
But I do have a problem with people who want fox hunting banned on the grounds of cruelty despite the fact that it merely replicates an event which occurs naturally in the wild - particularly when the same people see nothing wrong with hook and line fishing, which does not occur naturally in the wild and is quite excruciatingly painful to the fish.
[QUOTEAnyway, using your definition of 'natural' surely taking domesticated dogs into the countryside and sending them to hunt is unnatural too, the dogs wouldn't be their without human intervention, therefore it must be unnatural.[/quote]
On the contrary, the dogs would be there if humans let them loose and refrained from interfering in their instinct-driven habits.
Even domesticated dogs will run off and harass sheep. It's perfectly natural; it's what nature tells them to do.
Lots of things are 'natural', it doesn't mean their right.
LOL? So now we want to ban animals from performing natural acts? What's next: instinct is illegal?
