I loved the show, who cares if is staged, Wrestle-mania 27 was watched by over 1.2 million people in the US alone and thats about as staged as it gets. New top gear is not a car show it is a car themed entertainment show, old top gear was a car show and it got cancelled because nobody watched it because car shows are boring to most people and have a much lower target audience.
Top gear is the most watched show on iPlayer, the most watched show on the entire BBC (worldwide viewers, and lets face it a BBC2 show beating east-enders is pretty impressive ^^) and in comparison it has double the viewers of the closest show on BBC2. So all in all they must be doing something right
My opinions on the cars:
The Ferrari: Remember when Audi took over at lambo? yeah, it just doesn't look like a proper Ferrari to me, de-badge it and have it in white/black/yellow and I guarantee half the people you ask (who don't know what it is) will say Lambo/koenigsegg/McLaren/or maybe even that new Toyota/Subaru super car their working on. Don't like the steering wheel either, personally If I was going to spend that much on a Ferrari id buy a 328 Turbo and use some of the change to modernise/restore it.
The Merc: Really liked it, it didn't look space age like the Ferrari it had obvious old school designs like the angle for he front, looked very nice though the doors were a bit silly but still my fav of the three.
The Porsche Ive not been a massive fan of this type of Porsche, and in this colour scheme I like it less, like the Ferrari its merely aesthetic problem as I like the sound of the car in principle just not the looks. Its looks kinda like a stretched beetle to me in the gray and the white schemes. Its strange because I
do like the 997, the Silver ones that launched in 2005 were sexy but I don't like the GT ones with weird colour schemes and decals that look like they came from eBay.