Adrin Flux vs Chris Knott £4.50 difference, same underwriter, what would you do?

Lum

Lum

Soldato
Joined
23 Nov 2008
Posts
3,283
Location
South Wales
So not many places will even quote me on the Cefiro this year. Direct Line came out best with a renewal price of £579.82 but will not cover any further modifications (boost controller and air filter) on top of the existing ones (Exhaust, brakes and alloys)

Adrian Flux want £730.00 Chris Knott want £734.50, both are using the same underwriter, Highway.

Now I'm aware that Flux aren't exactly the most reputable of insurers, but I suspect a lot of that is due to their most common underwriter, Equity Red Star, who I will never buy a car insurance policy from again.

Highway are an unknown to me, are they any good?

Chris Knott are also an unknown. My question is, is it worth paying an extra £4.50 to not have to deal with Flux? Are they any good when it comes to time to make a claim?

Still waiting for a call back from A-Plan Thatcham, they didn't return my calls last year either so I'm not hopeful.
 
Not a big fan of Highway.

Flux service is hit and miss, not sure about Chris Knott.

A-Plan service was first class for my import, but then they saw my occupation so there were highly unlikely to mess me about. :p
 
I hear nothing but complaints about them from the likes of SXOC.

What's wrong with Highway then? This year nobody can touch them because all the others take 5 years worth of claims into account and 2006 was a bad year for me.

As for A-Plan, they are good, but their most common underwriter, Markerstudy, are dreadful.
 
Last edited:
Whats so bad with Flux?

I have a friend who pranged his car in the recent bad weather, he's already had a payout - and a good one - he's delighted with the service he had from them.

Good & bad experiences with all I think you'll find....

Buy a pint or two (if your lucky!) with the £4.50
 
I used Flux for five years - never had any problems, excellent phone service and always understood what I was doing or what I needed. Never had to claim, mind! :)
 
Ive used Highway myself,, was involved in a prang not my fault,, had no problems with them they were great
 
Having wonderful fun with Equity Red star at the moment; won't pay out for my fault admitted accident in 2009 still, got court documents and everything. Just awesome. The woman is trying to claim for not being able to do the hoovering and other silly things, mind.
 
Equity Red star I hate for two reasons.

1) Their protected NCB disappears completely if you have 2 claims. eg. 1 claim, no loss, 2 claims, 4 years loss. Waste of money

2) Had a non-fault claim in the same period as the above two, would've meant 6 years NCB loss, so I paid for the repair myself. The 3rd party paid my garage directly and Equity Red Star also paid them, only they sent it to the wrong address. As the 3rd party wouldn't pay them back, it took me 2 years to get my money back.

Haze: Was your case a simple one or a complicated one. We've had bad experience in the past with Markerstudy who paid out when we wanted to dispute things (stolen car rammed my GF's car into a parked car. They paid out to the parked car's owner) and they couldn't be bothered.
 
What bad stuff do you hear about Flux on SXOC Lum?

I am insured with Flux / Equity Red Star and have normally read only good stuff about them. Obviously you read bad stuff now and then but you would for anywhere!
 
quite stright forwards really i had the sense to run across the road and get myself a witness
 
Just seems to be the general vibe, not just on SXOC but on pretty much all the car forums I've been on over the years. I dunno if it's just because they have a large amount of the modified/jap market and therefore have picked up more complainers, but until this thread I've never seen anything positive said about them, and a lot of negative.

A-Plan seem to get a mixture of both, and Sky seem to get generally positive comments, not that it matters since neither can quote for me.
 
I will never ever ever even get a quote from adrian flux ever again after they messed up my mod form meaning the underwriter never got the list of mods meaning if I'd had to claim they would probably have rejected it. Pay the extra £4.50 and enjoy insured driving :)
 
I was insured with Highway through flux for quite a while, 7 years or so.

Never had a problem really even through 2 non fault accidents in that time, only moved as got a way cheaper quote on year they couldn't match.
 
When I got my quote with Chris Knott, I told them I'd take it on the proviso they use Zurich instead of Highway, and they readily agreed.

They were rubbish on last renewal though, premium shot up from £500 to £2000 a year for a Skoda Fabia due to one car park prang.
 
I've been with chris knott last couple of years

Can't fault them.

Their renewal quote was actually cheaper than i could get anywhere else so i just renewed !
 
Have you tried Lancaster? http://www.lancasterinsurance.co.uk/car_insurance.htm

I've been with them since I've had the quattro, really good price and when some old idiot reversed into the back of the quattro last year the service was great, they sorted everything really quickly, the next day a chap from the repair shop came round to see what needed doing, picked the car up and 10 minutes later my courtesy car arrived.
 
Highway, no, big ****** no, don't do it. NO!!!

Note: I've been up all night so I'm not going to be very coherent, I'm going to make it as short as possible, I'm fed up of going through all the details but here's why I think they are pretty much a waste of your time.

I've been messing around with them for 15 months, yes months when some bint left her hand brake off, didn't park in gear on the ferry from the UK to Jersey, the day I bought the car. Her car rammed the back of mine and made very minor damage, scratches and all. But the principle that she must pay and I do not stands.

What should have been a very simple open and closed case has become a nightmare.

After, details were exchanged, a signed accident form from myself, the person who hit me(3rd party) and the engineering officer on board, photos taken, statements made.

At first she ignored my phone calls, I gave it a few weeks as she was a uk citizen in Jersey for an unknown period, I tried some more with nothing. My insurance was notified the next day, to be honest I was on a 16 hour rough crossing and to put it harshly, I've never in my life been so sick. I wanted to find the damned flare gun and end it then and there!

I report directly to adrian flux, who send me an accident report form in which I had to send 3 because they never made it's destination on recorded delivery, which translates to "we lost it". Then one to Highway and one for some reason to lv.com which is the sister company of highway ?

Let's not mention explaining the entirety of the event takes a long time, so during a phone call I have to drivel on and on, for them to pass me on to someone else and repeat it, over and over. Until I took initiative and kept all communication with one employee.

Turns out, 3rd party had denied the event ever taking place, also provided a fake name and telephone number. Contacting the ferry company for details to take further action was like headbutting a bulldozer. I understand data protection but my insurance couldn't even get that information. A few phone calls later citing that they are witholding information to an unresolved accident on their ship quickly got me what I needed.

Fast forward to 3 weeks ago, 3rd party insurance were told they were never contacted by mine until Jan 2011 (Accident happened in Nov 09) I cannot begin to underatand how this is even possible, my insurance said they contacted the 3rd party insurance in Dec 09. So conflicting reports here, who knows who is lying.

The ferry company took a long time to provide the photographs, "My boss is on holiday, he's back in a week", more like a month. "It's not in this office, I will try the other", "sorry I'm new here". The manager's no better constantly "out of the office" and never returns voice mail.

Eventually I had the solid evidence I needed in MY possession, not in the hands of retarded jobs worths. Pictures, the report that she hit my car, photos of her car and mine. Oh, did I mention that the reg number I gave "didn't exist?" It does now apparently.

So 3 weeks ago, they admitted liability, I called her insurance asking for reasons they denied liability, it was the person who hit me they said. They denied it, I asked what steps will be taken now that she's lied about an accident ever happening, not reporting it etc, they can't tell me, I'm fine with that I understand it's none of my business what they do to her, but it's my feeling bloody nothing.

Still at 3 weeks ago, it's come down to them accepting to pay for the repair (3rd party insurance/mine) I've not renewed my insurance at the moment, financial problems and definitely not with them so they agreed to have the car picked up, repaired and brought back.

That was until a week ago my insurance phoned up and said the person who hit me has denied it happening. Wait, what? yeah, I'm as confused as you. They said they will be contacting the 3rd party and sending her the evidence I provided, I will be contacting them tomorrow first thing when they open.

I've tried being as patient as a saint, more than can be said for most people, it's been over a year for a frickin' paint job on the rear bumper. I've also lost it and been outright aggressive on the phone because I have had enough. Just dialing the number and waiting for an operator to pick up has my heart beating in anxiety for complete idiocy from people who just don't have a clue in the world.

I've missed lots out, it's not really all in the right order, I'm tired and fed up with the whole ordeal, I've lost complete faith in this insurance company, I don't even get any sort of reimbursement, compensation, understanding, anything for the crap I've had to put up with for over a year.

I've never had to claim for anything in regard to car insurance before, it's all new to me and so is the legal system, but I'm at the point I want the person who hit my car to suffer I can't afford a lawyer but my insurance should cover legal costs right? How can people like that get away with it. Get her to lose her insurance, a temporary driving ban, a monetary fine, all of them, anything, I don't care. I don't see an increased premium to be adequate any more.

Damnit, I'm ranting but yeah you get the basic idea.
I don't understand how with all the information at hand it hasn't been sorted already, I have witnesses, report forms, photos. How the hell does something like this take OVER A YEAR! :(
 
Back
Top Bottom