Bank Transfer Mistake

Associate
Joined
15 Nov 2007
Posts
2,402
Location
Sheffield, UK
Was wondering weather this happened to anyone else but it happened two years ago during the start of the recession. My dad was keeping on top of his banking, and for some reason or another moved the money in one of the accounts and closed it (the balance was to the sum of about £28,000). Now I don't even know how such a mistake can happen but basically a month later after everything "settled" down (Note that all our money is accounted for as my dad keeps meticulous records of everything) he noticed one of his accounts had unexpectedly been credited with a vast sum of money. To the sum of about £28000.

Now he didn't immediately make the connection, assuming perhaps a business has mistakenly transfered money so it stayed there and he didn't give it much thought for a few days. Then the penny hit and he had a hunch at what happened and went through his record to double check the figures. And yes, the amount was exact to the penny as what he transfered out of that other account before he closed it.

So off he went to the bank to inform them of this mistake.

Now fast forward a month and half later. Still nothing done about the money. We still have it and its not doing much. So he thought "Well F it, if they ever do come chasing it back i'm only obliged to give them the capital back, so why not make a bit of interest here..". So the end point is it gets put in some high interest scheme of 8% pa, tied to the FTSE.

Now fast forward to present day. I had forgotten all about it (obviously my dad hadn't) but I come home one day from uni and my dad asks if he can borrow as much money as i can lend him, untill april. It appears that finally after two years (We had hopes that they would never come for it/ it got left in our possession for over 5 years, which in my understanding we could have legal grounds to ownership of the money) that they now want it back!

So long story short is I had to lend my dad some money so as to minimize interest loss in his accounts. He's happy about the banking mess as it gained him £4k for next to no work.

I was wondering if this happened to anyone else as I can't see it being human error that caused these transfers so there must be others?

SUMMARY:This is why banks Suck. :D
 
Last edited:
I am a little lost here?

He closed an account
transfered the money into another account
and the bank wants the money back?

That is what i get out of that post.
 
I dont follow why you needed to give him 13k

I don't need to and he doesn't need it per say, but if i don't it means he has to just take out "bond" (Don't know the exact banking term of what its in) just as the second year matures (in april) and lose a fair bit of interest. And my money wasn't doing much I might as well.
 
hold on. he put it in savings and it was earning money, so why can he not just pay back the money himself?
 
I am a little lost here?

He closed an account
transfered the money into another account
and the bank wants the money back?

That is what i get out of that post.

Gah sorry for my crap writing skills, you're almost correct.

He closed an account
transfered the money into another account
month later bank transfers free money (effectively duplicating above statement) into his account
and the bank wants the money back?
 
Last edited:
I am a little lost here?

He closed an account
transfered the money into another account
and the bank wants the money back?

That is what i get out of that post.

I assume the money made it to where it was supposed to go... but also ended up elsewhere. I think. :confused:
 
From what I gather he put the money into an ISA account and just let it sit there. So why did you need to give him 13k to pay it back?
 
hold on. he put it in savings and it was earning money, so why can he not just pay back the money himself?

Because he doesn't want to lose the interest on all of it, so we're gathering all monies that will return lower and will pay the bank with that.
 
hold on. he put it in savings and it was earning money, so why can he not just pay back the money himself?

From what I gather he put the money into an ISA account and just let it sit there. So why did you need to give him 13k to pay it back?

Because he put into a long term investment where there are penalties for early redemption. So borrowing the money elsewhere short term means more profit long term.

ISA wasn't mentioned.

However, having worked for several banks I'm a little surprised this wasn;t noticed earlier. I'm not calling shenanigans but it surprises me that such a large sum wasn't identified earlier as there would have been a reconciliation error somewhere.
 
Back
Top Bottom