Advising other people on their parenting...

Soldato
Joined
9 Mar 2007
Posts
12,604
Location
Nodnol
Am i right in assuming this is a faux pas?

There are several times in life that i've wanted to just quietly explain to parents that what they're doing and/or allowing their child to do is just plain unacceptable. I'm generally not talking about anything horrifying, just good manners in most cases.

One example i'll throw out there occurred yesterday; i was walking into a shop to overhear a young girl near the entrance, likely around 8 years old at a guess, telling her mum she was finished with her juice box. The mother instructed her daughter to throw it out of the door, firstly this projectile rubbish narrowly missed me as it flew past and obviously this is also littering. There was a bin around 5ft from the entrance to the shop. It's a small thing i know, but there was this strong urge to explain to them that it was totally unacceptable behaviour, but being a typically British passive aggressive i thought i'd write an angry post on the internet instead.

I work in a school and because of parenting like this it's nearly impossible to explain to some children why they should throw away their own rubbish, they just don't understand that people should clean up after themselves. It's like you're talking a foreign language, often the children just reply with 'Why?' when instructed to collect their own food packaging in the canteen.

We have all been there i'm sure, sat in a restaurant trying to have a nice meal whilst children scream past you, trying to make your way around a supermarket while a child runs riot, looking through a picnmix while a young snotty nosed boy helps himself with his hands (I have actually witnessed the latter, the mother snatched what he was halfway through eating from him and threw the sweets BACK into the pixnmix!).

Have you ever been in a situation where you've said something? If not, could you imagine yourself saying something?

What would/have you said?
 
If I saw something that was plainly worng I'd say something. Keeping quiet is why this country is going to ****

I went to the local zoo and when we got to the monkey enclosure I saw a young chav mum encouraging her daughter to throw sweets over the wall into enclosure. I went absolutely nuts at the mum and attracted the attention of a zoo keeper, who promptly frog marches said chav mum off the premises.

Felt sorry for the little girl though - she had her day at the zoo spoilt by her mum being irresponsable.

sat in a restaurant trying to have a nice meal whilst children scream past you

Standing up and pushing your chair back a foot or so at the oppurtune moment normally puts an end to that behaviour quite swiftly!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The only time I've ever said something was when a woman was smacking her kid in the street. I wouldn't have said anything but she must have hit the child (only young) about 8-9 times and he was obviously in pain. I'd never seen a parent hit a child that hard, went far past a traditional slap on the backside. Poor kid.

That worries you? But you cant even clean up after yourself after eating at say Mc D's?
 
I ask the Parent if they Beat there child, When they reply No I ask if I can.
 
Streeteh do you have children ? :)

No and this is why i generally stay out of things. It's easy to preach when you're on the other side of the fence, I just wonder how far is 'too far' and why such simple little things are ignored/encouraged.

Like the eg of littering; Is there really any excuse to encourage your child to do this? Or throwing snotty picknmix back into the box, is there any parenting situation where this is remotely acceptable?
 
Like the eg of littering; Is there really any excuse to encourage your child to do this? Or throwing snotty picknmix back into the box, is there any parenting situation where this is remotely acceptable?

I can't think of a time any of my kids have EVER dropped any litter. i don't need to tell them to pick it up as they wont drop it in the first place.

And if any of them even dared to put thier hands in the pick'n'mix boxes they'd get a switft crack across the knuckles!
 
so basically your going to advise on issues which going by your title you have no knowledge of :confused: gg :p

yes kids do silly things and yes they can be annoying but this may also not be the parents fault or parenting skills at fault as kids are highly un predictable and do the most random things at the worst possible times :D

when you enter the world of parenting youll find your answer :)
 
so basically your going to advise on issues which going by your title you have no knowledge of :confused: gg :p

No, i've asked whether it's acceptable to advise them, and if anyone here has done, how did they approach the situation.

I work with children, some of which have emotional/behavioural disorders, so i'm not completely uninformed in the subtleties of their behaviour.
 
Last edited:
so basically your going to advise on issues which going by your title you have no knowledge of :confused:

But commenting on someone littering isn't really advising someone on thier parenting skills is it?

If I'd have seen that I'd have said something along the lines of "Aren't you going to tell her to put that in the bin? Just dropping it on the floor is disgusting".

It's just promoting decent behaviour - nothing to do with parenting.

Then again, my wifes a primary teacher and she's given up using the sentance "would you do that if you were at home?" as the answer is invariably "yes".
 
No, i've asked whether it's acceptable to advise them, and if anyone here has done, how did they approach the situation.

title .... Advising other people on their parenting... it implies you are going to advise people on parenting without the knowledge of being a parent which is probably the first reply youll get if you do so or probably some kind of confrontation . "do you have kids "

well keep your nose out if polite or **** *** if not polite :D

i wouldnt do it myself even though i have kids as your not there parent whether they are bad or good. maybe at your work or at school where you are employed to do some kind of mentoring but out of work then its not really your duty . by all means try it if you want .
 
Last edited:
title .... Advising other people on their parenting... it implies you are going to advise people on parenting without the knowledge of being a parent

Which is why this forum doesn't comprise entirely of titles, the content of the op is what is relevant to the discussion. The first sentence of the op, asking whether it's a faux pas, clearly indicates that i'm asking whether the act described in the title is acceptable. Or did you not bother to read the actual thread?

[EDIT] Also, it's not as if i'm asking whether it's acceptable to advise parents on their childs diet, hobbies or interests. I'm asking whether it's ok to point out where a family is completely ignoring socially acceptable behaviour that negatively impacts other people, again i jump back to the idea of someone else unknowingly partaking in snotty picknmix later that day.
 
Last edited:
I don't think no-one has the right to tell another stranger how to bring up their family. I don't have children, however if I did I certainly would never interfear with someone elses life.

If it was something where the child was in danger yes I would say something but not until then.
 
so basically your going to advise on issues which going by your title you have no knowledge of :confused: gg :p

yes kids do silly things and yes they can be annoying but this may also not be the parents fault or parenting skills at fault as kids are highly un predictable and do the most random things at the worst possible times :D

when you enter the world of parenting youll find your answer :)

Oh look, it's the " I had sex, procreated and I'm suddenly an expert in child upbringing" card. We all see this too much, Now I'm not saying you aren't a good parent, that's not what I'm saying.

However what I am saying is that we are all capable of raising a child, some better than others (some actually badly) but this doesn't stop us being objective and being able to talk about it because we haven't done it yet.


I also hate this idea that it's taboo to tell a parent either, as if they have no right, it's just pure snobbery, avoiding issues and playing high all mighty because you now have an excuse.
However this is over a small issue such a littering, you should have told the adult directly that it's ***** behavior.
 
Last edited:
Which is why this forum doesn't comprise entirely of titles, the content of the op is what is relevant to the discussion. The first sentence of the op, asking whether it's a faux pas, clearly indicates that i'm asking whether the act described in the op is acceptable. Or did you not bother to read the actual thread?

yes i have read the thread and just gave my parenting view ;) i understand what your saying and while it maybe more right than wrong whether it works in the real world without some kind of negative response from protective parent or some kind of confrontation from them is up to you in how you pursue it if you want to.
 
Back
Top Bottom