Bmw 5 estate or E-Class estate or Audi

I'd far rather do a big distance in my Scania than in any car mind you (not that this is of any use to the OP!!)

Being sat up high makes such a difference to the journey......

Limited to 55mph(?) and with a tachograph on the go causing you to have to stop every 4(?) hours or so....

I would take the car and drive a bit faster and for as long as i want thanks :p
 
Limited to 55mph(?) and with a tachograph on the go causing you to have to stop every 4(?) hours or so....

I would take the car and drive a bit faster and for as long as i want thanks :p

Yes, limited to 55 - although you'd soon appreciate its quite fast enough given the stopping distances @44tons.

Breaks every 4:30, which is long enough for most to be ready for a nap.

Its more the way the truck drives, the completely different field of vision, view etc, I find running down a motorway in a car (regardless as to what sort) extremely tedious after a while, you don't see anything like as much as you do from a large HGV's cab, and thats before you glance down into some vehicles.... ;)

I regularly do say Stoke - London & back in my Scania, get out feeling fresh as a daisy, yet driving from Stoke to Taunton (Somerset), a slightly shorter distance, in a car leaves me feeling tired.

I can only guess that because a truck is designed for long distances (air suspended seat for example) its inherently the more comfortable - for me at least - and assume this is why I have the above feeling comparing one to a long ish trip in a car.
 
Last edited:
I regularly do say Stoke - London & back in my Scania, get out feeling fresh as a daisy, yet driving from Stoke to Taunton (Somerset), a slightly shorter distance, in a car leaves me feeling tired.

Whereas I have happily driven from Lichetenstein to Cologne or Inverkeithing to Plymouth in a single day and not felt tired.

Remain to be convinced by your point.
 
I sincerely hope you were given a fuel card or were reimbursed mileage :-)


Its my business.

using the approved mileage allowance scheme it doesn't half knock your taxable income down.

Plus I get 20% of whatever I pay in fuel back.

I used to mostly use a tesco credit card to pay for the fuel and clear it every month. Didn't half rack up the clubcard points:D

With stops I used to avg 50mph throughout the day (daytime) so being limited to 55mph wouldn't be an issue. Plus its HGVs that keep the motorways flowing. The 1st thing i do if the motorways start clogging up is dive into lane 1 and sit with the wagons who more often than not at least keep moving whilst everyone else races upto 40mph then back to stationary.

R420LA6X2/4MNA : I wonder how many times I've driven past you without knowing. What's your cab called
 
Last edited:
175k bejesus

I'd go to a dealer and just sit in a car.......... for a day .......... each ......... then see which one you can live in literally
 
[TW]Fox;23748646 said:
Whereas I have happily driven from Lichetenstein to Cologne or Inverkeithing to Plymouth in a single day and not felt tired.

Remain to be convinced by your point.

Perhaps its because your nearly half my age? You tell me.

All I'm saying is I find a large HGV much less tiring to drive over a relatively long distance compared to driving a car,whatever the make / model of car too - I found this with all of my cars, from my e38 7,e39 5 etc down to a Peugeot 309 I owned a few years back, the truck is imo the less taxing to drive compared to a car over a similar distance.

I assume its down to the much better field of vision given your sitting so much higher than in a car?

Incidentally, the concentration required to drive a 6 axle artic I would argue is greater than that needed to drive a car, despite this, as I say, I find the latter far easier & am less likely to feel tired in one. Maybe its because its what I do day in, day out.......


Once you've driven such a vehicle, maybe you'll be in a position to be convinced? maybe not.

R420LA6X2/4MNA : I wonder how many times I've driven past you without knowing. What's your cab called

Many times I'd imagine.....

I don't have my "own" truck as such these days, I do day shifts now (i.e. I'm not away all week in the same allocated vehicle anymore) so I drive whatever is available at the start of my shift.
 
Jesus, if I was doing 700 miles a day I would DEMAND active cruise control.

You need something like the Gs300 with adaptive cruise control and LPG.

I bet you could get 700 miles with a tank of petrol and a tank of LPG.
 
Perhaps its because your nearly half my age? You tell me.

All I'm saying is I find a large HGV much less tiring to drive over a relatively long distance compared to driving a car,whatever the make / model of car too - I found this with all of my cars, from my e38 7,e39 5 etc down to a Peugeot 309 I owned a few years back, the truck is imo the less taxing to drive compared to a car over a similar distance.

I assume its down to the much better field of vision given your sitting so much higher than in a car?

Incidentally, the concentration required to drive a 6 axle artic I would argue is greater than that needed to drive a car, despite this, as I say, I find the latter far easier & am less likely to feel tired in one. Maybe its because its what I do day in, day out.......

Sounds like you get into a car and your brain goes into overdrive.

Omgz so low to the ground, I have the ability to jump from 60mph to 90mph within seconds, omgz , omgz , omgz I need to watch every single detail on the Mway as I am going so much faster than what I am used.

I think that's whats happens in your case.

I did 600 miles in the 530i in one day, was perfectly fine. Did 600 miles in a Fiesta 1.2, was nearly dying and believe it or not, I had a little weep near Tamworth.
 
Jesus, if I was doing 700 miles a day I would DEMAND active cruise control.

You need something like the Gs300 with adaptive cruise control and LPG.

I bet you could get 700 miles with a tank of petrol and a tank of LPG.

Thats what was appealing about the Accord.

But its an Accord

I'm hoping an E-class or the 5 has it
Fox will tell me:D


I really like the E-Class but the 5 Series seems better on paper.

If I get a BMW how do I stop myself being one of those BMW drivers:D
 
[TW]Fox;23749129 said:
They both have cruise as standard and adaptive cruise as an option.

Cheers Fox

The 520d seems to be a good motor enough power for me (Nothing but an M5 is going to feel like my SLK55 AMG anyhow)

So I think I'm now looking for a 520d with Black leather and no wooden wood.
With all the bells and whistles.

Wish me luck
 
Yeah going on for 700 miles a day

With stops I used to avg 50mph throughout the day (daytime) so being limited to 55mph wouldn't be an issue.

Hmmm...

So, 14 hours spent driving each day for 250 days a year? Or to put it another way, 14 hour days, 5 days a week, with two weeks holiday a year?

Are you sure you've done the maths right? :p

I'd be at serious risk of falling asleep at the wheel spending 14 hours a day driving!
 
I am now starting to think there is some seriously flawed maths going on.

That's essentially, start driving at 9am and finish 11pm ....I'm not buying this.
 
Hmmm...

So, 14 hours spent driving each day for 250 days a year? Or to put it another way, 14 hour days, 5 days a week, with two weeks holiday a year?

Are you sure you've done the maths right? :p

I'd be at serious risk of falling asleep at the wheel spending 14 hours a day driving!

That quote was when I was driving during the day.
The big runs were overnight so avg speed was erm a little higher officer. plus the max I'm allowed under domestic driving hours is 10 hrs in an 11 hour shift obviously those rules get bent a little every now and then but hey ho

2 weeks holiday...My mrs wishes. I had a week off in 2008 then another in 2010 and another week in 2011 (Maldives yay) noting in 2012

I can't switch off from work so holidays arn't much fun. An issue I'm planning on changing from now on (Today I have been diagnosed with IBD either colitis or chron's more tests needed)
 
the max I'm allowed under domestic driving hours is 10 hrs in an 11 hour shift obviously those rules get bent a little every now and then
Domestic driving hours? In a car???

That's news to me!! - I assume you have no tachograph or similar driving recording device, so how - if at all - could it be enforced??

As far as commercials are concerned,under domestic driving hours, you can drive for 9 hours per day/shift extending to 10 hours twice in a working week, putting it simply (the practice has many variances) you can drive for 5 days one week and 6 the next & so on....
 
Back
Top Bottom