I find Gibson's QC questionable, so to find one that i like the feel of, the sound of and the look of is quite a challenge.
It's not a secret that Gibson USA sacrificed QC many times in its history to achieve sales targets, the most infamous being their "golden" "Norlin era" - late sixties to late seventies when popularity of the instrument rose but so did appetite for cash. Gibson (owned by Norlin at the time) began cutting corners and started stacking bodies from two or thee pieces. As the prime grade wood supply would become more and more expensive they moved on to a "sandwich" construction for some models, where two layers of glued wood were crossboarded under the carved top (often made of two or more pieces as well).
By mid seventies they reached "pancake" stage, where cheaper models were made of several thiner crossply layers with stuffing chips supporting curvatures in the top or necks and other malarky.
Gibson's excuse at the time was strengthening body for "sustain", but the effect was quite opposite, in addition to sheer weight of some of those wood combinations reaching 12-14 pounds around your neck, where normally you would expect Les Paul to weight around 8lb.
By the end of seventies, most of the top models were reverted back to single piece body with one piece top, but the trend continued on cheaper models reaching quite extreme combos of off-the-floor wood used in their instruments. And it wasn't just Gibson, a lot of copycat manufacturers looking for market share el cheapo followed the suit, finding most peculiar ways of building instruments from almost wafer thin scraps:
So, bad QC and corner cutting is nothing new in "big name" league. And judging just by the number of models Gibson floods the market with in the last few years I guess cuts had to made somewhere...
Although, having said that - it is much harder to hide cost cutting in some models these days. My Les Paul BFG - it's one ugly motherlover, but I know 100% that the wood, construction and grade is solid. It's completely naked, so they just couldn't hide it in that model. Also, no issues with binding. It just doesn't have any
Fender Strat, its a possibility but I am still not sold on its looks. It looks weird and wrong to me. From the headstock, to that weird curve and the bottom to the pick guard.
Fender headstock varied over the years. Big "CBS" headstock is a marketing ploy, it allowed for bigger decal (and counter weight for glued bodies?). 70ies headstock is fugly, I agree, but when it comes to Fender, I struggle to figure out how telecaster became so popular. It looks terrible, in its original design it sounded like a ton of 5p coins chucked against concrete floor and the headstock, my god, I would expect this thing on front page of News Of The World with headline "Alien crash lands in Roswell with pictures: 'poor thing broke its penis' says onlooker". Small headstock from 1954, as used to this day, is a perfection though. It's the most copied design of all time
Leo Fender had terrible eye for design though. When he sold Fender brand to CBS in 1965 and a decade later started collaborating with George Fullerton (co-designer of stratocaster) to open new venture - G&L - this were the best headstock designs they could come up with:
Don't let me even start on bodies and pickguards... And yet, G&L is by far the best strat of that era that you could possibly get.
IMHO currently the closest strat-perfect thing in production are Gary Levinson's Blade guitars:
Has passive pickups and active circut for boost, similar to Clapton strat, the sound is just crystal and sweet.
I am looking at PRS again too, actually found a Custom 24 (full fat) within budget.....and talking about budget, which is around £1k. as close as possible.
£1000 or just over, in used guitar world would get you a decent (if simpler/uglier) USA Gibson Les Paul and a very decent Fender. I mean both, together, for that kind of money. Covers about 90% of genres. Or a very basic PRS.
What music do you want to play with your guitar. When you close your eyes and imagine that one perfect instrument playing, what's the tone in your head. I don't mean, what's your skill, just what does that "one" guitar sound like in perfect world? Give us a song title or video link.