Help me choose a car please

Associate
Joined
21 Apr 2015
Posts
441
Location
United Knigdom
I am looking for a new car. My budget is £1000-£3500. I want something more grownup but still plenty of power, I have a family now so want 4 or 5 door, has to be either a saloon or estate (thinking more for an estate). It must be a petrol and have less than 80k on the clock.

I have been looking at all kinds of cars and just confused with what I want now lol.
 
Your requirements are a bit vague, what have you now got? - you could have for arguments sake a diesel Vectra and want a 540i Touring, or say a Fiesta where a Mondeo estate would be a jump up, what's more power? 100bhp or 280+?

£1k to £3.5k covers a lot of bases, bottom end (£1k) to something reasonable (£3.5k)



Any why the 80k limit? - at this budget buy on condition not age nor miles IMO, I'd be far more inclined to look for 100k+ but something that'll take the mileage with a big fat service history to back it up.


I would ask yourself exactly what you need, your budget may force a compromise of need over want.
 
Last edited:
Saab 9-3/9-5 Aero (estate)

Big, comfy, quick, quite well equipped, cheap comparatively with the 3 series tourings, A4/A6 avants etc
 
I currently have a 1.6 focus which I hate. I want 150bhp plus really I had a 206gti before the focus so I really miss the power. Its just a general rule I have when it comes to buying petrols. I will look for good service history and condition.

What are Saab parts like to get a hold of? I know there was a company who stocked their parts.
 
I currently have a 1.6 focus which I hate. I want 150bhp plus really I had a 206gti before the focus so I really miss the power. Its just a general rule I have when it comes to buying petrols. I will look for good service history and condition.

What are Saab parts like to get a hold of? I know there was a company who stocked their parts.

Peice of cake to get hold of parts, various outlets stocking genuine saab bits. But yeah, forget the arbitrary mileage requirement - you'll be looking at ~10 year old cars for this money and 8k miles a year in a big car is generally not kind use.
 
"Don't buy one" isn't a reason, you'll likely have to do much better than that.

He thinks they're boring to drive.

Which they are, but the OP never said it needs to be exciting. The 9-5 is the better car but also a lot larger. The 9-3 is great value, lots of engine choice with several powerful options available. You can have a 2.8l turbocharged V6 (250bhp) with plenty toys for £2500

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/201510087633950

Or a late model 2008 facelift 2.0T estate for £3500

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/201510117717533

Plenty of great 9-5s around too for this money
 
He thinks they're boring to drive.

Which they are, but the OP never said it needs to be exciting. The 9-5 is the better car but also a lot larger. The 9-3 is great value, lots of engine choice with several powerful options available. You can have a 2.8l turbocharged V6 (250bhp) with plenty toys for £2500

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/201510087633950

Or a late model 2008 facelift 2.0T estate for £3500

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/201510117717533

Plenty of great 9-5s around too for this money

My 1.6TDI A3 is extremely boring to drive, that's why I picked it.
 
Okay. Shoddy build quality, they really don't wear miles very well, poor interior materials in places (coatings on buttons, handles, trim etc all have tendency to scratch off looking ugly), inexplicable suspension creaks and groans in low temps, dull handling, terrible gearbox (5 speed,) undetectable coolant loss in early cars (porous engine block), electrical gremlins (particularly the car forgetting it has a remote, potentially rendering it impossible to access if parked with near side door close to wall or other car - nearside door has a key operated lock, offside doesn't), rough and unrefined engine (mine always ran/runs a little lumpy when warm at idle, not fixed with the changing of many parts (plugs, coils, throttle body, crankshaft position sensor, probably others that I can't remember).

Mines a convertible, but the above could apply to any 4 cyl petrol-engined 9-3. I remember being shocked by my mate's dad's almost new Aero saloon and it's numerous creaks and rattles. The MD I work under also had an Aero saloon from new - he complained of creaky suspension, a habit of breaking rear springs, leaks into the cabin and the heater matrix failing (all under warranty).

One last thing - my convertible forgot it has a folding roof a couple of times, and refused to operate or acknowledge any kind of failure). I could probably go on. I can't think of any car I've been in that's been reasonably well looked after that felt to tired.

The 9-3 is cheap when compared with the BMW E46/Audi A4 for a reason. I just bought an E46 saloon - it looks and feels like its done less than half the mileage of my Saab despite being a bit older and having done similar miles.
 
Last edited:
I actually don't think I can say much against that 9-5. It looks good for the money tbh. Does the B235R still suffer sludging in this MY?
 
I do love the Saab but 3 things that are stopping me, the insurance quote is around £800 for it which is a lot. The tax is very high too (nearly 3 times what I pay now) and I am unsure about the mileage. I know you's have said not to worry but in my mind lots of miles equals hard driven miles.
 
Back
Top Bottom