Blue powerade, whenever I get cold/flu have a bottle every 3-4 hours and it will shift even the nastiest of colds.
Are drugs a placebo?
- Thread starter Ace Modder
- Start date
Blue powerade, whenever I get cold/flu have a bottle every 3-4 hours and it will shift even the nastiest of colds.
If it's a placebo, then how do these drugs work at reducing fever in babies/toddlers who are too young to understand?
Or is the placebo acting on the parents/nurses, making them hallucinate when looking at the thermometer?
Or is the placebo acting on the parents/nurses, making them hallucinate when looking at the thermometer?
Soldato
- Joined
- 17 Aug 2003
- Posts
- 20,160
- Location
- Woburn Sand Dunes
The wife has psoriatic arthritis, ibuprofen is the difference between her getting out of bed and not some mornings.
I also took anti-depressants about 18 years ago for a few months, had no idea what I was getting into. They are certainly not placebo and wouldn't recommend them to anybody, they do to some degree 'work' but at the cost of rearranging your brain chemistry possibly permanently. Leaving you a bit zombied. Almost a chemical method of lobotomising somebody.
Ibuprofen will shift a headache for me in about 20 minutes - Paracetamol very hit and miss - I find it works well for things like toothache but not so much for headaches. When I get a migraine though nothing will touch it :|
With colds stuff like Lemsip is the difference between being able to get comfortable to sleep or not.
With colds stuff like Lemsip is the difference between being able to get comfortable to sleep or not.
Cocodamol certainly works but it once backed me up so badly the stomach pain it gave me was far worse than the original pain it was prescribed for!
Remember the Nurofen scandal last year - by using advertising to change your understanding of what the drug did, marking their price up even though they contained the same ingredients? BBC Source. The other half was being a right cow and giving me a headache so I took Nurofen Period Pain and would you believe it, the pain went away. Perhaps some placebo effect here, dunno.
Talking of ingredients, remember the markup of branded medicines which contained the exact same stuff as the cheaper alternatives. It's all about the P/L codes. MSE Source.
Remember the Nurofen scandal last year - by using advertising to change your understanding of what the drug did, marking their price up even though they contained the same ingredients? BBC Source. The other half was being a right cow and giving me a headache so I took Nurofen Period Pain and would you believe it, the pain went away. Perhaps some placebo effect here, dunno.
Talking of ingredients, remember the markup of branded medicines which contained the exact same stuff as the cheaper alternatives. It's all about the P/L codes. MSE Source.
This. Bizarre thread is bizarre.
I take antihistamines on a regular basis, I know they work well.
Antibiotics stopped me getting blood poisoning a couple years ago.
Taken various corticosteroids and I can vouch for the effectiveness of those, too
Fortunately I'm not on nearly as many "meds" as other people I know. Just stuff to control allergies, enhance breathing and stop nighttime itching (which makes it impossible to sleep if I don't dose up before bed). But I know how bad things are if I don't take them, and therefore can judge the effectiveness of taking them. The ones I take sure aren't placebos.
- Joined
- 8 Sep 2003
- Posts
- 23,189
- Location
- Was 150 yds from OCUK - now 0.5 mile; they moved
I see what you did there. GG
doesn't work for you, is very different to not working.I don't know. All I know is taking paracetamol for a headache just doesn't work.
You do realise they're generally tested in double blind trials alongside placebos?
From my GP and from my Pharmacist, i also recall reading it in the piriteze paperwork that comes in the box
It's the glucose in it.
The dentist once gave me a strong glucose drink (not sure what it was, but wish I did lol) after giving me an anesthetic injection which made me feel faint. It was probably the most effective thing I've ever taken
Although they have to beat placebo, that doesn't mean they work on the majority of people.
Yet people still just aimlessly take it although they know it doesn't work on them, rather than trying something else.
Paracetamol for instance only works on about 25% of people with normal headaches. But it's not the only option. I'm in the majority it doesn't work for, however ibuprofen lysine works wonders for headaches.
that is indeed true and perhaps the reason for the OP's complaints