I don't disagree in the most part - but he trades live and has done for a long time, a good watch, a sensible guy and comes across well on his trading/videos etc - he's also selling his services so I do agree a fair amount of caution is required.
He's decent on his streams, shows what he's doing, show his winners and looser as well. I've followed him for a while now.
I was following him too, but reading reviews scared me off. There's good stuff on his channel no doubt but people seem to be split between him being legit, complete fraud (not actually trading real money on stream) and using his followers to pump and dump low market cap/low float stocks. I also read that people have done some investigation into his trades and weren't able to find corresponding orders in the level 2 market data. On the other hand I did see that he has at least some audited trades on his site...
It could just be the typical negativity that surrounds anyone who's successful I guess. I really hope this is the case because I enjoy his videos and his presenting style. The small account challenge series he did is great.
Another I've started following is 'stockjock' on twitch. He doesn't sell services as far as I know and streams all his trades each day. He's a lot less talkative though.