Pretend new forum posters

Soldato
Joined
3 May 2012
Posts
9,912
Location
Wetherspoons
I read these forums a lot, waaaaaaay more than I post, but then I try to stay out of some of the topics as they end up, well as anyone who is a regular here, you know.

Anyway, I have noticed a trend over the last 6 months or so, may have been going longer, but posts by new forum accounts, that have similar trends, and I would believe to be new made up accounts by existing members/ex-members.

I don't know if it is the same person making these threads, or several people, I would say likely more than one. I also note some of these threads do subsequently get deleted so I guess the mods can see the IP addresses or whatever. Some do not.

Usually the trends are:

Two word forum name
New member
Low post count

More so outside of the hardware area, but I have seen a few in there also. In the hardware area, normally they will post a scenario, and seemingly pretend to be not competant or have a clue what they are talking about, but the dead give away is now and then they will post something that actually you wouldnt know unless you knew what you were doing, little bits here and there. The problem is normally (intentionally I believe) an impossible conundrum that never gets solved.

The majority : the posts outside of the hardware area are normally on the face of it, an innocent enough question, that has the potential to kick off depending on your attitides, a good example of that was a post made about going on holiday with a group of friends during lockdown, the question wasnt specifically about that, but the post alluded to that fact.

But I have seen loads of these recent, and if you read the forums enough, you start to recognise the style of the writing and you can tell its the same person, or small group of people.

But why?

Are these banned accounts?

Do people just like stirring up the forums into policitcally motivated arguements, I mean, I guess that could be funny.

Has anyone else noticed this?

And no, this isnt a subtle way of saying its me doing it.
 
There are a lot of new accounts that appear and start posting seemingly 'innocent' questions and the like....and after a while links start appearing in their posts...hey I found this thing that solved my problem....etc. Mods seem pretty good with the ban hammer for them though.
 
Why would it bother you? it's just a website to chat on?
It's not as if people have just used their free AOL CD to " install the internet " and this is their first time chatting to strangers online?
 
Why would it bother you? it's just a website to chat on?
It's not as if people have just used their free AOL CD to " install the internet " and this is their first time chatting to strangers online?

Yes we know you are a returning user. Just post your original name instead of trying to be witty.
 
Accounts that probably have been banned from certain sub forums and need a new account to access them, usually mods are on the ball with this and can work out who it is pretty quickly and respond in kind.
 
Yeah I noticed it too.

I ended up just assuming it's OCUK staff trying to drum up forum activity that ultimately leads to spending.

Also thought if it was real people they shouldn't be using their real names, which got me wondering if they really signed up for this site or if something else posted on their behalf and then scraped the replies.
 
Cannot say I've noticed, but I guess I am not an regular enough forum member to notice :)

I did laugh / like the idea, of a bot automatically pasting questions from other sites. Then pasting replies back onto their site. Probably a way of somehow making their community / site look active.

Perhaps we should all start responding with "Microsoft staff hate this one weird trick...."
 
You need to worry when multi account users start arguing with themselves.

The only thing I can think of is boredom.

I know what you are saying though. There's lots of people here with multiple accounts.
 
You need to worry when multi account users start arguing with themselves.

You're gonna explode when you realise that it's only you and me on the forum, I'm all the other accounts just arguing with myself all day.

It at least feels a bit like human interaction :(
 
This morning i had a PM from a new random, mods got the hammer out on that one. Advertising some forum, though i never checked out the link. Not had a spam PM on here before, but have noticed lots of random non computer threads about, OP sometimes never responds either.
 
Cannot say I've noticed, but I guess I am not an regular enough forum member to notice :)

I did laugh / like the idea, of a bot automatically pasting questions from other sites. Then pasting replies back onto their site. Probably a way of somehow making their community / site look active.

Perhaps we should all start responding with "Microsoft staff hate this one weird trick...."
I've seen the sort of thing OP has described in the past, and while trolling from returned members or some kind of interactive marketing stunt designed to drive people to a certain link (although I don't really remember links being posted as some kind of resolution or answer to a topic in most cases) is believable I have wondered about bots too.

I see similar things on a different forum I'm in occasionally, and always wonder if the threads are just created to scrape information on niche topics to educate an AI or something like that. I guess just grabbing information to paste elsewhere to make a different site look informative or a forum look more active is a good idea too...

That, or agents from twitter and Facebook are trying to infiltrate the forums to make using them a less satisfying experience to try and get everyone over to their platform :p

I think I just struggle to imagine that anyone gets enough of a kick from starting threads with a believable (and also quite banal a lot of the time) premise purely to waste everyone's time. I'm probably underestimating how petty and mean some people can be I guess :p
 
and always wonder if the threads are just created to scrape information on niche topics to educate an AI or something like that.

I've spotted some instances where I'm pretty sure they are scraping information for magazine/online articles, etc. there are definitely some who are being a bit more subtle with the marketing - as they persistently don't accept/throw up exceptions to solutions and go around and around for a bit before *suddenly* coming to a product which gives them a solution then repeat that solution a few times.
 
Back
Top Bottom