Crazy thread is crazy. I'll put up accurate info, because who has time to purposely reset to get inaccurate data to win the internet?
My old 530d, over 36k
It was actually very accurate even when compared to OBC. In my notes on fuelly, I logged the tank average as well as average speed, and fuel used. Usually the results logged manually were within 1 mpg of results from the OBC.
My Alhambra over 13k tracked miles:
The OBC isn't quite as accurate on here. Probably around 5% off compared to manual figures. But I don't use it the same way, since the trip resets after a few hours of inactivity.
My Edition 30. Over around 3500 miles, so not yet meeting the 5,000 mile requirement, but still interesting none the less.
Some of my older cars:
My old B5.5 Passat 1.9 TDI 130 over 5,000 miles:
One of my Range Rovers (4.6 V8) over 2,000 miles:
My old 335d over 17,000 miles.