When i got part of a ceiling plastered and they left with the entire ground floor of my house covered in plaster splashes and residue, yes I complained.
If an alloy wheel scratch required me to be on my knees with my nose against the wheel to see the scratch, no I wouldn't!
I think you underestimate how easy that would be to see imo. Even in the first pic it looks a little bent down there and the gap isn't uniform, it's certainly far from a clean fit like the bottom left. I think it would probably annoy me. That's the beauty of it all though, everybody is different.
TBH the alloy wheel analogy is probably a bad one. I've had fitters take a chunk of paint of of a wheel and tbh didn't really care. What does it matter when every panel is spent?