• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

Gigabyte z68xp UD4 or Asus P8z68 V-Pro

wam7 said:
I was hoping to get the v1.3 of the Gigabyte Z68XP UD4 which is shown on their UK web site. It's basically there Gen3 board supporting PCI-E 3.0. Nobody seems have them in stock, so I called Gigabyte UK and spoke to a guy in technical services who had not long been in touch with their head office.

According to him they won't be releasing the v1.3 in the U,K and it will be Asia only. I was a little incredulous as to how true this would turn out to be but he said quite a few resellers had contacted him asking the same question and this was the answer he was giving them. Hmm.
H'mm well they have them in the USA, I bet their is that much stock of revision 1.0 in Europe and thats why maybe.

http://www.overclock.net/t/1152889/gigabyte-ga-z68xp-ud3p-rev-1-3
 
Does anyone know off the top of their head if either of these boards have voltage read out points?
 
stulid said:
Damn, I wonder if every board is the same as each other really in terms of voltage read outs? i.e. same motherboards, are they calibrated the same, if so could just go by someone elses findings.

The good thing about these MSI motherboards is I have my board in my case, attach the wires at whatever voltage points no problem, I doubt I could do this with these boards. :(

I can't decide over trying the Gigabyte Z68XP UD4 or Asus P8Z68 V-Pro, lol. :(

Has anyone actually had both boards and know which one clocks better?
 
stulid said:
Let you into a secret, Wam7 is sending his ASUS back for a Gigabyte UD4P
lol, I think I'm going to go for the Gigabyte GA-Z68XP-UD4, pity their not fully Gen 3 but I'll be buying X77 later next year anyway so no big deal.

I can't stand ASUS, I have been terrorised by their RMA procedure when I had an AMD Athlon Asus A8V Deluxe, never even got the board back!
 
Last edited:
I've just been having a look for the Gigabyte GA-Z68XP-UD5, not a lot of places have stock and on the Gigabyte website their is no Rev 1.3, I'm guessing their stopping production and concentrating on the UD3P and UD4.
stulid said:
It was quite funny, usually I get private emails from people asking for specs etc, but this one just went something like "Hi Stu, what board do you use? I'm going to send this ASUS **** back tomorrow"


To continue, this just popped up - http://forums.overclockers.co.uk/showthread.php?p=20592483#post20592483
lol, I've seen quite a few issues with these ASUS motherboards on various forums for the P67/Z68 chipsets, definitly not going to take the risk.
 
Theres no "P" in the UD5 name at OCUk;) also no display connector and thus no Lucid/Quicksync.
 
Last edited:
Another sad little thing to note is the "B3" in the Z68 board name, this was to reassure buyers that there was no SATA bug (despite no Z68 ever being affected) in the early stages of the chipsets life, now that this SATA issue is dead and buried, the later Z68 boards dropped the "B3"

For example the early UD5,
http://www.gigabyte.eu/products/product-page.aspx?pid=3848#ov

And the newer,
http://www.gigabyte.eu/products/product-page.aspx?pid=3909#ov

So do try and get the newer UD5 with the "P" and Lucid/quicksync (whether if you use them or not)
 
Last edited:
stulid said:
Theres no "P" in the UD5 name;) also no display connector and thus no Lucid/Quicksync.
Their is a P version though, but none of the obvious places where people would look have any in stock it's as if Gigabyte have ceased production?

I was just reading this the other day: http://www.hardwarecanucks.com/foru...te-z68xp-ud5-lga-1155-motherboard-review.html

I was tempted last week to buy the Gigabyte Z68X-UD5, but I have no backup graphics card, my intention is to sell my graphics card a few weeks before Keplar is released, hopefully get around £300 for my card so it wont cost much upgrading.

Wish I had ordered the Gigabyte GA-Z68XP-UD4 earlier today, will have to wait till Monday before I can go crackers with it. :(
 
Well as it's no longer a secret ;) I have sent my Asus P8Z68 V-pro back. I thought I'd give it a try as I got it for a *really* good price but after having it for a week I have decided to go with either the Gigabyte Z68XP UD4 or the Z68X UD5 which is on one week only here so makes it slightly cheaper than than the UD4.
Just wish OcUK had the XP version as that would make my choice easier. As I could make use of the VGA and quick sync feature.

The Asus is a nice board but I needed too much voltage to keep my 2600k at 5Ghz (1.46) and I know the previous owner could do it at 1.35 with a UD5. Added to that there were some other quirks that reminded me why I moved away from Asus to Gigabyte for my Q6600. Capacitor whine which was driving me crazy, no WOL (Wake on Lan) which is really handy for me and my USB Keyboard was often not recognised resulting in me having to unplug and plug it back it. (I was using latest bios)

The UEFI bios looks good but my major criticism is that I have to jump between at least two different menu's to overclock. Give me a good old blue bios where the things I have to change are on one page. Besides, once I've spent the first week fine tuning I hardly go in the bios again! Added to that, I had to do a CMOS clear a couple times which I wouldn't have to do on the Gigabyte.

Only choice now is XP UD4 or X UD5. The UD5 has 20 power phases to the 16 of the UD4 which in theory means a more stable overclock but at the expense of the iGPU.
 
Last edited:
Yes but how does it overclock?

I'm not an overclocking fan,infact bit of a noob overclocker, however I had my 2500k up to 4.6 GHz on auto voltage via BIOS but put it at 4.4 GHz which I'm more then happy with.

I'm sure it could go a lot higher since it passes the Intel stress burn test at 4.6 but being bit scared about damaging my CPU long term I did not bother going any higher lol...
Anyway loving my board and no still issues :)...I should say using Corsair A50 cooler with MX4 paste(temps idle are 29c up to 70c max with Intel Stress test on highest setting).

It's one board that's not going back ;).
 
Last edited:
What is swinging it for me for the Asus P8Z68 V motherboards is you can use Offset with LLC on there boards for definate which would mean no Vdroop.

Now if I use Gigabytes DVID/Offset in 'Normal' mode, LLC cannot be used? so I'm guessing this will have huge Vdroop?

Hard to get a definate answer on this. :(
 
stulid said:
Would you like me to turn on the pc and check?
Sure, see with my current 2500K I can get this:

4.6GHz = 1.384v load (prime95), 1.408v load (IBT 2.56) 1.01v to 1.06v idle. (Auto CPU Voltage)
4.6GHz = 1.280v load (prime95), 1.280v load (IBT 2.56) 1.296v idle. (Manual CPU Voltage = 1.30v BIOS)

With MSI motherboards, I can use Auto CPU Voltage with "Low VDroop setting' but with my VID being high at 4.6GHz i.e 1.4111v at load, I would like Offset so need an Asus or Gigabyte if it works properly to run at 1.280v with power saving features enabled, but if their is huge Vdroop then I'll have to run it at a higher voltage.
 
stulid said:
Give me an hour or so to fit a drive and install an OS/programs etc.
Okay thanks, knowing my luck your 2500K will probally have a vid of 1.280V at 4.6GHz lol. :(
 
Back
Top Bottom