• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

evga 650i nforce vs gigabyte GA_P35_DS3R

Associate
Joined
6 Sep 2007
Posts
178
Hi

Afrter some good recommendation from this forum I was just about to get an evga 650i nforce board to overclock an e2180 - when I saw the Gigabyte GA_P35_DS3R which costs a bit more but looks a better buy (has built in e-sata) I think maybe Im just attracted to the better brand name.

Any comments on this board vs the evga?

thanks

Masten
 
the p35 chipset clocks a lot better than the 650i and supports penryn, it is worth going for the gigabyte board over any nvidia board atm unless you need SLI
 
Ok, thanks

Could you tell me the difference between the different versions of the board

- Gigabyte GA_P35_DS3R
- Gigabyte GA_P35C_DS3R
- Gigabyte GA_P35_DS3P

Also will it work with this memoery

http://www.overclockers.co.uk/showproduct.php?prodid=MY-030-GL&groupid=701&catid=8&subcat=

I looked on he web-site and it says it works with Geil (GX22GB5300DC) which is a slightly different no. to this one.

No I dont need Sli, just something easy for a beginner to overclock an e2180 to about 2.66Ghz really.

thanks
 
P35-DS3R is DDR2 & uses a cut down PCB
P35C-DS3R basically as above but can use either DDR2 or DDR3
P35-DS3P is based on the same PCB as the DS4 & DQ6 so it's full size & adds firewire & a 2nd x16 physical (x4 electrical slot).

When the DS3P is the same price as the DS3R as it is on OcUK imo it's a no brainer to get the DS3P.
 
Can the gigabyte boards independently change the memory and processor speeds like the evga nforce 650i (not that Ill ever probably do that!)
 
oh right - is that a big disadvantage would you say or not really worth worrying about. I guess Im looking for simplicity as this is my first self build and overclocking attempt. (have an e2180 I want to clock to 2.66Ghz)
 
Nope it's not a disadvantage, and even less so with an E2180 since it has the x10 multiplier.
 
The DS3 has the JMicron RAID, but not the Intel RAID. Tho that makes little difference tbh.
 
the p35 chipset clocks a lot better than the 650i and supports penryn, it is worth going for the gigabyte board over any nvidia board atm unless you need SLI

The EVGA 650i is the Ultra version - it supports Penryn and it doesn't have SLi. It clocks just as well as the Gigabyte and it's better featured for general use. If you want eSATA though, the Gigabyte is a decent board.
 
How does the p31 chipset compare to the p35? Considering a gigabyte p31 for a budget system against a p35, should I just spend the extra on a p35? Looking to clock an E2180 and currently in the process of buying the kit.
 
Depends on the price. You can pick up a P35-DS3 for ~£60 and it's worth the extra tenner.
 
I'm happy with my 650i. Was cheap and have my 2180 sitting at 3Ghz no problems. Only criticism is there was no included manual. Thankfully I'm comp literate, so for a beginner it would be daunting.
 
I'm happy with my 650i. Was cheap and have my 2180 sitting at 3Ghz no problems. Only criticism is there was no included manual. Thankfully I'm comp literate, so for a beginner it would be daunting.

The manual is available as a pdf on the cd or it can be downloaded from the ASUS website.
 
Back
Top Bottom