HD Camcorder, HDV, MiniDV - confused!

Soldato
Joined
6 Sep 2005
Posts
3,781
Hi guys

What's the easiest way of transferring HDV camcorder tapes onto the hard drive?

I would have thought that a camcorder like the Canon HV30 would do the job but that says it takes MiniDV tapes even though it records in 1080i.

Is HDV a different format to MiniDV or more of a branding exercise? Even Canons top of the range 'camcorders' use MiniDV so I'm a bit confused over what HDV is and what would use it when :confused:

Many thanks in advance for any pointers!
 
The HD video cams on the market use one of four mediums: (all produce the same end result)

HDD - hardrive cam,
pros- no media to carry/lose, longest continuous recording time. easy transfer to any pc via usb.
cons - no removable medium (if you do fill it, it is full until you get to a pc), heaviest of the three types and usually the largest. Mosty use AVCHD codec that can be a pain to edit and transfer with buggy software.

MiniDV - these are becoming more rare, the first 2/3 generations were only this format, often the media is branded as HD DV tapes, but any mini dv tape works (the more expensive ones simply have a ECC circuit and larger buffer on the tape iirc)
pros - lighter than HDD cams, changable media.
cons - only 90mins per tape, tranfer to pc via Firewire+video capture software only

DVD - AVOID! - stupidly short recording time on each disk in the highest quality, power hungry too

Memory stick cams (self explanitory)
pros - small, lightweight, longest battery life - memory has no moving parts
cons - usually use the same AVCHD codec the same as the HDD cams do, memory sticks limited to 16GB atm, but thats still a fair quantity of footage.
 
Last edited:
What's the easiest way of transferring HDV camcorder tapes onto the hard drive?

use a free prog called HDVsplit

VERY simple, the resulting file will play one a pc using vlc media player or even on a ps3...
 
Back
Top Bottom